Discontinued Apple Pie Ice Cream Brands
The list below contains the apple pie ice cream brands weve been able to identify as discontinued. Sometimes this is permanent while in others the company has paused the flavor temporarily.
Whenever possible, weve attempted to get official confirmation from the company, but unfortunately, this information isnt easy to come by.
A Love For Homemade Ice Cream Recipes
When you walk down the ice cream aisle at your grocery store, there are cases and cases of ice cream tubs, but not that many flavor options. Once you get past the standard chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, butter pecan, cookies and cream, and candy bar swirl varieties, what do you really have?
Learning how to make homemade ice cream is much easier than you might think. Theres quite a bit of waiting around involved, but other than that, its simply whisk-simmer-churn.
For The Love Of Cinnamon
A few years ago, I was shopping in my local supermarket, a.k.a. My Happy Place, when I came upon a pint of cinnamon ice cream. I had never tried it before. In fact, I had never even heard of cinnamon ice cream. Have you? If not, I can assure you that its downright dreamy. It was a store brand pint of ice cream, nothing fancy, but boy am I glad I tried it. Cinnamon ice cream is such an amazing complement to so many fall bakes like pies, cakes, even muffins. It is a great stand-in for vanilla, and actually kicks the fall flavors up a notch. Cinnamon ice cream takes something good and makes it great. So I got to thinking what if instead of topping an apple pie with cinnamon ice cream, we turned things upside down? And thats how this Apple Cinnamon Ice Cream Pie was born.
Also Check: Pie Nation Pizza
The Best Way To Make Apple Pie Filling For Ice Cream
This also means that you need to prepare the apple pie filling in advance as well. I think it really helps to mash the apples like apple sauce instead of leaving them chunks. Big chunks of frozen apples arent always the easiest to eat! I left a few chunks in my ice cream but I prefer it to be more pureed that chunky.
What You Will Love About This Recipe
The beginnings of Fall have arrived. The cooler mornings that I love, the leaves beginning to change and lots of apples at the Farmers Market!
Apple Pie Ice Cream is the perfect way to enjoy those apples. It has all the flavors and things I love about apple pie but in a homemade ice cream form. There are yummy, cinnamon and sugar coated apples along with the crunch of cinnamon graham crackers all in a cinnamon based ice cream.
Don’t Miss: Churchs Chicken Apple Pie
Pies Weve Turned Into Ice Cream
No matter what your family eats as the main course this holiday season, theres a good chance dessert will include some sort of pie. Whats a holiday meal without some pie?
Everyone knows how well ice cream pairs with pie. We love the stuff so much that we cant seem to help ourselves when it comes to creating pie-flavored ice creams. How many of these 15 flavor creations have you eaten?
1. Thats Life Apple Pie This flavor tasted its best when the eater was wearing neon. The 80s were weird like that.
2. Miz Jelena’s Sweet Potato Pie Made with ginger ice cream and a fudge swirl, this short-lived flavor lives on in our Flavor Graveyard.
3. Sweet Potato Pie We were pretty sad to lay Miz Jelenas Sweet Potato Pie to rest in 1993, so we thought wed change up the recipe and put Sweet Potato Pie another chance at infamy in our Scoop Shops.
4. Pecan Pie Legend says Pecan Pie didnt show up in recipe books until 1886. We apologize that it took us over 100 years to make our own variation.
5. Southern Pecan Pie After Pecan Pie came and went, we decided to try a new twist. So we sent the flavor down south with brown sugar ice cream, pecan chunks and swirls.
6. Sublime Key Lime Pie Key lime pie is good. But Sublime Key Lime Pie? We guess its fluffy meringue swirls were just too sublime for the world to handle.
8. Apple Pie Imagine putting a scoop of our Apple Pie on top of that slice of Apple Pie you just took out of the oven. This is the stuff dreams are made of.
How To Make The Cinnamon Ice Cream
Its basically the pie on top of the ice cream instead of the ice cream on top of the pie. And guys it is so. darn. good. Making cinnamon ice cream from scratch is almost as easy as using a premade pint. And since I wasnt sure that everyone reading this would be able to find cinnamon ice cream, I figured that making it from scratch would be a must for this recipe. Luckily, no churn ice cream recipes were all the rage in the summer of 2020, and theres a very good basic recipe out there to which you can add any mix-ins you want. So its really easy to whip up your own version of cinnamon ice cream at home.
Youll start by beating heavy cream, sugar and vanilla in a bowl until you get stiff peaks. This is pretty much a basic whipped cream. Then, fold in a can of sweetened condensed milk and some cinnamon. And boom ice cream! Its that easy.
You May Like: Pinkie Pie Remote Control Scooter
What Tools Are Needed To Make Homemade Ice Cream
Some helpful tools tools you need for this recipe include an ice cream tub for your freezer and an ice cream maker. I have the attachment for my KitchenAid mixer but if you dont have a KitchenAid mixer, I hear this Cuisinart ice cream maker is really popular.
Keep up with all the happenings. Follow Beyond Frosting:
Mix The Milk And Cream
Now that your apples are good to go, it’s time to get started on the actual ice cream mixture. Take out a large bowl and start to make the mix. First, toss in the milk and heavy cream, which provide the creamy base for this delightful dish. Then, throw in the remaining sugar and vanilla extract for a delicious sweet flavor. The last thing you need to add is the graham crackers. Remember, you should have crushed these ahead of time, so they should mix in very easily.
Stir everything well, and then move on to the next step.
Also Check: Chocolate Covered Key Lime Pie On A Stick
Mymochi Apple Pie A La Mode
Wrapped in a soft, sweet Japanese dough , known as Mochi, this apple pie ice cream from MyMochi is available on a seasonal basis but has not been on the market since 2020. According to the companys Twitter account, there are no immediate plans to make it a year round offering.
We hear ya and will definitely consider keeping Apple Pie à la Mode year-round
Edys Slow Churned Washington Apple Pie Light Ice Cream
This light ice cream featured cinnamon, pie chunks and apples from the State of Washington. As of October 2020, the companys Twitter account announced its been discontinued.
Our Best of States Washington Apple Pie has been retired, Naomi. Well let our team know you were asking about it! In the meantime, we suggest giving our Limited Edition Pumpkin Pie a try. You can check it out here:
Edys Ice Cream
Recommended Reading: Chicken Pot Pie Recipe Campbells
What You’ll Learn In This Recipe
Anytime you make an ice cream recipe, there’s always a little bit of science that goes into it. In today’s recipe, you’ll learn some of the magical science behind ice cream including:
- The role each ingredient plays in creating a silky, smooth ice cream.
- Tips for storing your homemade ice cream so it lasts in the freezer.
- Troubleshooting tips for making a homemade ice cream base. This will be especially helpful if it’s your first time!
If you enjoy learning about food science and tips for improving your skills in the kitchen, be sure to sign up for my five day email series. You’ll learn practical culinary secrets every home chef needs to know!
Giant Eagle Cinnamon Caramel Apple Pie Ice Cream
This ice cream is private labeled under the Giant Eagle brand and is available at its stores in Indiana. While it contains real apples, it doesnt list pie crust as an ingredient as some other brands but instead crunchy pieces of cinnamon vanilla.
- Link to Giant Eagle Cinnamon Caramel Apple Pie
Don’t Miss: Américan Pie Band Camp Trailer
How To Make Apple Pie Ice Cream
Homestead Creamery Apple Pie Flavored Ice Cream
Homestead Creamery sources the ingredients for its hand dipped apple ice cream from nearby locally owned dairy farms. Located in Virginia, the company sells its ice cream to grocery stores in the area and provides a store locator on its site.
- Link to Homestead Creamery Apple Pie Flavored Ice Cream
- Homestead Store Locator
Read Also: Impossibly Easy Chicken Pot Pie
How To Make Bourbon Apple Pie Ice Cream
I churn this ice cream on slow for about 10 minutes and then increase the speed. Then, I add the smashed apples directly to the ice cream mixture. It is best to add this in during the last couple of minutes. I really cant resist having a few bites of ice cream right out of container, it has more of a custard consistency.
I usually freeze my ice cream for a few hours before I eat the rest. Sometimes if the ice cream over freezes, I let it thaw for about twenty minutes before serving. I just really like soft ice cream. When I was younger, I used to stir my ice cream until it reached a milk shake consistency. Old habits dont die. With apple season under way, I know you need another way to use them all up!
Putting It All Together
The topping is equally as easy. Youre essentially just making an apple pie filling, right on the stove top. It comes together relatively quickly, but youll want to make sure it cools all the way down to room temperature before you put it on top of the Apple Cinnamon Ice Cream Pie. Otherwise, youll speed up the melting.
And thats kind of a nice thing about making ice cream pies in the cooler months its not as much of a race against time to eat them before they melt. And while ice cream pies arent what you would typically consider to be seasonal for October, the fall flavors in this Apple Cinnamon Ice Cream Pie will make you rethink that notion. In fact, I make another ice cream pie for Thanksgiving every year that my brother-in-law is obsessed with, and it fits in perfectly among all the warm desserts. Stay tuned for that in November!
For now, lets revel in apple season and cut ourselves an extra sliver of this Apple Cinnamon Ice Cream Pie soon to be everyones upside down favorite. Enjoy!
Also Check: Key West Key Lime Pie Company Net Worth
The Ultimate Fall Ice Cream Recipe
Apple pie is the ultimate fall dessert. You can’t go wrong with a classic apple pie, but sometimes it’s just not enough for some people. That’s why I had to create this recipe! This ice cream will satisfy your sweet tooth and give you that great taste of Fall all year long- no oven required! All you need are a few simple ingredients and an ice cream maker. Have fun experimenting with your favorite flavors in the kitchen – we know we did while creating this recipe! Don’t forget to sign up for our newsletter below so that you’ll get more recipes and cooking tips like this one delivered straight to your inbox each month, along with exclusive content from us.
Best Caramel Apple Pie Ice Cream
Create a homemade caramel apple pie ice cream completely from scratch
This apple pie inspired ice cream is filled with the flavors of chai spices, granny smith apples, and a rich caramel sauce. Whether you’re looking for a summer ice cream recipe or need a frozen fall treat, this apple ice cream is sure to be a crowd pleaser.The apples are cooked and blended up in the vanilla custard base ice cream to give a smooth, creamy textured ice cream.
There are few things as comforting as homemade ice cream, especially in the summer. It’s even better when the ice cream is smothered in homemade caramel sauce.
I’m a firm believer that ice cream is a dessert that should always be eaten, no matter the time of year. This means it’s important to have flavors that reflect the various seasons. Today’s apple pie ice cream recipe would be perfect for the fall or even during the winter months!
This homemade ice cream recipe is made with fresh apples, lots of warm spices, and finally caramel topping to finish it off. It has quickly become one of my favorite desserts! I hope your whole family will love it too!
You May Like: Sonic Banana Cream Pie Shake Recipe