Where Did The Whoopie Pie Originate
There is actually quite a great deal of controversy surrounding the origin of the whoopie pie and which state is responsible for its creation. Generally considered to be both a classic New England treat and also a favorite tradition of the Pennsylvania Amish, no one knows definitively where the first whoopie pie was made. Historical records of whoopie pies from the early 1900’s have traced its birthplace to any one of the following US states: New Hampshire, Virginia, Massachusetts, Pennsylvania, and Maine.
While each state has its own “claim to fame” for the first whoopie pies on record, Maine has gone as far as declaring it the official state treat by official legislature, and as such, seems to hold the highest bragging rights in the great debate. One whoopie pie bakery, Labadie’s Bakery of Lewiston, Maine, claims to have been selling them since their opening in 1925. Conveniently enough, there is no documented proof to back up the story, but Mainers insist that the creation is theirs. Originally named the Maine state dessert in 2011 the whoopie pie was eventually reclassified as the Maine state treat to allow the blueberry pie as the Maine state dessert, thanks to a local abundance of wild blueberries.
What Is Whoopie Pie
The best way to describe a whoopie pie is that its a mini chocolate cake sandwich in cookie form. It is made of two round pieces of chocolate cake, with a creamy filling or frosting sandwiched between them. A traditional filling is a marshmallow filling, but different kinds of buttercream are widely used too. The original and most commonly used flavor of whoopie pies is chocolate, but you can find other flavors such as pumpkin, or vanilla. The batter is soft, something between a cake batter and a cookie dough, and the texture of the cake is tender. Whoopie pies taste like a really good frosted chocolate cake.
Pa Dutch Whoopie Pie Recipe
Make this Lancaster County favorite no matter where you live!
Whoopie Pies Cake Ingredients
– 1 cup of warm water
Preparing the Cakes In a large bowl, combine flour, salt, cocoa, and baking soda. Mix and set aside. In another bowl, combine the sugar, shortening and eggs. Beat for about two minutes. Mix the dry ingredients with the egg mixture and add the warm water and milk and beat at a medium speed for two to three minutes. Add the vanilla and beat until the ingredients are thoroughly blended. Bake the batter as drop cookies. Drop by rounded tablespoons onto ungreased non-stick cookie sheets. Bake in a preheated oven at 375° for 10 to 12 minutes or until the center of the “cookies” spring back when lightly pressed. Remove from the cookie sheets and cool a wire rack.
– 4 cups confectioner’s sugar
Preparing the Filling Beat the egg whites until stiff then set them aside. Combine the other ingredients and beat vigorously for several minutes at a high speed. Fold in the beaten egg whites.
Whoopie Pie Assembly Spread a generous amount of filling on a completely cooled cookie and then top with another cookie. To preserve your newly created treat, wrap each whoopie pie individually in plastic wrap.
Don’t Miss: Key Lime Pie Company Key West
How To Tell If Whoopie Pies Have Spoiled
You can check to see if theyre still okay to eat by the sight, smell, and taste. If theyre hard, very dry, or look off then they should be discarded.
Additionally, you can smell them, and if they have a bad smell they should also be thrown away.
Finally, if they taste bad, then they should be tossed into the bin. You shouldnt risk eating potentially spoiled whoopie pies.
Dutch Country Bakery In The Bristol Amish Market
Price: Regular: $1.15 minis: $5.99 for a 12-pack
If you cant get out to Lancaster County, you can still indulge in Pennsylvania Dutch desserts from The Dutch Country Bakery in the Bristol Amish Market. They have shelves filled with cakes, muffins, breads, and whoopie pies, both regular and minis . Aside from chocolate and vanilla, they offer a luscious red velvet, a rich and smooth peanut butter with cream cheese icing, a refreshing mint, and oatmeal.
Recommended Reading: Key West Key Lime Pie Company Recipe
How To Freeze Whoopie Pies
Now that you have a decent understanding of not only the intriguing background of whoopie pies, as well as the pros and cons, and how well they freeze, lets get into how you actually freeze them. Its super easy!
- First, you should decide how you want to freeze them. You can freeze them in a batch or conversely you can freeze them individually. I personally prefer freezing them individually wrapped and stored as you arent obligated to defrost more than what you plan on eating. Also, theyre less likely to stick together if theyre wrapped individually.
- Next, prepare them for freezing.For the individual method, wrap each whoopie pie in plastic wrap. If you want to store them together in a bag without the wrapping, place them on a cookie sheet and allow them to freeze. If you dont like using so much plastic wrap then this is a good option as well.
- Then, take the wrapped or individually frozen whoopie pies and place them into a freezer-safe bag or container.
- Label the bag or container and then place them in the freezer.
- Use within three to six months for the best quality whoopie pies.
Whoopie Pies In Maine
Oddly enough, the iconic Whoopie pie has never been officially classified as a pie, cookie, or cake. A true Maine whoopie consists of two dark-chocolate rounds, around the size of a hamburger, with a rich, dense filling sandwiched in-between. Some bakers have adapted this traditional treat to include pumpkin or gingerbread rounds, typically offered during the festive fall season. Despite how tasty these close-cousins of the original Whoopie pie may be, the deep, rich chocolate version with white, velvety filling remains a regional favorite.
The key to a perfect whoopie is when the cookie rounds are soft and dense, rich and not too sweet. The fluffy, white filling complements the whoopie pie, and traditionally is made with vegetable shortening, often called oleo in Maine homes, rather than butter or margarine. This results in a rich, smooth filling that provides the perfect bite in-between the soft baked layers. Legend has it that the Whoopie pie may have been conceived during a time when cooks would want to use up their leftover cake batter in a practical, prudent way. The result is a delicious, distinctive treat that remains a Maine favorite for decades.
Recommended Reading: Easy Bean Pie Recipe
How To Bake Soft Cake Like Chocolate Cookies
- When ready to bake, preheat the oven to 350F. Line sheet trays with parchment paper.
- With a medium-sized cookie scoop, portion out the cookies . Dont be surprised if the dough looks like blobs. It does spread when baking but I was able to fit 10 cookies on my sheet trays. This recipe should give you around 22-24 cookies.
- If your scooped cookies look very rough, you can lightly moisten your hands and smooth out the top of the cookies.
- Bake the cookies, one tray at a time, at 350F for 10-11 minutes. The cookies are done when the edges are set and the middle still looks a bit underbaked.
- Remove the cookies from the oven and allow them to cool completely. If you want to move them to a cooling rack after 5-10 minutes I recommend using an offset knife or butter knife to remove them from the parchment. The cookies can stick to the parchment paper.
What Is A Whoopie Pie
Whoopie Pies are a classic treat across New England and Pennsylvania . Two soft chocolate cookies filled with vanilla frosting or marshmallow fluff make up for this handheld snack. The original flavor was chocolate but these days many variations can be found including my delicious recipe for Gluten Free Gingerbread Whoopie Pies.
There are many stories about how a whoopie pie got its name. Pennsylvania claims that whoopie pies go back centuries in their state, originating in Amish kitchens. Amish women would create little pies/cakes for their families, who would find them in their lunch boxes and shout out Whoopie!
You May Like: Campbells Mini Chicken Pot Pie
Where To Buy Whoopie Pies In Lancaster Pa
The whoopie pie is an all-American baked good of many colorful names: black moon, gob, black-and-white, bob, or BFO for Big Fat Oreo. To us, here in Lancaster County, they are known as whoopie pies, our beloved favorite dessert. No matter what you call the Pennsylvania Dutch treat, you can find homemade whoopie pies made from scratch at our local Lancaster County bakeries.
Where To Find The Best Whoopie Pies Around New England
We were shocked to read that Pennsylvania takes credit for the invention of the whoopie pie. As the story goes, in the early 1920s, Amish wives put these circular confections into their husbands lunchboxes, inspiring the guys to say Whoopee! Mainers roundly dispute that theory and contend that the first official whoopie was created at a bakery called Labadies in Lewiston in 1925.
Sure, both states host a whoopie pie festival. But credit for the Worlds Largest Whoopie Pie, baked in 2011 and weighing in at 1,062 pounds goes to . . . ta dah! Maine. The Pennsylvania record is a measly 230 pounds. And it took New Englanders to create the magical ingredient, Marshmallow Fluff , that elevated the whoopie pie to classic dessert status.
Whats more, the whoopie pie was designated the Official State Treat of Maine in 2011 Ive talked to many tourists who say one of the major items on their Maine to-do list is trying a whoopie pie, says Alex Campbell of Two Fat Cats Bakery in Portland. The whoopie pie is definitely ingrained in Maine cuisine and culture. Heres a look at some worth-every-sugar-gram whoopies.
Labadies Bakery, Lewiston, Maine
Most winning whoopie: The perfection that is chocolate cake-meets-vanilla cream. They ship to all 50 U.S. states and military addresses around the world. 161 Lincoln St., Lewiston, Maine www.whoopiepies.com.
Two Fat Cats Bakery, Portland and S. Portland, Maine
Wicked Whoopies, Freeport and Farmingdale, Maine
Whoo Wagon, Topsfield
Also Check: Key West Key Lime Pie On A Stick
Tasty Whoopie Pie Variations
The original and most commonly made Whoopie pie is chocolate, almost a devils food in many recipes. Maple Whoopie pies provide another popular choice, embracing the region with pure Maine maple syrup baked into dense, moist cake, and paired with the beloved rich, white filling, for a fall sweet that is worth waiting for! Some inventive bakeries and establishments in Maine serve Whoopie pie cake which amounts to a cake-sized version of this popular regional treat, filled with the traditional white icing and left un-frosted.
Some tips for making whoopies that resemble the Maine original include quality ingredients and perfect cook time. The distinction of a whoopie pie and any sandwich-style pastry is the texture, which comes from the consistency of the batter. Maine bakers have perfected this technique to produce a cake that is dense, moist and deliciously chocolatey, while the filling has to be sweet, smooth velvet on the tongue. Wrapped in plastic when warm produces a shiny, slick surface that melts in the mouth- and on the fingers!
Our Top 10 Best Whoopie Pie Recipe On The Market
It is quite a common phenomenon to be confused over which is the best whoopie pie recipe to buy. This dilemma arises due to the existence of various types of whoopie pie recipes that are present in the market. To reduce your conundrum, we have prepared a comprehensive guide of how you may pick the top whoopie pie recipes available in the market.
Disclaimer: We are using Amazon affiliate Product Advertising API to fetch products from Amazon, include: price, content, image, logo, brand, feature of products which are trademarks of Amazon.com. So, when you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.. Read more.
Read Also: Black Muslim Bean Pie
Our Recommended 10 Best Whoopie Pie Recipe Reviews 2022
- STURDY AND NON-STICK: This pan is made from durable steel with a non-stick finish that’s easy to use and easier to clean up. Prepare your favorite recipe’s batter, bake and cool, then slide right out of the pan to decorate with your favorite icing or toppings.
- MAKE DELICIOUS WHOOPIE PIES: Create delicious baked whoopie pies with this easy-to-use pan. Since these pies are baked, not fried, you can make healthier options any day of the week right at home in your own kitchen. Bake, decorate, and share with your friends and family!
- USE AND CARE INSTRUCTIONS: Before first and after each use, wash in warm, soapy water or run through the dishwasher. Rinse and dry thoroughly with soft cloth. Please do not put in a toaster oven or microwave. Each pan is covered by Wilton’s Limited 10-year warranty contact seller for further details.
- EVERYONE, EVERYWHERE, EVERY DAY: Innovative products. Mouthwatering inspiration. Fun in the kitchen. This has been at the heart of what we do for nearly 90 years. Whether youre hosting a party or need to bring a special treat, Wilton has you covered.
- Used Book in Good Condition
- Griffin, Nancy
How To Assemble And Store Gluten Free Chocolate Whoopie Pies
To assemble the Gluten Free Chocolate Whoopie Pies, use a medium-sized cookie scoop and place the filling in the middle of one cookie. Top with a second cookie and gently press them together. The filling may squish out on the sides but who said Whoopie pies cant be messy.
Whoopie Pies are the best when eaten fresh. If you would like to make them in advance of time, fill them as directed and place them in an airtight container and refrigerate for up to 5 days.
To freeze Whoopie pies, freeze them on a sheet tray first and then wrap each individual pie in plastic wrap before transferring them to a ziplock bag or airtight container. Freeze up to 3 months. Thaw in your refrigerator.
You may also just freeze the unfilled gluten-free gingerbread cookies for up to 3 months and fill them as directed when thawed.
You May Like: Gordon Ramsay Key Lime Pie
Best Recommendations And Buying Guide For Your Whoopie Pie Recipe
Before you venture out to purchase your preferred whoopie pie recipe, take into consideration some factors. These factors will ultimately help you decide which whoopie pie recipe is the right fit for your requirements.
Use the internet to do your research about all the available whoopie pie recipes in the market. This is helpful for both online and retail/ in-person purchases. If you are buying from an online marketplace, try to ascertain the most trustworthy online store. Usually, the online shops that have the highest following of masses are the best ones.
These shops not only provide reliable products but also give the buyers a lot of diversified products to choose from. Search for the different types of whoopie pie recipe available in the online store and find ones to choose from.
Read the reviews of people on the online pages to understand the detailed and nuanced pros and cons that entail this particular whoopie pie recipe. You can also understand through other peoples reviews whether a particular whoopie pie recipe fits your needs.
Assessing products online before buying the desired products from retail shops is also a very common phenomenon.
While doing the crucial research on the whoopie pie recipes available in the market, you might ask yourself a few questions that will help you reach your decision: