Best Mail Order Apple Pie

Must Try

Are Mail Order Pies Actually A Reasonable Substitute For Homemade

Pies That Fly! (Mail Order Program)

If youre like many of us here at Dandelion Chandelier, youre a working parent or busy professional with lots of plates spinning at any given moment. And yet . . . when fall comes sweeping in and the holiday meals approach, we feel obligated to bake pie. Whether we know what were doing or not!

The best places to buy apple pie online via mail order now for the fall 2021 holidays, including pies for Thanksgiving and Christmas.

Blue Duck Tavern Washington Dc

Chef Sebastien Archambault and pastry chef Naomi Gallego rely on a wood-burning oven for most of the upgraded tavern classics served at this restaurant in the Park Hyatt. Texas-born Archambault trained in Paris , and both locales influenced his 6-inch apple pie. A nod to French pastry, this version of the American classic has a crispy and butter-heavy crust, with a dark caramel and an acidic swirl of Granny Smith apples. Though the award-winning menu changes every six weeks, the pie has remained untouched since its introduction in 2006.

Pumpkin & Cookies Mochi Ice Cream By Mochidoki 4 For $10


Though not technically a baked good, Mochidokis ice cream stuffed rice cakes are sure to provide a sweet end to any holiday meal. Flavors run the gamut from Black Honey Walnut to Vegan Lychee, but if you want a taste of the holidays, Pumpkin & Cookies cant be beat. This seasonal mochi features pumpkin spice ice cream studded with chocolate and vanilla creme cookies for the ultimate two-bite dessert. For now, shipping is only available around the eastern United States so cross your fingers and make sure your state is on the list. Buy Now

You May Like: How Long Do You Bake Shepherd’s Pie

Our 100% Satisfaction Guarantee

We promise you will be 100% happy with not only your products, but your entire Tastes of Chicago experience.

Customer Service is our passion. If you have a problem with any of our products, customer service representatives or shipping please let us know. You and those who receive our package must be delighted or we will make things right.

Welcome To The Maine Pie Co

The Best Mail Order Pies That Look and Taste Gourmet

Filled to the brim with the finest, freshest ingredients, The Maine Pie Co. is the best gluten-free pie ever! Delicious Maine made pies are assembled, generously filled and frozen at our designated gluten-free facility in Biddefords North Dam Mill. Our unbaked, frozen pies allow customers to have a homemade, tasty gluten-free dessert, on demand and always fresh. Crafted with experience and a love for baking, we offer traditional flavors like Apple and Blueberry and new favorites like Threeberry. We offer seasonal pies as well, each bursting with irresistible flavor combinations: available April through September, try our Strawberry Rhubarb Crumb pie, overflowing with fresh summer fruits. Just in time for the holidays enjoy our delicious Pecan and Pumpkin pies. And for that special occasion or change of pace, bake up our delicious Lemon Curd Tart and rich Chocolate Tarts. Theyre available year round and perfect for a hostess gift, for parties, or as an easy, everyday indulgence. The Maine Pie Co. will leave your family and friends saying,

This cant be gluten free, it tastes too good!



You May Like: Bob’s Red Mill Gluten Free Pie Crust Mix

Mamans Nutty Chocolate Chip Cookies 12 For $65


There is no occasion that wont be improved by chocolate chip cookies, and these beauties from Maman bakery are packed full of dark chocolate chunks and a blend of salted nuts for crunch. They were Oprah-annointed in 2017 and are still a delicious contender for best chocolate chip cookie in NYCbut you can order them from anywhere in the continental U.S.Buy Now

Baltimore Bomb From Dangerously Delicious: Baltimore

Pie meets rock and roll at this Baltimore pie shop, which was founded by baker, band front man and former Food Network Star contestant Rodney Henry. The pie shop hosts a few music events alongside their full menu of both sweet and savory pies. The Baltimore Bomb a shop original is packed with Maryland-made Berger cookies melted into a vanilla chess filling and served in a saltier crust to balance out the sweetness.

Also Check: Best Chicken Pot Pie Recipe

Mcconnells Pumpkin Pie Ice Cream $12


Who says ice cream is only for summer? Vanilla is a classic for topping pies, but youll find plenty of delicious seasonal fall and winter flavors from several ice cream companies that ship nationwide, including California favorite McConnells. Their ultra creamy pints are always made from grass-fed milk and cream, and this one is swirled with roast pumpkin puree warmly spiced with cinnamon, ginger, cloves, and molasses.Buy Now

Banana Split Pie From Just Pies: Columbus Ohio

Order a Pie Online

Just Pies is, fittingly, all about pies, with more than 35 varieties, including apple crumb, Boston cream, Buckeye and German chocolate pecan. A fan favorite is the special Banana Split pie, mashing the favorite childhood ice cream treat with pie, layering chocolate, strawberries and banana cream piled high with whipped cream a dash of sprinkles on top.

Don’t Miss: Where To Buy Steak And Kidney Pie

Four And Twenty Blackbirds

Liana L. / Yelp

The Big Apple serves some of the best apple pie in America. Brooklyn-based bakery Four and Twenty Blackbirds was founded in 2009 by sisters Melissa and Emily Elsen, who were born and raised in rural South Dakota, and they brought their small-town recipes to the big city. Their salted caramel apple pie is the shops most popular order. They combine homemade caramel sauce with sweet and tart apples straight from the Hudson Valley of New York.

Best Cherry: Grand Traverse Pie Company

Grand Traverse Pie Company

Grand Traverse Pie Company, named for the city of its location, takes local, Michigan-grown produce and whips it into perfect pies that Oprah has endorsed. Their Cherry Crumb pie is the signature of the Traverse City National Cherry Festival, a celebration of the cherryone of Michigan’s most delicious exports. This award-winning pie is perfectly sweet and tart, with a tang that zips your tongue and a buttery crumb topping.

The company serves pies with everything a pie-lover could want, from apples and blueberries to cream pies, peaches, pumpkins, and more. Grand Traverse’s ever-popular Michigan ABC pie is a combination of apples, blueberries, and cherries that melds into a delicious mix.

Everything is available on their website with the standard option of two-day shipping to make sure the pies are kept fresh. Pies can even be customized with messages like “I Heart You” or “No. 1 Mom” for an extra-special touch. Another delicious option to consider is the pie of the month club.

Don’t Miss: One Peanut Butter Pie Bars

Six Of America’s Best Apple Pies

Has traveled to 130 countries and written about them all

It’s no surprise that one out of every four American’s favorite pie is apple. But if you think cherry pie is the next favorite, you’re wrong. Tied for second are pumpkin and chocolate cream pies, and in third place is another tie: cherry and pecan.

Apple pie was not always such a favorite. In the 14th century, sugar was scarce and expensive, so pies were made without it. Back in those days, no one ate the pastry , and was used both as both the baking dish and as a serving vessel.

Later, sugar became readily available and finally, pie lovers could eat the crust. Apple pie recipes are usually passed down from mothers and grandmothers, but if you don’t bake, don’t worry. Either hit the road or pick up the phone and order one. Here are six places offering some of America’s best apple pies:

So go ahead — try one — but remember, there’s no free lunch, so if you don’t want to gain the weight, plan to walk it off, run it off, hike or swim it off, do a Zumba class or whatever else it takes for you to burn 600-1,200+ calories.

Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie Ovenly



Cant decide on whether to serve cookies or pie for Thanksgiving dessert? Choose both. Brooklyns esteemed sweets shop, Ovenly, offers a 9-inch cookie pie crammed with chocolate chips and gooey caramel and sprinkled with flaky sea salt. Add a customized message on top in pastel icing . Then, top a slice with ice cream for a cookie pie a la mode.

Don’t Miss: How To Make Strawberry Pie

The Best Classic Pies To Order Online

  • $75

Prices taken at time of publishing.

If youre looking for a no-fuss option to serve to picky family members who prefer their pies traditional, editor Elle Simone Scott of Americas Test Kitchen recommends ordering from this Black-owned bakery. Justice of the Pies is not just baking pies in the name of social justice, although the end justifies the means, she says. Its also some of the most creative and decadent pie offerings Ive seen in a long time. Her favorite is the classic bourbon pecan, but it has a very Thanksgiving-appropriate apple pie, too.

  • $65

Prices taken at time of publishing.

Why limit yourself to just one kind of pie? Brenna Houck, editor of Eater Detroit, recommends going for this mini-pie gift box from Michigans Zingermans Bakehouse, which includes a traditional toasted-pecan pie, a chocolate chess pie, and a pleasantly tart and tangy cranberry-walnut pie.

  • $35

Prices taken at time of publishing.

  • $40

Prices taken at time of publishing.

If you or your Thanksgiving guests have dietary restrictions, Three Babes Bakeshop in the Bay Area makes a delicious pecan pie minus the gluten. I tried their pie a few years back at the farmers market at the Ferry Building, where they sell seasonal specials by the slice, and they are truly amazing, says Caroline Schiff, pastry chef at Fort Defiance General Store in Brooklyn . And if you dont have any dietary restrictions, Three Babes sells an outstanding gluten-full bourbon-pecan pie as well.

Best Brunch Pie: Dangerously Delicious Pies

Dangerously Delicious Pies

SPRUCE15 for $15 off of minimum $50 spend, first time customers only, excludes shipping, standard T& C applies.

Baltimores legendary pie shop Dangerously Delicious Pies, led by musician-turned-pie-maker Rodney Henry, is known for its unique and creative pies. One of the shop’s most famous creations, the Blueberry Pancake Pie, has been called one of the best pies in America by People magazine. Made with pancake batter and fresh berries, this pie is a sweet, fluffy combination of breakfast and dessert.

That’s not all the shop sells, however. The Baltimore Bomb is a gooey, fudgy chess pie stuffed with Berger cookies, a cakey, chocolate frosting-covered treat made in the city.

Another tasty treat is the quiche pie, which is perfect for a weekend brunch. And if youre in Maryland, that quiche must contain crab. The shop’s Crab and Cheddar quiche is loaded with lump crab meat and sharp cheddar cheese and is topped with the local favorite Old Bay seasoning for a perfect sampling of Maryland cuisine.

If youre worried about shipping crab meat, the pie comes frozen. Just pop it into your oven at 350 degrees for 25 to 30 minutes before serving. And dont forget to whip up a homemade Orange Crush, a mixed drink with orange juice, vodka, and triple sec you cant have brunch in Baltimore without it.

Recommended Reading: Pyrex Deep Dish Pie Plate

The Apple Pan Los Angeles

This L.A. landmark has been selling Hickory hamburgers since 1947. Dedicated customers allow little change: When the horseshoe-shape diner introduced new fries, people noticed and demanded the old styles return. Equally famous is Apple Pans pie, a perfect example of the diner pie: flat, with a thin crust and sweet, soft-cooked apples. Owner Sunny Shermans grandmother came up with the restaurant name out of the blue. It might be random, but the name stuck. No website 310-475-3585

Rhubarb Pie From Purple Pie Place: Custer South Dakota

The Only APPLE PIE Recipe You’ll Need

This seasonal haunt, down the street from Mount Rushmore at the foot of the Black Hills, is hard to miss for its bold purple and pink exterior. Although there is a full menu, the pies are a real draw evident by hundreds of slices ordered each week, along with full pies. Anything rhubarb is worth trying whether it be the simple rhubarb pie or the sweet, spicy and tangy rhubarb-raspberry-jalapeno.

Read Also: How To Cook Chicken For Chicken Pot Pie

Fresh From The Oven To Your Door: 15 Amazing Online Pie Companies

This might just be the greatest invention since sliced bread. No running to the store for butter, no cursing when you burn your hand on the oven and no crying when your laborious pie crust is burnt to a crisp. Weve found your saving grace pie bakers who deliver the goods to your door with a click of the mouse. Believe us when we tell you that your taste buds will be giving thanks once they get a load of the tastiest slices that can be shipped from the Atlantic to the Pacific. Whether you fess up to the fact that you didnt make them yourself is entirely up to you.

1. Achatz Handmade Pie Company : Described as iconic, gooey and from another dimension, Achatzs pies are homegrown and handmade right from a Michigan orchard. They churn out flavors that will get the old drool going. Were talking taste combos like Apple Caramel Nut, Michigan 4-Berry or Double Crust Peach Pie.

2. Bubbys : Bubbys cranks out pie pastry with organic butter and house rendered lard from heritage hogs from family farms. Choose from Classic Pumpkin Pie or Michigan Sour Cherry but the Apple Whiskey Crumble Pie is whats tickling our taste buds.

3. Butter and Scotch : When your business is named Butter and Scotch anything you make has to be good. Try some holiday-centric pies, like Pumpkin Spice, Bourbon Ginger Pecan and Smores.

12. Two Fat Cats Bakery : What can we say? Life is short, eat more pie. But make sure its true, honest-to-goodness pie like these from Two Fat Cats Bakery.

Smores Pie Butter & Scotch


Another winner from Brooklyns Butter & Scotch, this smores pie layers smooth milk chocolate custard into a graham cracker crust and tops the whole thing with piles of marshmallow topping that gets torched until its nice and toasty. Its the perfect winter treat with a summer campfire feel.

Also Check: Apple Pie Baked In A Paper Bag

Key Lime Pie From Kermit’s: Key West

Few trips to Key West are complete without some of the regions namesake Key lime pie. Its the signature dessert, and though most restaurants serve it, Kermits is the place to get it. The shop specializes in everything Key lime, including sauces and candies but the real treat is the classic Key lime pie filled with tart key lime curd spread into a graham cracker crust and decorated with dollops of whipped cream.

Popular Recipes

More Recipes Like This