Best Places To Try Key Lime Pie In Key West
March 29, 2021·In: Florida, USA
Youre in the right place to find the yummiest and best Key Lime Pie in Key West. When youre headed to Key West youve got to make sure to grab a slice of Key Lime Pie . Even if youre usually someone who picks chocolate over fruit-flavored dessert, just try it. Im here to let you know all of the best places for Key Lime Pie in Key West .
I spent an entire summer living, working, and playing in Key West, Florida so Ive got my fair share of amazing recommendations for your trip. I even compiled the ultimate Key West, Florida bucket list with 98 amazing things to do, see and eat- youve got to check it out. Plus, in addition to these mouthwatering places to pick up Key Lime Pie in Key West, there are also loads of other amazing places to eat in Key West you need to add to your itinerary. And for my top tips and tricks, check out my list of 17 things you need to know before visiting Key West, Florida.
*There may be affiliate links in this post. Read my privacy/disclosure policy to learn more.
Whats Key Lime Pie anyways?
So whats the deal with Key Lime Pie? Key Lime Pie is a delicious, creamy pie usually made with Key Lime juice, sweetened condensed milk, and egg yolks . Key Limes which are similar to traditional limes, do vary in taste and are usually more yellow than green in color.
Youll love this post: Ultimate Key West Food Guide | 19 Places You Must Try
What Are The Ingredients In Key Lime Pie
Traditionally, a key lime pie’s filling consists of key lime juice, egg yolks, and sweetened condensed milk. It typically sits in a graham cracker crust, although it can also be cooked in a more traditional pie crust. It is sometimes served without a topping but often has a light meringue topping made from egg whites or whipped cream. The pie is served chilled.
Can I Freeze Homemade Key Lime Pie
You can, actually! Let it sit in the fridge for 4 hours after baking, then wrap the key lime pie tightly in plastic wrap and foil before freezing it. To thaw, set the frozen key lime pie in the fridge overnight.
Note that you should freeze this easy key lime pie plain you can whip up a fresh batch of cream just before serving the pie.
Don’t Miss: Chocolate Covered Key Lime Pie Key West
How To Make Homemade Whipped Cream
- Dont aim for stiff peaks. You want the whipped cream to keep its shape and be soft, billowing peaks. If by chance you OVERBEAT the whipped cream fixing it is actually very easy. Simply add in more fresh heavy whipping cream and whisk by hand. My life was changed when I found that out!
- Wait until peaks start to form before adding in the confectioners sugar. I much prefer confectioners sugar in this recipe, as it dissolves entirely and leaves a smooth texture. If you choose to use granulated sugar be sure to add it immediately at the beginning and whip it with the cream.
- Homemade whipped cream is best used immediately, but it can be stored for up to 10 hours if needed. After that, it may start to separate.
Top the chilled Key Lime Pie with the whipped cream and serve! If you would rather top this pie with a meringue topping, just use the meringue recipe in my Lemon Meringue Pie. Store the pie in the refrigerator, loosely covered with aluminum foil, for up to three days.
To freeze Key Lime Pie, freeze it without the added whipped topping. Place the pie in the freezer for a couple of hours before double wrapping it tightly in plastic wrap. Keep it in a heavy-duty freezer bag. Remember to label and date the wrapping the pie will last for up to a month in the freezer. Thaw the pie in the refrigerator.
Oprahs Favorite Key Lime Bundt Cake
We Take the Cake ships its delicious cakes nationwide on Goldbelly! Oprah chose this unique Key Lime Bundt cake as one of her Favorite Things. If your idea of heaven is divinely moist and dense pound cake kissed with the tangy flavor of Key lime and drizzled with Key lime cream cheese frosting, you will love it too.
We Take The Cake has become one of the most sought after, made-from-scratch bakeries in the US. The team at We Take The Cake understands that its not just about sending a cake. It represents celebration, comfort, appreciation, love, and togetherness, even if you cant be there yourself. They take pride in mixing the batters and frosting from scratch, using whole milk, fresh eggs and real butter, NEVER a cake mix or commercially made frostings.
Don’t Miss: The Key Lime Pie Company
The Best Key Lime Pie In Cape Town
Enjoy the best Key Lime Pie delivery in Cape Town with Uber Eats. Enter your delivery address to browse the Key Lime Pie restaurants available near you. See a Key Lime Pie spot youve never tried? Compare menus, ratings, and prices to help make your selection. Once youve placed your Key Lime Pie order online or on the Uber Eats app, you can track its delivery to your door as you count down the minutes to dig in.
Give The Gift Of Pie: 6 Mail
Dont wrap that ill-fitting, itchy sweater. Instead, give the gift of pie. Unique, regional pies from all over the country pies you couldnt easily make in your kitchen are the holiday gift of choice for Jane and Michael Stern of Roadfood.com. They share their six picks for mail-order pies.
1. Key lime pie, Key West Key Lime Pie Co.Key West, Fla.
The Key West Key Lime Pie Co. will send you a magnificent, true, authentic Key lime pie. Of course you have to get it 2-day service, but this is the classic, real Florida Key lime pie. If you dont like pie, they will also send you Key lime pie bars, which are a slice of Key lime pie enrobed in chocolate and sent to you in dry ice. You can eat Key lime pie chocolate coated on a stick talk about heaven.
The best mince pie we ever had was from the Red Truck Bakery in Warrenton, Va. Its in the most gorgeous part of Virginia. The guy who owns it said, I am on a one-man crusade to resurrect the traditional mince pie. It is the sumptuous, suet-rich pastry with lots of bourbon and sugar. Its just wonderful. This is as luxurious as a pie can be. I dont know how much bourbon is in it, but it really does taste intoxicating.
3. Peanut butter pie, Dans Peanut Butter Pies Newbury Park, Calif., 368-7664
4. Apple pie baked in a paper bag, The Elegant FarmerMukwonago, Wis.
5. Salty honey walnut pie, Three Babes BakeshopSan Francisco
6. Pie-of-the-month plan, Royers Round Top CafeRound Top, Texas
Also Check: Damgoode Pies Little Rock Delivery
Best Key Lime Pie Delivery Services Of 2021
- Best for Overall: Goldbelly
SPRUCE15 for $15 off of minimum $50 spend, first time customers only, excludes shipping, standard T& C applies.
Why We Chose It: Goldbelly offers an assortment of key lime pies and other key lime baked goods from top vendors around the country.
-
Assortment of products and vendors
-
Free shipping included on many orders
-
Delivered frozen for longer shelf life
-
Good customer reviews
-
Free shipping not available on all items
Online gourmet marketplace Goldbelly offers an assortment of key lime pies from around the country. Goldbelly sells items from nearly a dozen other companies that make key lime pies and key lime pie-inspired products. Try key lime cheesecake from Juniors cheesecake in Manhattan, key lime pie jars from Colada Shop, key lime mini pies from Pink Pie, key lime pie ice cream sandwiches, and even Oprahs Favorite Key Lime Bundt Cake. Want to stick to the classic? There are numerous options for purchasing traditional key lime pies from businesses including Little Pie Company, Blue Smoke, Emporium Pies, and more.
My Prize Winning Key Lime Pie Recipe Came Together Quickly So Since I Had Extra Time I Decided To Use Leftover Limes And Make Some Candied Lime Peel Which I Had Actually Thought About Making At Home As My Secret Ingredient But Then Thought Nope Limes Sugar And Water Will Be Thereif I Have Time I Will Make That There So I Can Bring Something That Wont Be
While our pies chilled, we got down to our second challengethe mystery ingredient from the Florida Keys which turned out to be beautiful Yellow Tail Snapper fillets. I had never worked with or eaten it before, however, I am pretty familiar with halibut, so I figured it was similar to cook with.
Ingredients were set out for us to choose from. Things like flour, Panko, mango, tomatoes, breadcrumbs, eggs, spices, herbs and much more. I saw coconut milkand I saw many going for breading or flour as well as mango so I quickly decided to do something I thought no one would do. A curry sauce, similar to one of my favorite ways to prepare halibutTake a look at my recipe for Pan Seared Halibut in Thai Curry Sauce.
I am not talking about using curry powder, instead, a is curry defined as cooking down vegetables and herbs. So I grabbed tomatoes, ginger, onion, etc. I cooked them down and finished the sauce with coconut milk and seasonings. Whatever I could find in that kitchen to give it the flavors I was thinking of in my head, I grabbed. As far as the fish, I simply pan-fried it with seasonings, then sat it atop the sauce I made.
Judges came around and tried each of our dishes as we raised our hands once complete . I kept hearing Gordon Ramsay in my head. Stick to one thingdo it well, taste, taste, taste so thats what I did. Each judge independently tasted and scored our yellow-tail snapper entrée as well as our pie. Then the scores were merged.
Recommended Reading: Bean Pie Recipe Muhammad Speaks
Best Overall: Four And Twenty Blackbirds
Four and Twenty Blackbirds
SPRUCE15 for $15 off of minimum $50 spend, first time customers only, excludes shipping, standard T& C applies.
The New York City pie shop Four and Twenty Blackbirds opened in 2009 when South Dakotans Melissa and Emily Elsen set out to become the city’s best handmade pie bakery. With high-quality ingredients sourced from local orchards, their apple pie is the ideal American dessert, but it’s so satisfying that it can stand alone as its own meal.
The shop’s apple pie is sweetened perfectly with caramel and is salted to enhance flavor, with a classic, lattice-style crust. Alternatively, the salty honey pie is a rich and creamy custard experience that’s sure to satisfy any sweet tooth.
The pies are shipped frozen with ice packs to retain freshness. They are delicious at room temperature and after being warmed in the oven at 250 degrees for 10 to 15 minutes.
Best Iconic Pie: Joes Stone Crab
Joes Stone Crab
Why We Chose It: Joes Stone Crab bakes its classic key lime pie daily and delivers via FedEx Overnight.
-
Good value if ordering multiple pies
-
Only one variety of pie
The iconic Joes Stone Crab in the South Beach district of Miami, Florida, is known for more than stone crabs. Its key lime pie is a signature dessert at the historic establishment that has been around since 1913. Joes Key Lime Pies are baked daily and are available by the slice for locals. For those of us not lucky enough to have Joes Stone Crab in our neighborhood, we can enjoy it as a whole pie via nationwide delivery.
Each 9-inch pie is delivered via FedEx Overnight and will arrive frozen and packed in dry ice. Customers can order up to three pies per order. Because of flat-rate shipping costs, it’s beneficial to order multiple pies at once for the best value while a single pie is $72.95, two pies are $112.95 and three pies are $134.95 . In addition to key lime pie, Joes Stone Crab offers a large selection of other items available for home delivery to round out a delicious meal.
Read Also: Key Lime Pie Shops In Key West
Tips For Making The Best Key Lime Pie
The original recipe calls for a store-bought pie crust, but I always crave a yummy graham cracker crust for this pie. You could buy these little graham cracker pie crusts that Smudge usually uses for her mini key lime pies, but we went the homemade route with this recipe from Sallys Baking Addiction.
The pie crust isnt baked, but refrigerated to meld it all together. To avoid a crumbling crumby crust, the key is to let the pie crust chill for a good long while so it sets up. I found the next day really works best.
I love my new hand crafted cake stand from Brooklyns AHeirloom and couldnt wait to use it for when I eventually make a cake, so it proudly displayed our pie instead. Youll be seeing a whole lot more of it in posts to come.
The Fudge Pie Company Miami Florida
The Signature Fudge Pie $25
The Cookies and Cream Fudge Pie $25
The signature pie of the Fudge Pie Company is exactly what your most intense chocolate cravings would hope for: a smooth, rich, dense, irresistibly chocolate fudge pie baked into a graham cracker crust. The recipe is the brainchild of Chef Stacey Donayre, a graduate of the French Culinary Institute of America who interned at the world-renowned LeCirque restaurant under the tutelage of French pastry chef and chocolatier, Jacques Torres. in short, Chef Donayre knows chocolate.
The Fudge Pie Company also offers delightful seasonal, dense and fudgy versions of pie lovers favorites such as the Key Lime Fudge Pie , the Maple Pecan Fudge Pie, the rich and dense Dulche de Leche Fudge Pie, and we almost hate to tell you about the Cookies and Cream Fudge Pie, becauseOMG. When you order, take our advice and order two. Shipping is the same and they arrive packaged so they can be frozen and remain bakery fresh to enjoy whenever a special dessert is exactly what you crave.
Each 9-inch pie weighs a hefty 2 pounds and serves 12 16.
Read Also: Campbells Soup Chicken Pot Pie
Key Lime Pie Delivery In Nyc
Sweet Street Desserts makes an extraordinary line of scrumptious premium pies that are rated #1 in taste and appearance. If your shopping list includes people with roots in Florida, why not schedule a Key Lime Pie for delivery to your NYC friends, family and business associates and remind them of home?
At Sweet Street Desserts in Reading, PA, weve been known for providing the worlds most delicious desserts since 1979. Our products are served with pride by select restaurants, caterers, coffee bars and gourmet food shops across the country and in 60 countries around the globe.
Our products are celebrated by customers who are looking for great-tasting, high quality gourmet desserts, such as cakes, cupcakes, cheesecakes, dessert bars, brownies and pies. With choices like our luscious Key Lime pie, our Oreo® Cookie Bash pie and our delicate Irish Cream Bash® pie, youre sure to find something to please the taste buds of even the most finicky eater.
If youre looking for a distinctive gift to wow your colleagues and loved ones, or need an exceptional dessert to celebrate your own special event, such as a birthday party, holiday bash, Sunday brunch or wedding, ordering one of our extraordinary desserts will do the trick.