Peace Pie Ice Cream Sandwiches

Must Try

Peach Pie Ice Cream Sandwiches

Forget peach pie à la mode and make it as an ice cream sandwich instead!

  • 2 3/4 cups all-purpose flour
  • 1 tablespoon brown sugar

Peach Bourbon Caramel Swirl Ice Cream

  • 1 container old-fashioned vanilla ice cream, divided
  • 1 ripe but still firm peach, pitted and diced, divided
  • 1 batch bourbon caramel sauce, recipe follows

Peach Compote

  • 6 ripe peaches, peeled, pitted and roughly chopped
  • 1/4 cup sugar

Peach Ice Cream Sandwich At The Masters

Nothing says spring and summer like fresh peaches. This recipe was inspired by another popular treat at the Masters golf tournament the Peach Ice Cream Sandwich. While Ive never had the pleasure of eating the ice cream sandwich, Ive heard it is delicious. I wanted to make a copycat version at home, but I really didnt want to deal with making the individual sandwiches. So, I decided to make a Masters Peach Ice Cream Pie instead. Sugar cookie crust filled with a creamy and delicious homemade peach ice cream. Let me tell you, this is DELICIOUS! I wanted to eat the entire pie! It is so light and packed full of peach flavor.

Georgia Peach Ice Cream

Below is the recipe for Ice Cream. See my favorite Sugar Cookies here. Hard freeze ice cream at least 1 hour before making sandwiches. You can put them together and enjoy them immediately or wrap individually in plastic wrap and take out one by one to enjoy.

If youre just making Peach Ice Cream and dont plan to put it in the sandwiches, consider adding chopped pecans.

Recommended Reading: Key West Key Lime Pie Company The Profit Update

If You Are Baking Pies And Have Extra Dough Save It And Make These Delicious Treats


1 pint of Aldens vanilla ice cream

1 pint of Aldens chocolate chunk ice cream

Cinnamon sugar

Plastic Wrap for sealing the ice cream sandwiches


  • Preheat oven to 375 degress F
  • Line a 9X13 in cookie sheet with parchment paper, set aside
  • Make cinnamon sugar by mixing the two ingredients in a small bowl until well combined, set aside
  • Make pie dough according to recipe directions
  • After rolling out the pie dough make 12 even rounds using a 3 inch cookie cutter
  • Place the cookie shapes on the parchment lined cookie sheet
  • Sprinkle each cookie with cinnamon sugar mixture
  • Bake pies for 15 minutes until golden brown
  • Place pies rounds on a cooling rack until they are completely cooled
  • Get ice cream out of the freezer and let it sit out for about 10 minutes until slightly soft
  • Assembling the Ice Cream Sandwiches:

  • Take one pie round and gently press ice cream about 1 inch high then cover with the other pie round. DO NOT PRESS HARD as the pie shells are flaky and tender
  • Gently wrap each individual PiesCream Sandwich in plastic wrap and freeze at least 2 hours before serving
  • As soon as you finish assembling each one place in the freezer so they arent melting as you prepare the others
  • If you make this recipe please write a comment to tell me your thoughts! I want to connect with all of you through your experience with my recipes.

    Love, Elena

    • Total Time:1 hour 10 minutes
    • Yield:61x

    Peach Ice Cream Pie With Sugar Cookie Crust

    Peace Pie opened in 2016 in Charleston, and serves a signature homemade ...

    When you are ready to serve this Peach Ice Cream Pie take it out of the freezer and let it sit on the counter for about 20 to 30 minutes so it will be easier to slice. Top each slice with a dollop of whipped cream and a little fresh peach slice.

    This pie is SOOOO good. It is great for all your upcoming get-togethers. I love to make this for cookouts, BBQs, potlucks, dinner parties and Easter! I love that you can make it ahead of time and pull it out of the freezer when you are ready to eat.

    Here are a few more pie recipes that are equally delicious!

    Recommended Reading: Sing And Dance Pinkie Pie

    Review Of Peace Pie Charleston

    301 ReviewsPrice range:Description:Restaurant detailsDescription:Wonderful ice cream sandwiches!

    Unique and delicious! Just happened to see a write-up about this place in a magazine on the plane to Charleston. Decided to add it to our to-do list. So glad we did! It was a delicious dessert and a good amount. Peace Pie sells specialty ice cream sandwiches which are inspired by pie al a mode. The Elvis and Salted Caramel Apple were very good, while the strawberry shortcake was just okay. Not that it was bad, but the other two flavors were much better. They had about 12-15 flavor options. Not only was the additions or mousse and jams delicious, the ice cream itself was homemade and delicious in its own right. Definitely take their advice and let it warm up for a minute or two before you enjoy. Note that there are no tables in the store and not tons of benches nearby. Not a drawback by any means, just be aware.

    These Easy Key Lime Pie Ice Cream Are So Refreshing

    There is just something about Key Lime Pie in the summer. I mean, I am all about a Key Lime dessert anytime of the year, but they just hit a little different when its warm outside.

    And this easy ice cream sandwich recipe is honestly one of those sweet treats that you will want to make all summer long.

    You make a simple no churn ice cream and then sandwich it between 2 graham crackers. Kind of a lot like key lime pie, honestlythat you can hold with your hands.

    And if youve never made no churn ice cream, youre in for a real treat. Its creamy richand theres sweetened condensed milk involved, which I will get to in a minute.

    These are fantastic for parties because you can make them way aheador an easy dessert to have in your freezer when you want something a little sweet.

    Don’t Miss: Damn Good Pies Little Rock Arkansas

    Peace Pie Ice Cream Sandwichesjpg

    Peace Pie specializes in novel frozen sandwiches with gourmet pie fillings.

    As featured on

    Watch this discussion.Stop watching this discussion.

    Keep it clean. No vulgar, racist, sexist orsexually-oriented language.Engage ideas. This forum is for the exchange ofideas, not personal attacks or ad hominem criticisms.TURN OFF CAPS LOCK.Be civil. Don’t threaten. Don’t lie.Don’t bait. Don’t degrade others.No trolling. Stay on topic.No spamming. This is not the place to sell miraclecures.No deceptive names. Apparently misleadingusernames are not allowed.Say it once. No repetitive posts, please.Help us. Use the ‘Report’ link for abusiveposts.

    Thank you for reading!

    Please log in, or sign up for a new account and purchase a subscription to read or post comments.

    Thank you for reading!

    Please log in, or sign up for a new account and purchase a subscription to continue reading.

    Please purchase a subscription to continue reading.

    Your current subscription does not provide access to this content.

    How To Make Homemade Ice Cream Sandwiches

    Whats great about these is you all you need is a mixer and a freezer. Well, and all the ingredientsand a spoonand some time

    You mix up your ice cream/key lime filling, which is super easy. Heavy cream, Key Lime juice, sweetened condensed milk, sugarit just keeps getting better doesnt it?

    The consistency will look like this:

    Pour that into a plastic container and freeze it for 5-6 hours.

    At that point it will be almost frozen, but still spreadable.

    If you forget it and leave it in longer, its not a problem, just let it sit on the counter until it warms up to a spreadable consistency.

    Then assemble your ice cream sandwiches using graham crackers!

    Youll use about 1/4 cup of ice cream on each

    Top the ice cream with another graham cracker and then you can individually wrap them in cling wrap and freeze until they are completely firm, about another hour or so.

    You can make these days in advance, which is pretty awesome.

    Trust me, these are amazing.

    Don’t Miss: Campbells Chicken Pot Pie With Cream Of Potato Soup

    Get Ready For The Weekend

    With our four-day Wednesday-through-Saturday home delivery package, you get home delivery of our popular Food and 72 Hours sections as well as the full Saturday-Sunday weekend paper.

    And, as with all of our packages, you get full access to all of our online content, any day and on any device.

    Membership includes access to newsletters, special offers and the ability to share your subscription with up to four additional household members.

    Subscriptions renew automatically every 30 days. Call 240-215-8600 to cancel auto-renewal. Most subscribers are served by News-Post carriers households in some outlying areas receive same-day delivery through the US Postal Service. If your household falls in a postal delivery area, you will be notified by our customer service team.

    The Story Behind Peace Pie Ice Cream Sandwiches A Cape May Favorite

    Image Source:

    Everyone has their favorite ice cream shop and ice cream flavor, but have you ever tried a Peace Pie? With locations in Cape May and Lambertville, ., Peace Pie has established itself as a unique ice cream destination.

    According to founder and creator Jerry Klause, Peace Pie began Thanksgiving night 2010, over a delicious batch of pie filling and a forgotten pie crust. Klause baked the pie filling and two giant shortbread cookies, then combined it all in layers with vanilla ice cream. Thus, he served a Pecan Pie Lasagna for dessert and it was a hit with the whole crowd. The following summer, the Klause family decided to take their delicious idea and put it into action with the design and production of Peace Pie, an ice cream sandwich with a layer of pie filling!

    The family initially sold their Peace Pies at farmers markets and local events throughout southern New Jersey. Their successful grassroots efforts led to the establishment of their flagship store in Cape May, which opened Memorial Day weekend of 2015. Within one hour of opening night, the Klause family knew they had a fantastic product.

    Peace Pie locations expanded to Charleston, S.C,. Saint Augustine, Fla., Ventnor City, and Lambertville. The Lambertville shop is conveniently located just across the bridge from New Hope, Pa, making it a perfect pit stop for a summer stroll. Open 12 p.m.. to 9 p.m. daily, orders are available for pick-up or delivery. All Peace Pies are $7 in-store.

    Don’t Miss: Campbells Chicken Pot Pie Recipe With Pie Crust

    How To Make Ice Cream Without A Machine

    This Peach Ice Cream Pie is super easy to make. The best part of the whole recipe is that you dont need an ice cream machine to make the ice cream filling! YAY!!! You also dont need to cook the ice cream base and there are no eggs in the filling. I told you this was super easy!

    Start by making the crust. Crush the cookies and mix with some melted butter. Press the crumbs into a springform pan and set aside. Next, make the ice cream filling. Puree some peach slices in the food processor. Combine whipped cream, sweetened condensed milk, and the peach puree. Stir in some chopped peaches and pour the mixture into the springform pan. Cover the pan with some foil and pop it in the freezer.

    Yummy Pie Flavors And More

    Cape May Weekend + White Bridesmaid Dresses

    Today they offer more than 35 flavors and the list seems to be growing. From the original Pecan Pie , other options include Salted Carmel Apple, Key Lime, Cherry, and Coconut Custard to name a few.

    We moved away from some of the more traditional flavors to include different Pie Fillings.

    Chuck in true Chocoholic form went straight to the Molten Chocolate Chocolate Ice Cream, Chocolate Mousse, and Chocolate Cookie! Stellar, he ate most of it before we could get a good pic.

    Recommended Reading: Key Lime Pie Review

    Peace Pie St Augustine

    If you missed our last blog post, we had dinner at Harrys Seafood Bar and Grille on our first night in St. Augustine. Our server was less than charming and basically blew off asking about dessert so we paid our check and left.

    Their loss was our gain! We wandered down the block, across the Plaza de la Constituciòn, and down Aviles Street to Peace Pie!

    This Is Our Best Offer

    You get home delivery Monday through Saturday plus full digital access any time, on any device with our six-day subscription delivery membership.

    This membership plan includes member-only benefits like our popular ticket giveaways, all of our email newsletters and access to the daily digital replica of the printed paper. Also, you can share digital access with up to four other household members at no additional cost.

    Subscriptions renew automatically every 30 days. Call 240-215-8600 to cancel auto-renewal. Most subscribers are served by News-Post carriers households in some outlying areas receive same-day delivery through the US Postal Service. If your household falls in a postal delivery area, you will be notified by our customer service team.

    Also Check: Campbells Soup Chicken Pot Pies

    Peace Pie: A Different Take On The Ice Cream Sandwich

    What could take the out-dated version of the ice cream sandwich to the next level? Put a layer of pie filling in the middle and sell it! Thats what Peace Pie in Charleston, SC, is doing, and business is off the charts. Peace Pie took the basic concept of an ice cream sandwich, added a twist, and now people are flocking to their stores to try tantalizing pie flavors like Coconut Cream, Pecan Pie, Banana Cream, and their popular Salted Caramel Brownie. We took some time to sit down with the Prince of Peace Pie himself, Joe Klause, to learn more about his fascinating journey from South Jersey to France, his pot smoking days, and what its like to be running his very own Peace Pie in Charleston. At the ripe young age of 29, Joes a laid-back guy with a lot of life experience in living abroad, studying music, and a taste for the Coconut Cream flavor.

    Jerry also started one of the most successful charter schools in New Jersey. Joe explained that its particularly difficult to start a charter school in New Jersey. When Joe was in second grade, Jerry served as the president of the school board in Ocean City where he grew up. He later started his own school for the performing arts called Charter Tech in Somers Point, NJ. Believe it or not, Jerry also currently has a list of Burger King franchises that he oversees. He credits a lot of his success at running businesses to his time at the popular burger chain.

    So, Prince of Peace Pie, how did Peace Pie get its name?

    Snickerdoodle And Peach Ice Cream Sandwiches

    Caramelized Peach Ice Cream Sandwiched between soft and chewy snickerdoodle cookies perfect for peach season. This brown sugar caramelized no churn peach ice cream is easy to make and its the best all summer treat. This flavour combo is more traditional and one that really accentuates the peaches and celebrates peach season. Because lets be honest, enjoying local fresh fruit and ice cream are really some of the best parts of summer.

    I know there are varying opinions on whether to use soft chewy cookies or crunchy crisp ones when making ice cream sandwiches. I love them both but I definitely favour soft and chewy for mine like Ginger Spiced Molasses Cookies, Double Chocolate Brownie Cookies, Classic Oatmeal Cookies, or Chocolate Caramel Spelt Oatmeal Cookies. I thought that snicherdoodles would be the perfect cookie to hold all the peachy goodness, because there is nothing like these cinnamon-sugar soft and chewy sugar cookies with their cracked tops and just a whisper of tang. They are the perfect match for the fresh, tangy-sweet, juicy peaches in season right now.

    Snickerdoodle & Peach ice-cream sandwich Main Ingredients:

    Step-by-step Instructions for Snickerdoodle & Peach ice-cream sandwiches:

  • Caramelize the peaches in butter brown sugar and spices then set aside to cool
  • Make vanilla ice-cream base Whip the cream until stiff peaks. Combine the Sweetened Condensed Milk with the bourbon and vanilla then fold it into the whipped cream.
  • Don’t Miss: Campbells Chicken Pot Pie With Pie Crust

    Popular Recipes

    More Recipes Like This