Antique Pie Safe For Sale

Must Try

Amish Pie Safe Cabinets By Brandenberry

Whitewashed Antique Pie Safe

Pie safe cabinets from Brandenberry Amish Furniture present a great way to let your pies and other baked goods cool off while their aroma permeates the dining room. And because its a throwback to yesteryear, the antique pie safe cabinet that graces you home is sure to be a great conversation piece. Plus it will serve as a timeless item of beauty.

Amish craftsmen custom build each pie safe cabinet. And they use solid Midwestern hardwoods. Like cherry, maple, oak and hickory. So with good care, your pie safe should supply delightful aromas to your family for generations to come.

Also, we have several custom options available. Everything from wood species to different stains and finishes to a range of hardware. Plus, you can go for doors with wood, copper or glass panels. So the pie cabinet you customize will be uniquely yours.

To see first-hand what makes our pie safe cabinets so special, visit our brick-and-mortar store in Shipshewana, Indiana!

The Mechanics Of Pie Safes

Generally, pie safes were made from local wood. Often, pine and other soft woods were used for shelves, drawers, and interior pieces, while a nicer, more expensive wood was used for the exterior areas. Pine was especially popular in the southern states.

Inside the cabinet were shelves to hold pies and other foods. There would be screening or punched tin designs in the top, sides, doors, or a combination of these. The screen allowed the baked goods to have ventilation while keeping rodents, flies, and hungry children at bay. The ventilation helped the food to stay cooler and to keep it from molding easily.

Some kitchen safes had tops that opened upward, while others had a combination of doors and drawers. There were even pie safes that were a combination safe and jelly cupboard. The pieces would be made to either the whim of the cabinet maker or the specifications of the lady of the house.

History Of The Pie Safe

Pie Safes have been used for hundreds of years to store a lot more than just pies! Pies, cakes, breads and all other types of baked goods were stored in pie safes. Storing the baked goods away in the pie safe kept them safely away from pests and helped the baked goods last longer.

The ventilated punched tin door panels that are popular on many styles were used to circulate air in the wood cabinet and also keep out bugs, dirt and of course, hungry kids. Learn More

You May Like: Campbells Chicken Pot Pie Recipe With Pie Crust

Expected Lifespan Of A Pie Safe

The pie safe is quite durable and sturdy, and its no surprise that many units built hundreds of years ago are still standing. To keep your pie safe in good shape for as long as possible, youll need to take certain precautions:

  • Keep the unit away from direct sunlight and areas that may be prone to sudden changes in temperature. If its placed too close to a heat source, such as an oven, the pie safe is at risk for splintering, peeling, and having the wood dry out and possibly crack.
  • Apply a bit of lemon oil. When done routinely, this is a great way to keep your safe in good condition. offers a number of different types and styles of pie safes. You can find a jelly cabinet or cupboard with one or two doors, or a charming arts and crafts pie safe with copper accents or glass doors.

We have many different safes crafted from high-quality wood, such as oak, maple and cherry. We offer larger safes with ample storage space, as well as smaller ones that fit nicely into tinier places.

Sign up for our email newsletter or view our solid wood chests and similar pieces of furniture to learn more about our varied selection.

What Determines The Value Of An Antique Pie Safe


As with any antique item, the value of an antique kitchen safe will be determined by a number of things, including:

  • Originality – Unique characteristics always add value to a piece. Unusual height, width, materials, or decoration can increase or decrease a piece’s worth.
  • Unrestored – Original paint and hardware are valued by most collectors. For instance, one seller chose to keep their 19th century chest-of-drawers sized pie safe in its primitive condition, and it still sold for $875.
  • Provenance – Provenance comes into play if the piece has been owned by an important historical figure or has a unique story attached to it.
  • Condition – Condition will always be important in determining the value of a piece. Take these two pie safe sides, for example. They were in a relatively significant state of disrepair, and they still sold for just over $200. This proves that pie safes are, like with almost all furniture, worth a substantial amount of money.
  • – Demand depends a lot on where you live and whether collectors are looking for what you have.

Ultimately, as is the case with most hand-crafted furniture, you can expect to pay several thousand dollars for a late 19th century pie safe, and several hundred for a 20th century safe.

Recommended Reading: Bean Pie My Brother

Proudly Handcrafted In America By Amish Woodworkers

Each Amish pie safe on DutchCrafters is handcrafted by highly recognized woodworkers. Pie safes are held to the highest standards of craftsmanship, and as they are intricately handcrafted, they are inspected for material defects throughout the build process. Additionally, Amish hand-craftsmanship ultimately results with ecological benefits as these methods require very low energy consumption and Amish craftsmen put every scrap of wood to use for agricultural purposes!

Pie Safe Cupboard: What Is It What Is It Worth

A relative gave me this pie safe a number of years ago. Is mine an important example of this type of furniture?


Pie safes were cupboards used to hold food of all types, and punched-tin panels allowed air to circulate inside while keeping bugs and other pests out. Your pie safe was made circa 1900 and has machine-punched panels. Collectors prefer safes from the 19th century that have hand punching. The finish on the cupboard has been stripped of its original patina, and this adversely affects the value.

Valued at: $1,500

*The estimates provided are preliminary only and subject to change based on firsthand inspection and further research. Appraisal prices refer to an item’s fair market value, or what one might expect to pay for an object of similar age, size, color, and condition at auction.

Recommended Reading: Churchs Chicken Apple Pie

Antique Pie Safe For Sale

Browse TODAY’s SELECTED Antique Pie Safe for SALE, BEST OFFER and Auction. FIND 1000’s of Antiques, Art, Vintage & RARE Collectors’ items offered for sale by antique centres, dealers and collectors. Plus Antique Pie Safe Appraisals, FREESales Advice, FREE Price Guide, Sale Prices, Values, Wish list and more…

Art, Antiques, Mid-Century, Vintage & RARE Collectors’ items…
TIP! SearchAntique, Vintage, RARE, Collectable, Collectors, Classic, Fine, Unusual, Early, Old, etc to help you find more antique pie safe..
4d 12h 33m
Price: 145.00
5d 4h 49m
Price: 79.00
6d 2h 43m
Price: 210.00
7d 3h 19m
Price: 74.99
7d 3h 30m
Price: 64.99
7d 19h 56m
Price: 300.00
8d 1h 44m
Price: 69.99
8d 3h 53m
Price: 165.00
8d 11h 47m
Price: 42.99
9d 20h 47m
Price: 79.95
10d 2h 39m
Price: 29.98
10d 5h 26m
Price: 23.75
10d 8h 2m
Price: 18.00
10d 8h 12m
Price: 18.00
13d 12h 49m
Price: 98.00
13d 15h 48m
Price: 78.04
14d 12h 38m
Price: 299.00
18d 2h 5m
Price: 99.00
18d 12h 12m
Price: 55.00
19d 8h 42m
Price: 139.99
20d 1h 58m
Price: 150.00
20d 5h 30m
Price: 375.00
20d 11h 14m
Price: 99.99
21d 22h 6m
Price: 98.00
22d 4h 52m
Price: 35.00
22d 11h 41m
Price: 129.00
24d 1h 38m
Price: 79.78
26d 1h 5m
Price: 75.00
26d 8h 15m
Price: 48.89
26d 8h 16m
Price: 54.98
26d 8h 16m
Price: 34.89
26d 8h 16m
Price: 28.98
26d 8h 16m
Price: 28.98
SEARCH 1,000,000’s of items for SALE, BEST OFFER& Auction… register for FREE Update Alerts of Antique Pie Safe for Sale!
0 Bids

Buy Sell & Value Antique Pie Safe

My newest project- Old Pie Safe

TODAY’s SELECTEDFOR SALEvaluationsale adviceprice/value guidesale priceskeywords1,000,000’s of Antiques, Art, Vintage and RARE Collectors’ items… What do you collect?

SEARCH 1,000,000’sof Antiques, Art, Mid-Century, Vintage & RARE Collectors’ items…
…for enjoyment, investment, a Special Event, Birthday or Anniversary Gift!

You May Like: Church’s Chicken Apple Pie

What Is A Pie Safe

The pie cabinet was most likely introduced to the United States by the German people who immigrated to the Pennsylvania region and later became known as the Pennsylvania Dutch. Despite the name, pie safes were used for more than pies. Everything from bread to cake was kept in a pie cupboard, and it was an important piece of furniture. They were generally composed of a tall and narrow cabinet made of pine, although other woods might be used, and were freestanding so that they could be moved easily if necessary. The pie safe was generally kept as far from the wood stove as possible to keep the food safe from too much heat. On the farm, it might even have been kept on the back porch, next to the dry sink, to catch as much cool air as possible.

Buy Sell & Value Pie Safe

TODAY’s SELECTEDFOR SALEvaluationsale adviceprice/value guidesale priceskeywords1,000,000’s of Antiques, Art, Vintage and RARE Collectors’ items… What do you collect?

SEARCH 1,000,000’sof Antiques, Art, Mid-Century, Vintage & RARE Collectors’ items…
…for enjoyment, investment, a Special Event, Birthday or Anniversary Gift!

Recommended Reading: Campbells Chicken Pot Pie With Pie Crust

Variation Among Pie Safes

All pie safes are made out of wood, but theres a significant amount of variation between pie safes in terms of the type of wood thats used to construct the furniture.

Determining the type of wood used to make the pie safe is a great way to get an idea of which region it is from:

  • Yellow pine. This was the most common type of wood used by cabinet makers from Virginia and the Carolinas.
  • Soft pine. In New England and Pennsylvania, soft pine was the most frequently used type of wood.
  • Spanish cedar wood. Most pie safes in Texas were crafted from this type of wood.
  • Cherry and curly maple. While less commonly used, cherry and curly maple were also used to make pie safes. Its rare to find a pie safe made from either type of wood in any region.

Many pie safes were crafted from available local wood. If the furniture was intended for use in a common area in the home, it might receive a quick coat of paint to freshen up its appearance.

Soft wood, such as pine, was commonly used to construct the safes shelves and drawers. In some cases, this wood was used to build the entire safe.

Among more upscale households, it was not uncommon for certain types of local hardwood, including hickory, chestnut, and maple, to be used for exterior surfaces.

How Big A Slice Of Cash Is Antique Pie Safe Worth

Used Antique Pie Safe for sale in Marietta

Question: I bought this unusual cupboard at a country auction many years ago. It is wood with 12 punched tin panels and tulip and star designs. I have it in my kitchen and use it for storing cooking utensils. Because I am moving to a retirement home, I wont have room for it and need to sell it. Can you tell me what it was used for, as well as its age and value?

Answer: Your cabinet is an antique pie safe dating back to the 19th century. The cuts in the tin panels allowed air to circulate through the storage area. While such pieces were made around the country, the most elaborate examples were done in Pennsylvania by German craftsmen. The pieces were cut from patterns and a design was drawn on a sheet of tin plate. Cuts were made with a hammer on a chisel.

Your pie safe could sell at auction for more than $1,000. Get some professional advice on reputable auction galleries in your area.

Do you have an antique item and need more information? For a personal reply, send a photo, history, size, and any signatures with a self-addressed stamped envelope and $25 to Anne Gilbert-Strawbridge, 1811 Renaissance Commons Blvd., #2-319, Boynton Beach, FL 33426.

Also Check: Key Lime Pie Co

Determining The Value Of A Pie Safe

As with most pieces of furniture, there are a number of factors that can help determine the value of a piece. Since the introduction of the ice box, the pie safe has historically been purchased and used more as a design piece than an actual storage solution for pies and other goods.

If you have your eye on a pie safe or are considering listing your pie safe for sale, its a good idea to know which factors are typically considered the most influential when determining its value.

Some of the most crucial components when it comes to figuring out the value of a pie safe include the following:

Professional appraiser, Helaine Fendelman, examined a pie safe cupboard from before 1900 and suggested that collectors typically prefer units from the 19th century with hand punching, rather than machine-punched panels. The value is negatively impacted if the cupboards finish has been altered from its original state.

Popular Recipes

More Recipes Like This