For The Picky Eaters: Tiny Pies
Sometimes the best things come in small packages. The Tiny Pies sampler box of personalized mini pies offers a diverse array of flavors such as cherry, Dutchys Apple, Sweet Texas Pecan, and Texas Two Stepa chocolate browniepecan filling that is remarkably indulgent.
What to order: Assorted Tiny Pies 12 Pack, $79.95Highlight: The crust.Popular opinion: An excellent, flaky tart thats perfectly sized.
Best Internet Famous: Milk Bar
Milk Bar
When we think of pies, crusty tops and delicious, gooey, fruity fillings generally come to mind. Milk Bar’s pie, however, is as simple looking as it can get. But there is a good reason why this was formerly known as “Crack Pie”the second it touches your lips, youre ordering a second one. The pie may not look like much, but hiding behind the playful dusting of confectionary sugar is an explosion of rich, salty, and sweet flavors.
Originally created out of scraps that were left over from staff meals, pastry chef Christina Tosi revamped an old-school recipe for chess pie from the classic American cookbook “Joy of Cooking.” By mixing oats, butter, sugar, and salt to make an oatmeal cookie crust, Tosi created a salty-sweet experience that some people claim is highly addictive. Inside the crust, Tosi adds a smooth, creamy filling made of butter, sugar, milk powder, and egg yolks for a sweet and soft bite that contrasts with the crunch and saltiness of the crust.
Milk Bar packages the pie cold with ice and plastic wrap, and it will last for up to a month in the freezer. Enjoy it hot or cold.
The Fudge Pie Company Miami Florida
The Signature Fudge Pie $25
The Cookies and Cream Fudge Pie $25
The signature pie of the Fudge Pie Company is exactly what your most intense chocolate cravings would hope for: a smooth, rich, dense, irresistibly chocolate fudge pie baked into a graham cracker crust. The recipe is the brainchild of Chef Stacey Donayre, a graduate of the French Culinary Institute of America who interned at the world-renowned LeCirque restaurant under the tutelage of French pastry chef and chocolatier, Jacques Torres. in short, Chef Donayre knows chocolate.
The Fudge Pie Company also offers delightful seasonal, dense and fudgy versions of pie lovers favorites such as the Key Lime Fudge Pie , the Maple Pecan Fudge Pie, the rich and dense Dulche de Leche Fudge Pie, and we almost hate to tell you about the Cookies and Cream Fudge Pie, becauseOMG. When you order, take our advice and order two. Shipping is the same and they arrive packaged so they can be frozen and remain bakery fresh to enjoy whenever a special dessert is exactly what you crave.
Each 9-inch pie weighs a hefty 2 pounds and serves 12 16.
Recommended Reading: Georgia Pecan Pie Mail Order
Best Cherry: Grand Traverse Pie Company
Grand Traverse Pie Company
Grand Traverse Pie Company, named for the city of its location, takes local, Michigan-grown produce and whips it into perfect pies that Oprah has endorsed. Their Cherry Crumb pie is the signature of the Traverse City National Cherry Festival, a celebration of the cherryone of Michigan’s most delicious exports. This award-winning pie is perfectly sweet and tart, with a tang that zips your tongue and a buttery crumb topping.
The company serves pies with everything a pie-lover could want, from apples and blueberries to cream pies, peaches, pumpkins, and more. Grand Traverse’s ever-popular Michigan ABC pie is a combination of apples, blueberries, and cherries that melds into a delicious mix.
Everything is available on their website with the standard option of two-day shipping to make sure the pies are kept fresh. Pies can even be customized with messages like “I Heart You” or “No. 1 Mom” for an extra-special touch. Another delicious option to consider is the pie of the month club.
This Story Is Part Of A Group Of Stories Called
Eater is sharing our favorite recommendations for everyday things from our friends at the Strategist.
Lets be honest: Thanksgiving is all about the pie. Pecan, sweet potato, pumpkin, apple every bite of turkey, stuffing, and green-bean casserole is just a means to an end, and by end, we mean your favorite seasonal dessert. So we reached out to food editors and pastry chefs across the U.S. to find out the best pies that can be ordered from the comfort of your couch. From classic bourbon pecan to ooey-gooey salty honey, here are the pros picks for delivery favorites.
Recommended Reading: How Long To Cook Chicken Pot Pie
Smores Pie Butter & Scotch
MOUTH
Another winner from Brooklyns Butter & Scotch, this smores pie layers smooth milk chocolate custard into a graham cracker crust and tops the whole thing with piles of marshmallow topping that gets torched until its nice and toasty. Its the perfect winter treat with a summer campfire feel.
The Overall Best Pies To Order Online
- $79
Prices taken at time of publishing.
Time and again, this cult, famous Brooklyn-based pie shop came up among our experts. I still dream of their pie slices, says Nadia Chaudhury, editor of Eater Austin and a former New Yorker. Shes such a fan, in fact, that she calls the companys 2013 cookbook my pie bible. If youre the type who likes to make pie from scratch, but if youd rather stay out of the kitchen, the pies also ship beautifully. You can order a handful of flavors, but for a not-typical pie, Chaudhury says to opt for the bakerys signature salty honey pie, with its wonderfully gooey, sweet, luscious, and just-rightly-intense custard.
- $80
Prices taken at time of publishing.
Wisconsin is all over the news for a lot of reasons right now, but if studio food editor Amelia Rampe of the Kitchn had her way, it would be in the news for this apple pie named the best pie in America by The Wall Street Journal and Gourmet from the Elegant Farmer. Ive made the recipe for this pie a couple times in the last month, and its really good, says Rampe. But if youd rather take the work out of your pie-making, order a few of these online: The price is for two pies.
Recommended Reading: Where To Buy Gluten Free Lemon Meringue Pie
South Carolina Pecan Pie
The rich mosaic of flavors and textures belie the recipe’s simplicity: corn syrup, sugar, eggs, butter, vanilla, a pinch of salt and a whole lot of pecans. A flaky homemade crust, while optional, certainly adds to the delicious overall effect. But it’s those sweet, meaty South Carolina-grown pecans that make this pie our own.
Though easy to put together, especially if you use a ready-made crust, South Carolina has a trove of eateries, bakeries and other outlets where you can gobble up a slice or purchase a whole pie to take home. In November, you’ll find plenty of pecan pies offered up at restaurants as well as the South Carolina Pecan Festival, celebrated the first Saturday in November in Florence. While some bakers add fancy touches, such as spirits or chocolate, others deliver their pie straight-up. It’s perfectly acceptable protocol, however, to pair your pecan pie with a healthy dollop of whipped cream or a scoop of vanilla ice cream.
Now that your sweet tooth is on high alert, here are a few places where you can indulge your pecan pie passion. Call ahead to check availability or to order whole pies where offered:
The Cottage, Bluffton: A homey cafe oozing Southern charm and catering to lovers of traditional pecan pie.
Kaminsky’s, Charleston and Columbia: A dessert cafe famous for its Bourbon Pecan Pie.
: An unassuming meat-and-three that surprises with its rich White Russian Pecan Pie.
If the baking bug bites, try the recipe below, courtesy of Young Plantations:
Signature Salted Caramel Apple Pie Four & Twenty Blackbirds
Goldbelly
The salted caramel apple pie from this beloved Brooklyn-based pie shop routinely makes best-of listsand for good reason. The apple filling is swirled with salted caramel and flavored with both spices and Angostura bitters for a pie thats at once comfortingly familiar and delightfully boundary pushing. The flaky, all-butter crust is finished with demerara sugar for a hint of sweetness and crunch in every slice.
Read Also: Quick And Easy Chicken Pot Pie
Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie Ovenly
Ovenly
Cant decide on whether to serve cookies or pie for Thanksgiving dessert? Choose both. Brooklyns esteemed sweets shop, Ovenly, offers a 9-inch cookie pie crammed with chocolate chips and gooey caramel and sprinkled with flaky sea salt. Add a customized message on top in pastel icing . Then, top a slice with ice cream for a cookie pie a la mode.
Best Brunch Pie: Dangerously Delicious Pies
Dangerously Delicious Pies
SPRUCE15 for $15 off of minimum $50 spend, first time customers only, excludes shipping, standard T& C applies.
Baltimores legendary pie shop Dangerously Delicious Pies, led by musician-turned-pie-maker Rodney Henry, is known for its unique and creative pies. One of the shop’s most famous creations, the Blueberry Pancake Pie, has been called one of the best pies in America by People magazine. Made with pancake batter and fresh berries, this pie is a sweet, fluffy combination of breakfast and dessert.
That’s not all the shop sells, however. The Baltimore Bomb is a gooey, fudgy chess pie stuffed with Berger cookies, a cakey, chocolate frosting-covered treat made in the city.
Another tasty treat is the quiche pie, which is perfect for a weekend brunch. And if youre in Maryland, that quiche must contain crab. The shop’s Crab and Cheddar quiche is loaded with lump crab meat and sharp cheddar cheese and is topped with the local favorite Old Bay seasoning for a perfect sampling of Maryland cuisine.
If youre worried about shipping crab meat, the pie comes frozen. Just pop it into your oven at 350 degrees for 25 to 30 minutes before serving. And dont forget to whip up a homemade Orange Crush, a mixed drink with orange juice, vodka, and triple sec you cant have brunch in Baltimore without it.
Also Check: Chocolate Covered Key Lime Pie On A Stick Key West
The Best Classic Pies To Order Online
- $75
Prices taken at time of publishing.
If youre looking for a no-fuss option to serve to picky family members who prefer their pies traditional, editor Elle Simone Scott of Americas Test Kitchen recommends ordering from this Black-owned bakery. Justice of the Pies is not just baking pies in the name of social justice, although the end justifies the means, she says. Its also some of the most creative and decadent pie offerings Ive seen in a long time. Her favorite is the classic bourbon pecan, but it has a very Thanksgiving-appropriate apple pie, too.
- $65
Prices taken at time of publishing.
Why limit yourself to just one kind of pie? Brenna Houck, editor of Eater Detroit, recommends going for this mini-pie gift box from Michigans Zingermans Bakehouse, which includes a traditional toasted-pecan pie, a chocolate chess pie, and a pleasantly tart and tangy cranberry-walnut pie.
- $35
Prices taken at time of publishing.
- $40
Prices taken at time of publishing.
If you or your Thanksgiving guests have dietary restrictions, Three Babes Bakeshop in the Bay Area makes a delicious pecan pie minus the gluten. I tried their pie a few years back at the farmers market at the Ferry Building, where they sell seasonal specials by the slice, and they are truly amazing, says Caroline Schiff, pastry chef at Fort Defiance General Store in Brooklyn . And if you dont have any dietary restrictions, Three Babes sells an outstanding gluten-full bourbon-pecan pie as well.
If Your Sweet Tooth Isnt Messing Around: Royers Pie Haven
In true Texas fashion, the family-run bakerys menu is chock-full of decadent pies that range from the Texas Trash to the Sweet n Salty, which has a dense brownie-like filling with caramel and sea salt. While Royers offers a mix of both sweet and savory options, were undoubtedly partial to the former.
What to order: Anns Pecan PieHighlight: A thick and crunchy pecan top that is utterly irresistible.Popular opinion: This one tastes like a giant cookie and pretty much blew my mind.
You May Like: Pyrex Deep Dish Pie Plate
Grand Traverse Pie Company
Traverse City, MichiganGTPC takes its name from a bay thats world famous for its cherries, so it stands to reason that you should absolutely get one of its legendary, crumbly topped pies, a gallon of ice cream, and a pillow. And while that pie is wonderful and perfect on its own, there are a bazillion other options too. Luckily, theres a pie of the month club, which you should 1,000% join, because pie is too damn delicious for once a year especially the there are chocolate cream pies, peanut butter chocolate cream, and every fruit imaginable packed into the crust.
Kermits Key West Lime Shoppe
Key West, FLIf youre going to order yourself a key lime pie, you might as well go directly to the source. Kermits Key West Lime Shoppe uses actual key limes in celebration of the official Florida state pie. Its tart and zippy as every good key lime pie should be, but mellows out thanks to condensed milk and cream cheese.
Also Check: How To Make A Pie Chart Online
The Pie That Makes A Statement: The Blue Owl Bakery
Apple pie lovers, youre in for a treat. This mile-high confection features layer upon layer of delicious apple slices encased in a mouthwatering caramel dome. Thats 10 pounds of pure pie goodness thats sure to wow even the hardest-to-please eaters.
What to order:HighlightPopular opinion
Best Overall: Four And Twenty Blackbirds
Four and Twenty Blackbirds
SPRUCE15 for $15 off of minimum $50 spend, first time customers only, excludes shipping, standard T& C applies.
The New York City pie shop Four and Twenty Blackbirds opened in 2009 when South Dakotans Melissa and Emily Elsen set out to become the city’s best handmade pie bakery. With high-quality ingredients sourced from local orchards, their apple pie is the ideal American dessert, but it’s so satisfying that it can stand alone as its own meal.
The shop’s apple pie is sweetened perfectly with caramel and is salted to enhance flavor, with a classic, lattice-style crust. Alternatively, the salty honey pie is a rich and creamy custard experience that’s sure to satisfy any sweet tooth.
The pies are shipped frozen with ice packs to retain freshness. They are delicious at room temperature and after being warmed in the oven at 250 degrees for 10 to 15 minutes.
Read Also: I Ate Some Pie Math
Of The Best Pies To Mail Order For Thanksgiving
All products and services featured are independently selected by Forbes Vetted contributors and editors. When you make a purchase through links on this page, we may earn a commission. Learn more
Prepping for Thanksgiving dinner is an all day affair. And heres a little known fact: the holiday actually begins the moment you pad into the kitchen in your fuzzy slippers with a mug of coffee and begin chopping onions and sage for the cornbread stuffing. But while cooking is half the fun, when it comes to dessert there are plenty of reasons to leave the pie to the pros. Luckily, you can order some of the best pies from top bakeries across the country and have them shipped directly to your door in time for dinner.
You can’t go wrong with babka pie.
Breads Bakery
From the classics like creamy pumpkin and gooey pecan, to genre benders like a chocolate chip cookie pie and a wreath-shaped babka pie, these nine sweet treats are best in show. Spend your cooking energy perfecting your gravy game. Then, when dessert rolls around, simply dollop the pies with whipped cream and get ready to wow your tablemates.
Chicago-based pie maven Maya-Camille Broussard swears that her pecan pie can make grown men cry. But the syrupy, vanilla-scented pecan filling, which comes spiked with a generous glug of bourbon is more likely to leave you smiling after Thanksgiving dinner.