Pumpkin & Cookies Mochi Ice Cream By Mochidoki 4 For $10
Mochidoki
Though not technically a baked good, Mochidokis ice cream stuffed rice cakes are sure to provide a sweet end to any holiday meal. Flavors run the gamut from Black Honey Walnut to Vegan Lychee, but if you want a taste of the holidays, Pumpkin & Cookies cant be beat. This seasonal mochi features pumpkin spice ice cream studded with chocolate and vanilla creme cookies for the ultimate two-bite dessert. For now, shipping is only available around the eastern United States so cross your fingers and make sure your state is on the list. Buy Now
Fall Cookie Set By Southern Sugar Bakery $54
Southern Sugar Bakery
Straight out of North Carolina, this autumnal assortment from Southern Sugar Bakery are mini works of edible art. Along with fall colored leaves, the collection includes plaque cookies with the message Happy Fall Yall to help reinforce that these were indeed baked in the south. Buy Now
Smores Pie By Butter & Scotch $42
Butter & Scotch
This New York bar and bakery had an instant hit when it introduced its Instagram-worthy Smores Pie. A graham cracker crust and creamy chocolate filling provide the foundation to a roasty, toasty marshmallow topping that is oh so addictive. They also have a Bourbon Ginger Pecan Pie for those who want a bite firmly anchored in fall.Buy Now
Also Check: The Key Lime Pie Company
Mamans Nutty Chocolate Chip Cookies 12 For $65
Maman
There is no occasion that wont be improved by chocolate chip cookies, and these beauties from Maman bakery are packed full of dark chocolate chunks and a blend of salted nuts for crunch. They were Oprah-annointed in 2017 and are still a delicious contender for best chocolate chip cookie in NYCbut you can order them from anywhere in the continental U.S.Buy Now
Bien Cuit Pumpkin Bread Pudding With Caramelized White Chocolate $8
Bien Cuit
Having a small Thanksgiving gathering this year? These single-serve bread puddings are the perfect pie alternative. With blonde chocolate, pumpkin, and dulce de leche-soaked pan de mie, these rich, bready bites are a nice break from tradition that still capture the seasonal flavors youre craving. This heavenly bakery is anchored in New York with three locations across Brooklyn and Manhattan but delivers their sweets nationwide.Buy Now
Don’t Miss: Bean Pie Recipe Muhammad Speaks
Kermits Key Lime Pie By Kermits Key West Key Lime Shoppe $3895+
Kermits Key West Key Lime Shoppe
Kermits Key Lime Pie is the best in Key West, or anywhere else for that matter. Local key limes are the key to a bright, tart filling that complements the pies signature graham cracker crust. A ring of whipped cream offers just the right touch of sweetness. Buy Now
Best Chicken Pot Pie: Centerville Pie Co
Centerville Pie Co.
Located on Cape Cod, Centerville Pie Co. has been serving up this homey classic since Laurie Bowen and Kristin Broadley ditched their day jobs as a deputy sheriff and banker to become “The Pie Ladies.” Oprah Winfrey visited the original bakery in the early days, savored the pulled chicken nestled in a doughy-yet-crisp pot pie, and catapulted the shop to fame by including the dish on three of her best-of lists. The pies are carried in many grocery stores on the East Coast, but now, thanks to their nationwide delivery, anyone in the country can get one.
While chicken pot pie may seem like it isn’t worth shipping across a continent, this isnt a make it at home pot pie: the chicken is slow-cooked in a large pot of broth, delicately hand-pulled, and the pie crust is expertly crimped.
Plus, it comes with extra gravy, because we all need a dappling of sauce under our pot pie slice for the real experience. It arrives uncooked, so crank up that oven, bake for 90 minutes, and enjoy the perfect savory flavor.
Also Check: Black Muslim Bean Pie Recipe
Vanilla Salted Caramel Cake By Ovenly $79 From Goldbelly
Ovenly via Goldbelly
For those looking to go beyond classic pie offerings during the holidays, Ovenlys Vanilla Salted Caramel Cake will fit the bill. The key is a double dose of caramel, whipped into the buttercream and drizzled on top that makes this sweet treat an absolute showstopper. But dont miss their perfect pumpkin olive oil loaf either.Buy Now
Maple Wicked Whoopie By Wicked Whoopies 12 For $30
Wicked Whoopies
Amy Bouchard has been making whoopie pies for over two decades. In fact, her company Wicked Whoopies has produced over 30 million of the beloved hand-held delight. Wickeds pies come in a variety of flavors but their maple version featuring rounds of syrup-infused cake filled with fluffy cream is a favorite for the holidays. Buy Now
You May Like: The Profit Key Lime
Mcconnells Pumpkin Pie Ice Cream $12
McConnells
Who says ice cream is only for summer? Vanilla is a classic for topping pies, but youll find plenty of delicious seasonal fall and winter flavors from several ice cream companies that ship nationwide, including California favorite McConnells. Their ultra creamy pints are always made from grass-fed milk and cream, and this one is swirled with roast pumpkin puree warmly spiced with cinnamon, ginger, cloves, and molasses.Buy Now
Four & Twenty Blackbirds Bittersweet Chocolate Pecan Pie $79 From Goldbelly
Goldbelly
This article is intended to bring some relief to the holiday cooking and/or gift-giving process, but lets be honest, trying to decide which incredible dessert to order from Four & Twenty Blackbirds can be stress-inducing. The Brooklyn-based bakery has a number of delicious options including their famed Salty Honey Pie.
But for Thanksgiving, this option takes the traditional pecan pie you know and love to the next level with a generous dose of chocolate ganache and tons of roasty toasty pecans.
Also Check: Where Was Key Lime Pie Invented
Best Brunch Pie: Dangerously Delicious Pies
Dangerously Delicious Pies
SPRUCE15 for $15 off of minimum $50 spend, first time customers only, excludes shipping, standard T& C applies.
Baltimores legendary pie shop Dangerously Delicious Pies, led by musician-turned-pie-maker Rodney Henry, is known for its unique and creative pies. One of the shop’s most famous creations, the Blueberry Pancake Pie, has been called one of the best pies in America by People magazine. Made with pancake batter and fresh berries, this pie is a sweet, fluffy combination of breakfast and dessert.
That’s not all the shop sells, however. The Baltimore Bomb is a gooey, fudgy chess pie stuffed with Berger cookies, a cakey, chocolate frosting-covered treat made in the city.
Another tasty treat is the quiche pie, which is perfect for a weekend brunch. And if youre in Maryland, that quiche must contain crab. The shop’s Crab and Cheddar quiche is loaded with lump crab meat and sharp cheddar cheese and is topped with the local favorite Old Bay seasoning for a perfect sampling of Maryland cuisine.
If youre worried about shipping crab meat, the pie comes frozen. Just pop it into your oven at 350 degrees for 25 to 30 minutes before serving. And dont forget to whip up a homemade Orange Crush, a mixed drink with orange juice, vodka, and triple sec you cant have brunch in Baltimore without it.
Pies And Pints Middlebury
Typical pizza restaurant with a bar. Menu has more than pizza. Nachos are excellent and I really like their Bourbon Wings. Have not eaten much else there. Their pizza is good. Sometimes it can be greasy.
This owners have it done. Great staff, food, and comfortable setting. Very nice experience. Also very suntainable.
I was going to give 2 stars but Im going to be nice. The pizza is average at best. Im not sure how this place gets 5 stars? The crust is really the best part. It is light and crispy but the toppings are eh….We got pepperoni and it was really greasy, and the cheese was runny. My recommendation is to go to Elennis for better quality pizza.More
This is a great spot for lunch, you can order a salad and a slice of pizza, or go with friends for apps, or do whole pies. Nice outdoor seating and plenty of parking. Dinner time is a little loud once the bat scene gets…going, so thats the time for some pints and maybe not so much pies…More
Always great pizza and beer … but also fabulous burgers cooked to perfection! Outdoor patio is wonderful!!
Theo and his attentive staff are the stars of this establishment. While the eats are hearty, abundant, and delicious, the crew truly adds the shine. If you’re a brew aficionado, this is the place you to be!
Great local place to watch a sporting event or not. Great pizza and pasta. The spinach dip was awesome.
Don’t Miss: The Key Lime Pie Company
Sugar Cream Hoosier Sugar Pie By My Sugar Pie $28
My Sugar Pie
If youre not familiar with the Hoosier Pie, it might just be the best thing to come out of Indiana aside from Larry Bird and David Letterman. It doesnt get much better than My Sugar Pies version which keeps things traditional with the trinity of butter, sugar, and cream. Its the kind of slice that after taking one bite youll be asking, Where have you been all my life? Buy Now
Best Cherry: Grand Traverse Pie Company
Grand Traverse Pie Company
Grand Traverse Pie Company, named for the city of its location, takes local, Michigan-grown produce and whips it into perfect pies that Oprah has endorsed. Their Cherry Crumb pie is the signature of the Traverse City National Cherry Festival, a celebration of the cherryone of Michigan’s most delicious exports. This award-winning pie is perfectly sweet and tart, with a tang that zips your tongue and a buttery crumb topping.
The company serves pies with everything a pie-lover could want, from apples and blueberries to cream pies, peaches, pumpkins, and more. Grand Traverse’s ever-popular Michigan ABC pie is a combination of apples, blueberries, and cherries that melds into a delicious mix.
Everything is available on their website with the standard option of two-day shipping to make sure the pies are kept fresh. Pies can even be customized with messages like “I Heart You” or “No. 1 Mom” for an extra-special touch. Another delicious option to consider is the pie of the month club.
Recommended Reading: Midnight Moon Apple Pie Recipes
Best Overall: Four And Twenty Blackbirds
Four and Twenty Blackbirds
SPRUCE15 for $15 off of minimum $50 spend, first time customers only, excludes shipping, standard T& C applies.
The New York City pie shop Four and Twenty Blackbirds opened in 2009 when South Dakotans Melissa and Emily Elsen set out to become the city’s best handmade pie bakery. With high-quality ingredients sourced from local orchards, their apple pie is the ideal American dessert, but it’s so satisfying that it can stand alone as its own meal.
The shop’s apple pie is sweetened perfectly with caramel and is salted to enhance flavor, with a classic, lattice-style crust. Alternatively, the salty honey pie is a rich and creamy custard experience that’s sure to satisfy any sweet tooth.
The pies are shipped frozen with ice packs to retain freshness. They are delicious at room temperature and after being warmed in the oven at 250 degrees for 10 to 15 minutes.
Lady M Mille Crpe Cakes $90+ Each
Lady M
Need something super sophisticated thats also super delicious? A mille crêpe cake from Lady M will wow, whether its one of their classic flavors like vanilla and chocolate, or a seasonal treat like their chestnut version. The delicate layers of tender, lacy-edged crepes and pastry cream or custard look incredible, and taste just as good too. In addition to their signature striped sweets, youll find impressive checkerboard cakes and cheesecakes, including a limited edition Pumpkin Nuage that beats plain old pie any day.Buy Now
Also Check: The Key Lime Pie Company
Best Internet Famous: Milk Bar
Milk Bar
When we think of pies, crusty tops and delicious, gooey, fruity fillings generally come to mind. Milk Bar’s pie, however, is as simple looking as it can get. But there is a good reason why this was formerly known as “Crack Pie”the second it touches your lips, youre ordering a second one. The pie may not look like much, but hiding behind the playful dusting of confectionary sugar is an explosion of rich, salty, and sweet flavors.
Originally created out of scraps that were left over from staff meals, pastry chef Christina Tosi revamped an old-school recipe for chess pie from the classic American cookbook “Joy of Cooking.” By mixing oats, butter, sugar, and salt to make an oatmeal cookie crust, Tosi created a salty-sweet experience that some people claim is highly addictive. Inside the crust, Tosi adds a smooth, creamy filling made of butter, sugar, milk powder, and egg yolks for a sweet and soft bite that contrasts with the crunch and saltiness of the crust.
Milk Bar packages the pie cold with ice and plastic wrap, and it will last for up to a month in the freezer. Enjoy it hot or cold.
Milk Bar Pie By Milk Bar $46
Milk Bar
The dessert formerly known as Crack Pie is the signature offering from Christina Tosis Milk Bar and for good reason. This sinfully sweet and salty creation is housed in an oat cookie crust and finished off with a light dusting of powdered sugar. Its sure to be a crowd pleaser at your holiday gathering provided there arent any dentists at the table.Buy Now
You May Like: The Key Lime Pie Company
Dutch Apple By Julian Pie Company $2095
The Smothers Family knows a thing or two about apple pie. Not only do they continue to run the Julian Pie Company, the Southern California institution which they founded over 32 years ago, they even bought their own apple orchard. Not surprisingly, apples find their way into nearly all of the bakerys pies, but the Dutch version, which features a crunchy crumb topping, is a standout. Buy Now