Chocolate Key Lime Pie Key West

Must Try

Key West Key Lime Pie Company

Key West’s Kermit Carpenter … Mr. Key Lime Pie

If we dont make it, we dont sell it is the motto for Key West Key Lime Pie Company. Theyve also been voted a favorite from some big names, including Food Networks Throw Down With Bobby Flay and CNBCs The Profit with Marcus Lemonis.

Their traditional key lime pies are a favorite, but they also play around with a few other flavors, including mango, blueberry, toasted coconut, and extra tart flavors. Theyll even dip your slice of pie into a rich and decadent chocolate! They also have a gluten free crust, so really something for everyone.

Address: 511 Greene Street, Key West, Florida

Where To Find The Best Key Lime Pie In Key West

There are many reasons to visit Key West in Florida.

From the bars that open at the crack of dawn to the chance to explore the third largest barrier reef in the world and enjoy the endless summer weather. Most importantly, however, is for the key lime pie in Key West.

Theres a lot of delicious foods to try while traveling in Key West. You can expect a wide array of seafood dishes, from lobster and crab to snapper, hogfish and grouper. But there are a few dishes that many consider the official foods of Key West. Conch fritters and key lime pie are among these.

Were here, in partnership with, to talk about key lime pie in Key West. Why you need to try and where you can find the best pie in the city.

What Are The Ingredients In Key Lime Pie

Traditionally, a key lime pies filling consists of key lime juice, egg yolks, and sweetened condensed milk. It typically sits in a graham cracker crust, although it can also be cooked in a more traditional pie crust. It is sometimes served without a topping but often has a light meringue topping made from egg whites or whipped cream. The pie is served chilled.

You May Like: Damgoode Pies Little Rock Delivery

You May Like: Campbells Soup Chicken Pot Pie

Excellent Key Lime Pie On A Stick Dipped In Chocolate

This is a very small shop, barely large enough for a line of people in and out. I ordered the key lime pie on a stick dipped in chocolate, it is great, especially for those who don’t particularly like plain key lime pie.


I have yet to taste a commercially produced key lime pie that’s as good as the ones made by my Florida native wife. I suspect part of that is the traditional recipe she follows , but her pies got me hooked on the concept, so when in the Keys with friends and family, we hunt for the next best thing. We believe we’ve found it at Key Lime ‘N More.We got there by Yelping and checking Trip Advisor — no doubt you’re looking at the other raves. But we also saw very good reviews for the pies from the Key West Key Lime Pie Company . So we bought a pie from each place for a pie-off. The results weren’t even that close. The Key Lime ‘N More pie got 5.5 votes out of 6 . The pie’s custard has just the right tang and texture. I’d ding ’em a little for a crust that’s too thin, and of course it’s still not The Absolute Best. To taste that, you’ll just have to master the traditional recipe and do it yourself.

Hotels In Key West That Serve A Great Key Lime Pie

Chocolate Raspberry Key Lime Pie

What could be better than staying in the best neighborhoods of Key West and that you know serves a great slice of key lime pie? That means pie for breakfast, pie for tea, pie for dessertor just because, any time of day!

Here are a few hotels in Key West that serve delicious key lime pie:

We hope that your tastebuds are salivating and youre ready to head straight to Key West to try out some of the best key lime pie in America! And, while youre thinking about Key West, check out our post featuring the best beaches in Key West.

Don’t Miss: Campbell Soup Chicken Pot Pie Recipe

A Nontraditional Chocolate Crust Versus The Traditional Graham Cracker Crust

Traditionally a graham cracker crust is used, however I wanted to duplicate the key lime pie with chocolate cookie crust I tried. I used ground chocolate cookies, butter, and sugar. After mixing the crumb mixture you simply press into the bottom and along the sides of your pie plate. Bake for 10 minutes at 350 degrees and let it cool while you mix the filling.

Best 9 Bakeries That Deliver Fresh Key Lime Pie Nationwide

204learn more

If youre searching for the best bakeries online that deliver Key lime pie to any doorstep in America, youre in the right place.

Youll see the best options available, how much they cost and what you can expect when you open the shipping box.

In A Rush? Best value Most selection

Key Lime Pies are the perfect balance of juicy, tart Key limes and sweet creamy filling. Unfortunately, making a real authentic Key lime pie can be a bit of a task on your own.but worry not!

Here are the top bakeries that will do the hard work and bake, pack and deliver a fresh Key Lime Pie to your doorstep. All you have to do is open the box and dig in!

Also Check: Américan Pie Band Camp Trailer

Whats In Key Lime Pie

There is some debate about what makes an authentic key lime pie. Graham cracker or pastry crust? Meringue or whipped cream? Cooked or uncooked? Is fresh best, or is store-bought just as good? But generally, here are the commonly accepted ingredients in the iconic, summery pie:

  • Graham Crackers
  • Sweetened Condensed Milk
  • Key Limes

Sounds good, right? Here are the best, most unique, and most beautiful, most delicious key lime pies in all of Key West!

Keep eating: What to Eat in Key West

Frozen Key Lime Pie On A Stick

Key West Key Lime Pie Company Review

While I was growing up, my dad always believed in taking our family on vacations somewhere to culture us kids. We certainly were hard to please. My brother slept at the symphony, while I ate it up. Most of us couldnt get enough of New York , but my brother detests crowds. One place we can all agree on is Key West, Florida. My dad, ever the adventurous one, tried out wind surfing while my mom and I graciously accepted cool towels during sun bathing on the beach. We all met up for Key lime pie every night. On a particularly muggy day in Florida, frozen Key lime pie is the way to go. But dipped in chocolate and put on a stick? Well, thats great for any day.

From: Dessert for Two© 2015 by Christina Lane Buy the book

  • To Make the Crust: Preheat the oven to 350 degrees F, and have a 6-inch pie pan ready.
  • In a small bowl, combine the graham cracker crumbs, sugar, and melted butter. Stir until evenly moist. Press the crumbs into the pie pan, taking care to pack it tightly and up the sides of the pan. Bake on a sheet pan for 10 minutes, then let cool.
  • To Make the Lime Curd Filling: In a medium-size bowl, using an electric mixer on medium speed, beat the egg yolks and condensed milk until light and airy, about 3 minutes. The mixture will be pale in color, and slightly foamy. Next, add the lime zest and Key lime juice and beat until combined. Pour into the piecrust, and freeze overnight.
  • Also Check: Campbell’s Skillet Chicken Pot Pie

    Best Ever Key Lime Pie

    Make this fantastic pie now while fresh key limes are available at the supermarket!


    My husband Jack and I have shared an obsession for Key Lime Pie ever since our early days of dating.

    One year, because of work schedules, neither of us could travel to see family for the Thanksgiving holiday. So instead, we decided to both volunteer to help cook and serve Thanksgiving dinner at a local church homeless shelter. One of the nearby restaurants donated key lime pies for dessert and they were the truly best key lime pies weve ever had!

    Fast forward to today Jack and I both still dream about those pies! Finally, we recreated our own version of the Best Ever Key Lime Pie and were sharing it with all of you today.

    Recommended Reading: Bean Pie Recipe Muhammad Speaks

    Frozones Key Lime Pie Pop

    Inspired by Disneys new treat at Hollywood Studios Neighborhood Bakery, I recreated a summer time treat with a sweet twist! They turned out INCREDIBLE! *pun intended*

    We loved the dance of flavors from the tart Key Lime and sweet white chocolate. Its so refreshing! It would be perfect for a Summer time snack.

    Its pretty easy to make too! Dont forget one thing, you are incredible and all of your friends will think so too when you show up with these Disney inspired treats!

    First, I made the graham cracker crust and let it cool while I made the key lime filling. Then, when it was done baking and chilled, I cut it into eighths, added some popsicle sticks and dipped them into chocolate.

    Thanks Susan from Just a Sunshine State of Mind for the photo of the original pie on a stick and for planting the idea in my head.

    You May Like: Damgoode Pies Little Rock Delivery

    Review Of Key West Key Lime Pie Co

    Good for:Dining options:Description:Key Lime Pie Company disappointing

    I was in the Florida Keys and had to get my key lime pie fix . I have been eating pies from this company for over 20 years. After the company got help from the Profit Marcus Lemonis, the taste improved and was great. This trip I bought a whole pie and was disappointed . The 15 or 20 minute drive home in a cooler with a bag of ice still softened the pie so the consistency wasnt optimal which is my fault . However the taste was blah , not much lime . Tasted like it was mostly whipped cream . The crust was awful. It tasted like a store bought ready made graham cracker crust. A cheap one. We didnt finish the pie which is unlike us. I went by the actual Greene St. Store to try it there to see if those were any different. I was told by the staff that it was the same recipe as what they ship to the stores where I got it so I just left . I wasnt interested in eating it again. I use to haul several pies in a cooler 500 miles home years ago. I can make a better one at home now. Im questioning whether theyve gone back to old habits with lots of ingredients. At least for the ones shipped to the convenience stores. It may be just me but I wont be buying these pies anymore. I feel sad about that family tradition being lost.

    Key Lime Pie: The Best Dessert In The Florida Keys

    The Southernmost Point: A Key West Treat: Chocolate ...

    Confession time: during my recent visit to the Florida Keys I ate Key Lime Pie for breakfast, lunch and dinner every single day. Id like to tell you that this was strictly for research purposes as I embarked on a quest to find the best Key Lime Pie in the Keys, but lets be honest, I just like to eat pie and when its listed on every single menu, it only makes it that much easier for me to indulge in a little sweet somethin somethin.

    I may not have been able to narrow the search down to the best pie , however, I did end up discovering a whole lot of unique variations of the dessert.

    Don’t Miss: Bean Pie Recipe Muhammad Speaks

    Kermits Key West Key Lime Shoppe

    Kermits claims to serve the original key lime pie in Key West. Its been declared the best in the city, even from the Food Network. Their version of the pie also follows the traditional recipe of creamy lemon filling, graham cracker crust and whipped cream on top.

    Kermits Key West Key Lime Shoppe also sells a large variety of other items with a key lime flavor. Including key lime cookies, key lime salsa, key lime chutney, key lime taffy, key lime tea and key lime olive oil.

    Not matter what other key lime pies you try while in Key West, make sure to also visit Kermits!

    Address: 200 Elizabeth St, Key West, Florida

    Kermits Key Lime Pie Shop

    One key lime pie was on every list and recommended by almost everyone we talked to: Kermits! He does several renditions of Floridas signature pie, from Belgian chocolate-dipped to strawberry-flavored to frozen and beyond, but the classic is perfectly tart and topped with three dollops of real whipped cream. It was the first one we ate and the best way to start our key lime journey!

    Kermit also has a cafe serving breakfast and lunch, as well as a shop with everything from key lime soap to key lime cookies, and from key lime seasonings to jellies, salsas, dressings, and dips!

    Key Lime Pie with Whipped Cream

    Still hungry? Iconic Eats Across the USA

    Recommended Reading: Bean Pie Recipe Muhammad Speaks

    Chocolate Dipped Key Lime Pie Stuffed Strawberries

    Key lime pie has always been one of my favorite Summer desserts. It has to be the good kind though, plenty of tart lime and not too sweet. When I was little, my Mom and I found the perfect recipe for it that was the perfect balance, and it always tasted amazing. Especially on a hot Summer day. But a lot of times when we would order key lime pie in a restaurant or buy it somewhere it was never as good and we were disappointed. I remember one year at the Minnesota State fair they had a key lime pie on a stick. Because at our state fair everything has to be on a stick in case any of you were wondering about that. But anyways, I bought one to try, and I was disappointed because it was way too sweet and not tart enough. I liked the concept though, because lime with chocolate is amazing. I have since come up with vegan key lime pie recipes that I enjoy. Like these Chocolate Covered Key Lime Pie Bars, or my Key Lime Pie Shooters, or this Key Lime Cheesecake. I will never tire of key lime pie recipes.

    Popular Recipes

    More Recipes Like This