Southern Baked Pie Company Georgia
Salted Caramel Turtle Pie
Founded in Gainesville, Georgia in 2012, Southern Baked Pie Company was launched by Amanda Wilbanks. Based on treasured family recipes and an all-butter pie dough that melts in your mouth, Amanda and her team of bakers create gourmet sweet and savory pies in a variety of sizes including: whole 10-inch pies, petite 5-inch pies, and bite-size tassies. Not sure which pie to buy? Their signature French Coconut Custard Pie was featured on the Today Show. No matter what you order, you cant go wrong.
Best Peach Pie: Harry & David
For a pie with bright, fruit-forward flavors, try this deep-dish option from Harry & David. The country-style peach and berry pie is filled with peaches, blueberries, and raspberries in a crisp pastry shell. Instead of a double crust or lattice top, the pie is generously sprinkled with a cinnamon-and-sugar streusel, making for a dessert that’s too beautiful to eat.
To buy: Peach and Berry Pie, $40 harryanddavid.com
Best Apple Pie: Little Pie Company
Founded by a Broadway actor in 1985, this pastry shop in New York City quickly became a highly acclaimed location to find delicious handmade pies. Three decades later, Little Pie Company continues to make irresistible pies in an array of flavors, receiving accolades from food critics and loyal customers alike. One of its most popular offerings is the sour cream apple walnut pie, which folds brown sugar and cinnamon in amongst layers of Granny Smith apple slices.
To buy: Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie, $69 goldbelly.com
Don’t Miss: Chicken Pot Pie With Campbell’s Cream Of Mushroom Soup
Best Caramel Apple Pie: Blue Owl Bakery
Wow your Thanksgiving dinner guests with this gravity-defying apple pie from Blue Owl Bakery. The Levee high caramel pecan apple pie is approximately 9 inches tall, filled with 18 hand-peeled Golden Delicious apples, and topped with a caramelly made-from-scratch crust. It arrives fully assembled and ready to bake in your own oven, so you can enjoy the heavenly smells that’ll waft through your kitchen as it bakes. Plus, Oprah named the Levee high caramel pecan apple pie one of her favorite things in 2011, so you know it’s bound to be delicious. The pie serves 10â12 people, so there’ll be plenty to share with Thanksgiving guests.
To buy: Levee High Caramel Pecan Apple Pie, $109 goldbelly.com
Best For All Key Lime Products: Kermits Key West Key Lime Shoppe
Kermits Key West Key Lime Shoppe
Why We Chose It: Kermits Key West Key Lime Shoppe delivers its key lime pie and a variety of other key lime products to homes nationwide.
-
Assortment of key lime products
-
Variety of flavors of pie and pie bars
-
Gluten-free pie crust available
-
High shipping costs
Kermits Key West Key Lime Shoppe is the place to shop for anything and everything related to key limes. Its key lime pie has been featured on the Food Network. Kermits makes a classic version with real key lime juice, a graham cracker crust , and fluffy whipped cream, along with two flavored versions: strawberry and coconut. A single, 9-inch key lime pie is priced at $38.95 plus overnight shipping costs.
In addition to key lime pies, Kermits sells an assortment of frozen key lime pie bars such as regular key lime pie dipped in dark chocolate and strawberry key lime pie dipped in white or dark chocolate. A variety of key lime cookies, key lime peanuts, key lime fudge, key lime liqueur cake, and more are also available for purchase from the online shop. Kermit’s pies, pie bars, and fudge are also available for sale on Goldbelly. An added bonus: Kermits Key West Key Lime Shoppe is a disabled veteran-owned small business and regularly supports local organizations in its shops communities.
Don’t Miss: Bean Pie Recipe Muhammad Speaks
Vanilla Salted Caramel Cake By Ovenly $79 From Goldbelly
Ovenly via Goldbelly
For those looking to go beyond classic pie offerings during the holidays, Ovenlys Vanilla Salted Caramel Cake will fit the bill. The key is a double dose of caramel, whipped into the buttercream and drizzled on top that makes this sweet treat an absolute showstopper. But dont miss their perfect pumpkin olive oil loaf either.Buy Now
An Indulgent Cold Treat For Cookie Lovers
Goldbelly
Want to offer a cold treat for your guests? This pie is filled with cookie dough ice cream for a little slice of heaven. The pie is layered with a graham cracker crust, cookie dough ice cream, hot fudge, cookie dough bites and a chocolate chip cookie on top. The best part? You can just pull it out of your freezer and serve.
Don’t Miss: Pienation
Best Fudge Pie: Collin Street Bakery
Though this Corsicana, Texas-based bakery is world famous for its holiday fruitcakes, Collin Street Bakery also makes a mean chocolate fudge pie. This dessert is made with whole eggs and semi-sweet chocolate, then baked inside a deep-dish crust until the top takes on the crackly consistency of a brownie. Try the original chocolate fudge pie, or order a deep-dish fudge pecan pie that’s been topped with toasted pecans to combine two classic holiday sweets into one.
To buy: Fudge Pie, from $22 collinstreet.com
Top 10 Gourmet Mail Order Dessert Pies In 2022
359learn more
Apple? Cherry? Pecan? The choice is yours.
Youll see the top ten pies that can be ordered online and delivered to your doorstep. They pretty much ship any doorstep in America, so all you have to do is decide which one is your favorite.
In A Rush?Blueberry Pie Cherry Crumb PiePecan Pie
All the pies featured in this top ten list are best selling and top rated. That means they are all tried and tested.
So lets dig in and see this epic list of internet-orderable sweet dessert pies.
Another American classic, this bountiful blueberry pie by Bake Me A Wish!
This pie features fresh blueberries and a buttery golden crust. Its a sweet and simple recipe thats always a family favorite.
The blueberry pie will serve between 6 and 8 people and is certified Kosher. Bake Me A Wish! will ship this pie to you overnight in refrigerated packaging for maximum freshness.
This would be a great pie to gift as Bake Me A Wish adds the option to select an occasion like birthday, best wishes or sympathy and includes a gift box and even a greeting card for a final touch.
BUY: Check out more information on Bake Me A Wish! and order your own blueberry pie on their website here.
Bloomberg voted this pie Best Mail Order Pie in America.
Thats quite a title.
Ever had a Texas pecan pie? Think bigger, gooier, yummier, richer and more decadent than any other pecan pie on the planet.
Equally good and equally delish.
Don’t Miss: Individual Chicken Pot Pie Recipe To Freeze
San Diego Chicken Pie Shop
San Diego, CaliforniaHave you ever chomped into a juicy carnitas burrito outside a taco truck late at night and thought, you know, this would be so much better if the tortilla was a pie? Of course you havent. That’s a highly specific thought to have… unless youve been to the San Diego Chicken Pie Shop, in which case, that’s your nostalgia talking. The shop will gladly ship you an eight-pack of the show-stopping chicken pot pies for about $60, but might we recommend splitting that order to include four of the pitch-perfect chicken numbers and four of the carnitas version, which come packed with the succulent, fatty pork. Will it forever render a carnitas burrito insufficient? Nah. Will it make you ponder stuffing barbacoa, birria, or lengua into a crust? Absolutely.
Amaretto Pear From Windowsill Pies: New Orleans
Started by two female baking entrepreneurs, this NOLA pie shop takes into account the history of the city and uses the French and Southern influences to bake picture-worthy pies. The Amaretto Pear and Dried Cherry pie is almost too beautiful to eat with the delicate lattice of autumn leaves, but the flavors are an equal work of art combining Lazzaroni amaretto-soaked dried cherries with succulent ripe pears and enough nutmeg and lemon zest to draw out the fruit.
Don’t Miss: Damgoode Pies River Market
Sugar Cream Hoosier Sugar Pie By My Sugar Pie $28
My Sugar Pie
If youre not familiar with the Hoosier Pie, it might just be the best thing to come out of Indiana aside from Larry Bird and David Letterman. It doesnt get much better than My Sugar Pies version which keeps things traditional with the trinity of butter, sugar, and cream. Its the kind of slice that after taking one bite youll be asking, Where have you been all my life? Buy Now
Best Key Lime Pie: Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shop
As the weather gets cooler, take your taste buds on vacation off the coast of Florida with the help of this delicious Key lime pie. Located on the historic Key West Bight, Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shop is renowned for its key lime pies with delightful graham cracker crust and tart, fluffy filling. The pies are made using the shop’s famous Key lime juice and dolloped with whipped cream for a light dessert that’s just as beautiful as it is delicious.
To buy: Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Pie, $79 goldbelly.com
Also Check: Damgoode Pies Fayetteville
Dutch Apple By Julian Pie Company $2095
The Smothers Family knows a thing or two about apple pie. Not only do they continue to run the Julian Pie Company, the Southern California institution which they founded over 32 years ago, they even bought their own apple orchard. Not surprisingly, apples find their way into nearly all of the bakerys pies, but the Dutch version, which features a crunchy crumb topping, is a standout. Buy Now
Derby Pie From Kern’s Kitchen Louisville
A trademarked Kentucky tradition since the 1960s, Derby Pie is a year-round favorite for locals. Kerns Kitchen in Louisville produces the custardy walnut-chocolate dessert from a secret recipe, selling it frozen online and to restaurants and grocery stores in parts of Kentucky, Indiana and Ohio. For the most-authentic experience, pair it with some Kentucky bourbon.
You May Like: Kermits Key Lime Pie On A Stick
Kermit’s Key West Lime Shoppe
If youre craving key lime this holiday season, you might as well go straight to the source. Kermits Key West Lime Shoppe in Key West, Florida, uses ultra-fresh key limes in their pies. The tart goodness sits on top of a crunchy graham cracker crust and is decorated with dollops of whipped cream. Pies start at $79, but you can get free shipping via Goldbelly in time for Christmas.
Four & Twenty Blackbirds Bittersweet Chocolate Pecan Pie $79 From Goldbelly
Goldbelly
This article is intended to bring some relief to the holiday cooking and/or gift-giving process, but lets be honest, trying to decide which incredible dessert to order from Four & Twenty Blackbirds can be stress-inducing. The Brooklyn-based bakery has a number of delicious options including their famed Salty Honey Pie.
But for Thanksgiving, this option takes the traditional pecan pie you know and love to the next level with a generous dose of chocolate ganache and tons of roasty toasty pecans.
Read Also: Rattlesnake Ranch Pecans
A Gooey Dessert With A Decadent Twist
Goldbelly
You dont have to choose between serving cookies or pie this Thanksgiving: You can have both in one. This dessert is packed with all the good stuff you love about gooey chocolate chip cookies, just in pie form. The Tollhouse Pie features a classic chocolate chip cookie recipe in a flaky pie crust. Layers of pecans, chocolate and caramel drizzle make for a next-level dessert thatll have everyone talking.
Hear From Our Happy Customers
We stopped at Bettys near closing time and grabbed two slices of pie to take back to our hotel. The pies were amazing!!!!! We came back the next day for breakfast. Hands down the best breakfast I have ever had in a restaurant! We mad Bettys our morning breakfast stop in our trip and ate pie for lunch each day! Cant wait to go back. Have had to order the cheese cake online cause we couldnt wait. And the banana cream is just as amazing!!!!
We spend the days exploring the winter activities on the North Shore and the nights sitting by the fireplace watching movies, giggling, and having fun. The only thing that could make three nights away from the kids any more special is PIE from Bettys! We stopped in on our first night and bought a pie. A single, delicious, mouth-watering pie. The next day – we went back. And we bought SIX pies. SIX. PIES. There were three of us. You do the math. We had no shame in our pie game!
Don’t Miss: The Original Key Lime Pie Company
Best Pumpkin Pie: Harry & David
No Thanksgiving spread is quite complete without pumpkin pie, and this deep-dish version from Harry & David is so delicious that you’ll be tempted to skip right over the turkey. Made from real pumpkins and baked inside a flaky crust, this enticing pie is topped with whipped cream and dusted in pumpkin pie spice. Harry & David offers express shipping on this classic holiday dessert, making it even easier to ensure your pie arrives in time for the festivities.
To buy: Deep Dish Pumpkin Pie, $60 harryanddavid.com
Chocolate Meringue Pie From Sugaree’s: New Albany Mississippi
This incredible creamy pie is only served on Fridays at the pie shop for good reason: Its a monster to prepare. The filling alone is three pounds, with an additional pound of meringue, piled high into a one-pound butter lard crust thats entirely made by hand. The recipe comes from the owners mom who still helps out in the bakery. The resulting dessert is so big, the staff orders a special box to contain it.
Don’t Miss: Américan Pie Band Camp Trailer
What Are The Ingredients In Key Lime Pie
Traditionally, a key lime pie’s filling consists of key lime juice, egg yolks, and sweetened condensed milk. It typically sits in a graham cracker crust, although it can also be cooked in a more traditional pie crust. It is sometimes served without a topping but often has a light meringue topping made from egg whites or whipped cream. The pie is served chilled.