Best Mail Order Key Lime Pie

Must Try

Oprah’s Favorite Key Lime Bundt Cake

The BEST-EVER Key Lime Pie!

We Take the Cake ships its delicious cakes nationwide on Goldbelly! Oprah chose this unique Key Lime Bundt cake as one of her Favorite Things. If your idea of heaven is divinely moist and dense pound cake kissed with the tangy flavor of Key lime and drizzled with Key lime cream cheese frosting, you will love it too.

We Take The Cake has become one of the most sought after, made-from-scratch bakeries in the US. The team at We Take The Cake understands that its not just about sending a cake. It represents celebration, comfort, appreciation, love, and togetherness, even if you cant be there yourself. They take pride in mixing the batters and frosting from scratch, using whole milk, fresh eggs and real butter, NEVER a cake mix or commercially made frostings.

Best For All Key Lime Products: Kermits Key West Key Lime Shoppe

Kermits Key West Key Lime Shoppe

Why We Chose It: Kermits Key West Key Lime Shoppe delivers its key lime pie and a variety of other key lime products to homes nationwide.

  • Assortment of key lime products

  • Variety of flavors of pie and pie bars

  • Gluten-free pie crust available

  • High shipping costs

Kermits Key West Key Lime Shoppe is the place to shop for anything and everything related to key limes. Its key lime pie has been named the “Best Tasting Key Lime Pie” on the Food Network. Kermits makes a classic version with real key lime juice, a graham cracker crust , and fluffy whipped cream, along with two flavored versions: strawberry and coconut. A single, 9-inch key lime pie is priced at $38.95 plus overnight shipping costs.

In addition to key lime pies, Kermits sells an assortment of frozen key lime pie bars such as regular key lime pie dipped in dark chocolate and strawberry key lime pie dipped in white or dark chocolate. A variety of key lime cookies, key lime peanuts, key lime fudge, key lime liqueur cake, and more are also available for purchase from the online shop. Kermit’s pies, pie bars, and fudge are also available for sale on Goldbelly. An added bonus: Kermits Key West Key Lime Shoppe is a disabled veteran-owned small business and regularly supports local organizations in its shops communities.

Best 9 Bakeries That Deliver Fresh Key Lime Pie Nationwide

204learn more

If youre searching for the best bakeries online that deliver Key lime pie to any doorstep in America, youre in the right place.

Youll see the best options available, how much they cost and what you can expect when you open the shipping box.

In A Rush? Best value Most selection

Key Lime Pies are the perfect balance of juicy, tart Key limes and sweet creamy filling. Unfortunately, making a real authentic Key lime pie can be a bit of a task on your own.but worry not!

Here are the top bakeries that will do the hard work and bake, pack and deliver a fresh Key Lime Pie to your doorstep. All you have to do is open the box and dig in!

Also Check: Damgoode Pies Little Rock Delivery

Best Key Lime Pie Delivery Services Of 2021

SPRUCE15 for $15 off of minimum $50 spend, first time customers only, excludes shipping, standard T& C applies.

Why We Chose It: Goldbelly offers an assortment of key lime pies and other key lime baked goods from top vendors around the country.

  • Assortment of products and vendors

  • Free shipping included on many orders

  • Delivered frozen for longer shelf life

  • Good customer reviews

  • Free shipping not available on all items

Online gourmet marketplace Goldbelly offers an assortment of key lime pies from around the country. Goldbelly sells items from nearly a dozen other companies that make key lime pies and key lime pie-inspired products. Try key lime cheesecake from Juniors cheesecake in Manhattan, key lime pie jars from Colada Shop, key lime mini pies from Pink Pie, key lime pie ice cream sandwiches, and even Oprahs Favorite Key Lime Bundt Cake. Want to stick to the classic? There are numerous options for purchasing traditional key lime pies from businesses including Little Pie Company, Blue Smoke, Emporium Pies, and more.

Tips To Making The Best Key Lime Pie

  • Allow it to cool down first , THEN place it in your fridge.
  • Allow the pie to chill at least 3 hours
  • Did you know placing things you need cold quickly on the BOTTOM shelf is best. Cold air falls. That is also what I did during the competition, placed it in the bottom of their commercial refrigerators I swear that helped me! I also told a few others to do the same :).
  • Dont put whipped cream on until shortly before serving for best/prettiest results.
  • Either dont cover the pie or have it in a domed container. Plastic wrap will stick your beautifully formed pie and mess it up.

If you enjoy making desserts as much as I do, you need to try one or all of the following:

Homemade Apple Fritters. Just a handful of ingredients yields a memorable dessert or breakfast treat! Everyone loves an Apple Fitter!

When cranberries are in season, this pie will get rave reviews! Its different and delicious! Get the recipe for this vintage Nantucket Cranberry Pie.

Post updated March 5, 2020Originally published May 12, 2017.


  • In your mixing bowl, whip the cream on high until stiff peaks begin to form.
  • Add in vanilla and powdered sugar and whip until firm whipped cream happens.
  • Scrape into a pastry bag fitted with a decorative tip and when ready (an hour before serving or so, decorate your pie.
  • Sprinkle a little fresh lime zest over-top.
  • Keep pie chilled until serving.

Also Check: Campbell Soup Turkey Pot Pie Recipe

Give The Gift Of Pie: 6 Mail

Don’t wrap that ill-fitting, itchy sweater. Instead, give the gift of pie. Unique, regional pies from all over the country — pies you couldn’t easily make in your kitchen — are the holiday gift of choice for Jane and Michael Stern of They share their six picks for mail-order pies.

1. Key lime pie, Key West Key Lime Pie Co.Key West, Fla.

The Key West Key Lime Pie Co. will send you a magnificent, true, authentic Key lime pie. Of course you have to get it 2-day service, but this is the classic, real Florida Key lime pie. If you don’t like pie, they will also send you Key lime pie bars, which are a slice of Key lime pie enrobed in chocolate and sent to you in dry ice. You can eat Key lime pie chocolate coated on a stick — talk about heaven.

The best mince pie we ever had was from the Red Truck Bakery in Warrenton, Va. It’s in the most gorgeous part of Virginia. The guy who owns it said, “I am on a one-man crusade to resurrect the traditional mince pie.” It is the sumptuous, suet-rich pastry with lots of bourbon and sugar. It’s just wonderful. This is as luxurious as a pie can be. I don’t know how much bourbon is in it, but it really does taste intoxicating.

3. Peanut butter pie, Dan’s Peanut Butter Pies Newbury Park, Calif., 368-7664

4. Apple pie baked in a paper bag, The Elegant FarmerMukwonago, Wis.

5. Salty honey walnut pie, Three Babes BakeshopSan Francisco

6. Pie-of-the-month plan, Royers Round Top CafeRound Top, Texas

Best Ever Key Lime Pie

Make this fantastic pie now while fresh key limes are available at the supermarket!


My husband Jack and I have shared an obsession for Key Lime Pie ever since our early days of dating.

One year, because of work schedules, neither of us could travel to see family for the Thanksgiving holiday. So instead, we decided to both volunteer to help cook and serve Thanksgiving dinner at a local church homeless shelter. One of the nearby restaurants donated key lime pies for dessert and they were the truly best key lime pies weve ever had!

Fast forward to today Jack and I both still dream about those pies! Finally, we recreated our own version of the Best Ever Key Lime Pie and were sharing it with all of you today.

Recommended Reading: Bean Pie Recipe Muhammad Speaks

What Youll Need To Make Key Lime Pie

  • Youll need 8 to 10 limes total for this recipe. Choose plump limes that give a little when you squeeze them they will be easier to juice. You should get about 2 tablespoons of juice from each lime. Be sure to zest the limes before you squeeze the juice from them, as its near impossible to do afterward.
  • Sweetened condensed milk is canned milk from which water has been removed, and sugar has been added. Be sure not to confuse it with evaporated milk, which is usually sold right alongside.
  • With no eggs, it may be hard to believe that this pie will set, but have faith it will.

What Are The Ingredients In Key Lime Pie

Low Carb KEY LIME PIE Battle – The BEST Keto Key Lime Pie Recipe!

Traditionally, a key lime pie’s filling consists of key lime juice, egg yolks, and sweetened condensed milk. It typically sits in a graham cracker crust, although it can also be cooked in a more traditional pie crust. It is sometimes served without a topping but often has a light meringue topping made from egg whites or whipped cream. The pie is served chilled.

You May Like: Damgoode Pies Little Rock Delivery

Worst Blogger Everand The Best Mango Lime Pie And Key Lime Pie Ever

Sooooohows it going? I guess its been a little while since my last post. Ive been meaning to write, but as you can see that hasnt panned out too well. Im starting to feel like the parent who promises to take their kid fishing at the cabin and then bails at the last minute and leaves the kid sad and disappointed on the front stoop decked out in all their fishing gear . As it turns out though, I have a legitimate excuse for being such a neglectful blogger the past couple months. Business has been steadily growing over the summer and Im currently looking into expanding The Earnest Baker. Hopefully Ill have some exciting news to share within the next couple months, so stay tuned for that!

As most of you know, I started selling my products at the Farmers Market a couple months ago. Business has been great and its been such a wonderful experience getting to share my baked goods, meeting the other vendors, and just being a part of the Market community. What Ive enjoyed most about the market is talking to and getting to know all my regular customers. I cant even begin to describe how stoked I am to have people who stop by each week to pick up their favorite baked goods. Ive always loved having that neighborhood bakery feeling where the regulars come in and you greet them by name and know their usual order. Thats the feeling I strive to recreate with The Earnest Baker. You know, kind of like Cheers, but with homemade Pop Tarts instead of beer.

I Found It Interesting That Traditional Key Lime Pies Down In The Keys Are Topped With Meringue Like A Lemon Meringue Pie My Husband Loves Key Lime Pie And Orders It Out When He Comes Across It Yet I Never Saw One In

Going into the challenge we all knew we had to make a Key Lime Pie. Of alllll the things I have made in my life, a Key Lime Pie wasnt one of them. So, a few days before the competition I made a few variations to see which my family enjoyed more.

We each were allowed to bring a secret ingredient to make our Key Lime Pie. My first thought was tequila, so I made one in my test run with that. My second thought was sour cream.

Also Check: Campbells Soup Chicken Pot Pie

My Prize Winning Key Lime Pie Recipe Came Together Quickly So Since I Had Extra Time I Decided To Use Leftover Limes And Make Some Candied Lime Peel Which I Had Actually Thought About Making At Home As My Secret Ingredient But Then Thought Nope Limes Sugar And Water Will Be Thereif I Have Time I Will Make That There So I Can Bring Something That Wont Be

While our pies chilled, we got down to our second challengethe mystery ingredient from the Florida Keys which turned out to be beautiful Yellow Tail Snapper fillets. I had never worked with or eaten it before, however, I am pretty familiar with halibut, so I figured it was similar to cook with.

Ingredients were set out for us to choose from. Things like flour, Panko, mango, tomatoes, breadcrumbs, eggs, spices, herbs and much more. I saw coconut milkand I saw many going for breading or flour as well as mango so I quickly decided to do something I thought no one would do. A curry sauce, similar to one of my favorite ways to prepare halibutTake a look at my recipe for Pan Seared Halibut in Thai Curry Sauce.

I am not talking about using curry powder, instead, a is curry defined as cooking down vegetables and herbs. So I grabbed tomatoes, ginger, onion, etc. I cooked them down and finished the sauce with coconut milk and seasonings. Whatever I could find in that kitchen to give it the flavors I was thinking of in my head, I grabbed. As far as the fish, I simply pan-fried it with seasonings, then sat it atop the sauce I made.

Judges came around and tried each of our dishes as we raised our hands once complete . I kept hearing Gordon Ramsay in my head. Stick to one thingdo it well, taste, taste, taste so thats what I did. Each judge independently tasted and scored our yellow-tail snapper entrée as well as our pie. Then the scores were merged.

How We Chose The Best Key Lime Pie Delivery Services

Key Lime Pie â Sweet Serendipity

To select the best services, we weighed company history and accolades, quality of ingredients used in the pies, customer reviews, and pricing. A variety of flavors and other related items were also considered. For example, Key Lime Pie Company was chosen for its previous recognition in pie contests and best pie categories in addition to its century-old family recipe, while Kermits Key West Key Lime Shoppe was selected for its accolades as well as its extensive selection of key lime pie products.

Also Check: Chocolate Key Lime Pie On A Stick

The Five Best Places To Get Key Lime Pie In Key West

Key Lime Pie

JMichl / Getty

The Florida Keys are iconic for many reasons: the Beach Boys wrote songs about the islands, while Ernest Hemingway fished off its waters and wrote along its piers. But perhaps the singular most important contribution that Key West has provided to American culture is Key Lime Pie: a distillation of those laid-back island vibes into one singular dessert, thatlike Key West itselfis difficult to resist.

sign in Key West

cristianl / Getty

You will be unsurprised to discover that, to this day, Key West remains the best place in the world to consume this local delicacy. The Florida town is the birthplace of the dessert, after allthough that has been hotly contested on the internet For foodies and local historians alike, the Curry Mansion on 511 Caroline Street, built in 1868, is hallowed ground. The one-time residence of Floridas first self-made millionaire, William Curry, is allegedly where the magic happened, when his Aunt Sally invented the soon-to-be-iconic recipe in the mansions kitchen.

Key Lime Pie

mphillips007 / Getty

Though Aunt Sally may have had the first inclination to mix cake batter with lime, her innovation has since been reworked and refined in the past century. Whether you prefer your Key Lime Pie served on a popsicle, or in a jar , here are the best haunts for devouring the iconic Floridian dessert in Key West.

El Mason de Pepe

El Mason De Pepe

Key West Key Lime Shoppe

Key West Key Lime Shoppe

Kermits Key West Key Lime Shoppe

Popular Recipes

More Recipes Like This