Best Key Lime Pie Nyc

Must Try

What Is The Origin Of Key Lime Pie

Key Lime Pie (Rob’s Best Recipes)

Early records show the first written recipes of key lime pie date back to the 1930s-1940s, but it was likely being made in homes long before then. There is general consensus that the first key lime pies were made in Key West, Florida, where there is an abundance of key limes. Legend has it that Floridas first self-made millionaire, William Curry, had a cook known as Aunt Sally who created the pie in the late 1800s, while others think that this was already a delicacy first produced by an area fisherman. Some food historians claim it has a completely different origin story, including one that links it to an invention by a milk company in order to sell more sweetened condensed milk. Because of the lack of refrigeration or ice in the Keys in those early days, sweetened condensed milk was the perfect shelf-stable ingredient to use in baking.

Famous Key West Key Lime Pie

Key West Key Lime Pie Co. ships its famous Key lime pie nationwide on Goldbelly! This sweet and tart 9-inch Key lime pie is made with fresh Key limes and topped with whipped cream.

Key Lime Pie gurus Jim Brush and Alison Sloat are a culinary rags-to-riches story. From their humble beginnings selling their signature Key lime pie on the side of the road, to having their Key lime pie named Americas Best Pie by the American Pie Council, the whirlwind ascent of Key West Key Lime Pie Company is a delicious story. The Key West bakery makes each pie by hand with a tried-and-true, 100-year-old recipe featuring real Key lime juice and a handmade graham cracker crust. Everything at Key West Key Lime Pie Co. is made fresh in-house using all-natural ingredients sourced right in Key West, Florida. The old and the new, the sweet and the tart thats Key West Key Lime Pie Co.

Best Brunch Pie: Dangerously Delicious Pies

Dangerously Delicious Pies

SPRUCE15 for $15 off of minimum $50 spend, first time customers only, excludes shipping, standard T& C applies.

Baltimores legendary pie shop Dangerously Delicious Pies, led by musician-turned-pie-maker Rodney Henry, is known for its unique and creative pies. One of the shop’s most famous creations, the Blueberry Pancake Pie, has been called one of the best pies in America by People magazine. Made with pancake batter and fresh berries, this pie is a sweet, fluffy combination of breakfast and dessert.

That’s not all the shop sells, however. The Baltimore Bomb is a gooey, fudgy chess pie stuffed with Berger cookies, a cakey, chocolate frosting-covered treat made in the city.

Another tasty treat is the quiche pie, which is perfect for a weekend brunch. And if youre in Maryland, that quiche must contain crab. The shop’s Crab and Cheddar quiche is loaded with lump crab meat and sharp cheddar cheese and is topped with the local favorite Old Bay seasoning for a perfect sampling of Maryland cuisine.

If youre worried about shipping crab meat, the pie comes frozen. Just pop it into your oven at 350 degrees for 25 to 30 minutes before serving. And dont forget to whip up a homemade Orange Crush, a mixed drink with orange juice, vodka, and triple sec you cant have brunch in Baltimore without it.

You May Like: One Bar Peanut Butter Pie

The History Of Key Lime Pie In Key West

There are a few stories going around about the origins of key lime pie. Some say it originates from New York while others say it was derived from the Magic Lemon Cream Pie published on a promotional brochure by Borden, a producer of condensed milk.

The story told in Key West goes all the way back to the 1800s, when Key West sponge fisherman kept limes on board to prevent sickness. The fisherman, called hookers by the locals, would whip up a sweet treat mixing the limes with condensed milk and sometimes adding a wild bird egg. Theyd pour it over stale Cuban bread and leave it out to set in the sun.

The fishermans wives took it a step further and baked it in a pie crust. It was a modest dessert of the working class, up until Sarah Jane Lowe Curry, the daughter-in-law of Floridas first millionaire started serving it. Known as Aunt Sally, she served it to the children visiting her home and it wasnt long until it was served in every restaurant in Key West.

Best Chicken Pot Pie: Centerville Pie Co

Best Killer Key Lime Pie (and cocktails) to Love In Key ...

Centerville Pie Co.

Located on Cape Cod, Centerville Pie Co. has been serving up this homey classic since Laurie Bowen and Kristin Broadley ditched their day jobs as a deputy sheriff and banker to become “The Pie Ladies.” Oprah Winfrey visited the original bakery in the early days, savored the pulled chicken nestled in a doughy-yet-crisp pot pie, and catapulted the shop to fame by including the dish on three of her best-of lists. The pies are carried in many grocery stores on the East Coast, but now, thanks to their nationwide delivery, anyone in the country can get one.

While chicken pot pie may seem like it isn’t worth shipping across a continent, this isnt a make it at home pot pie: the chicken is slow-cooked in a large pot of broth, delicately hand-pulled, and the pie crust is expertly crimped.

Plus, it comes with extra gravy, because we all need a dappling of sauce under our pot pie slice for the real experience. It arrives uncooked, so crank up that oven, bake for 90 minutes, and enjoy the perfect savory flavor.

Recommended Reading: Recipe For S Mores Pie

Best 9 Bakeries That Deliver Fresh Key Lime Pie Nationwide

204learn more

If youre searching for the best bakeries online that deliver Key lime pie to any doorstep in America, youre in the right place.

Youll see the best options available, how much they cost and what you can expect when you open the shipping box.

In A Rush? Best value Most selection

Key Lime Pies are the perfect balance of juicy, tart Key limes and sweet creamy filling. Unfortunately, making a real authentic Key lime pie can be a bit of a task on your own.but worry not!

Here are the top bakeries that will do the hard work and bake, pack and deliver a fresh Key Lime Pie to your doorstep. All you have to do is open the box and dig in!

Why Are Key Lime Pies For Delivery So Expensive

While $60 and up may seem quite steep for a single pie, this is due to the realities of shipping a box of frozen products via overnight or two-day expedited delivery. These are fixed costs that each company incurs that they either need to factor into the cost of each pie or add on as a delivery surcharge.

Recommended Reading: Aluminum Pie Pans With Lids

Best Iconic Pie: Joes Stone Crab

Joes Stone Crab

Why We Chose It: Joes Stone Crab bakes its classic key lime pie daily and delivers via FedEx Overnight.

  • Good value if ordering multiple pies

  • Only one variety of pie

The iconic Joes Stone Crab in the South Beach district of Miami, Florida, is known for more than stone crabs. Its key lime pie is a signature dessert at the historic establishment that has been around since 1913. Joes Key Lime Pies are baked daily and are available by the slice for locals. For those of us not lucky enough to have Joes Stone Crab in our neighborhood, we can enjoy it as a whole pie via nationwide delivery.

Each 9-inch pie is delivered via FedEx Overnight and will arrive frozen and packed in dry ice. Customers can order up to three pies per order. Because of flat-rate shipping costs, it’s beneficial to order multiple pies at once for the best value while a single pie is $72.95, two pies are $112.95 and three pies are $134.95 . In addition to key lime pie, Joes Stone Crab offers a large selection of other items available for home delivery to round out a delicious meal.

Kermits Key West Key Lime Shoppe

Perfect Key Lime Pie Recipe with Fresh Key Lime Juice

Kermits claims to serve the original key lime pie in Key West. Its been declared the best in the city, even from the Food Network. Their version of the pie also follows the traditional recipe of creamy lemon filling, graham cracker crust and whipped cream on top.

Kermits Key West Key Lime Shoppe also sells a large variety of other items with a key lime flavor. Including key lime cookies, key lime salsa, key lime chutney, key lime taffy, key lime tea and key lime olive oil.

Not matter what other key lime pies you try while in Key West, make sure to also visit Kermits!

Address: 200 Elizabeth St, Key West, Florida

You May Like: No Cow Lemon Meringue Pie Protein Bar

How We Chose The Best Key Lime Pie Delivery Services

To select the best services, we weighed company history and accolades, quality of ingredients used in the pies, customer reviews, and pricing. A variety of flavors and other related items were also considered. For example, Key Lime Pie Company was chosen for its previous recognition in pie contests and best pie categories in addition to its century-old family recipe, while Kermits Key West Key Lime Shoppe was selected for its accolades as well as its extensive selection of key lime pie products.

Hotels In Key West That Serve A Great Key Lime Pie

What could be better than staying in the best neighborhoods of Key West and that you know serves a great slice of key lime pie? That means pie for breakfast, pie for tea, pie for dessertor just because, any time of day!

Here are a few hotels in Key West that serve delicious key lime pie:

We hope that your tastebuds are salivating and youre ready to head straight to Key West to try out some of the best key lime pie in America! And, while youre thinking about Key West, check out our post featuring the best beaches in Key West.

You May Like: Impossibly Easy Chicken Pot Pie

The Best Key Lime Pie In New York City

Enjoy the best Key Lime Pie delivery in New York City with Uber Eats. Enter your address to browse the restaurants and shops offering Key Lime Pie delivery near you, then start comparing your options. Once youve placed your Key Lime Pie order online or via the Uber Eats app, you can track its arrival.

About Key Limes And Pie

Key Lime Pie

Key limes are small, yellowish citrus fruits that are quite different from the darker green Persian limes we see year-round in our local supermarkets.

Key limes are also called Mexican or West Indian limes. They are about the size of a ping-pong ball or a golf ball. They have thinner skin than Persian limes and are not as easily shipped, making them difficult to find. Key limes are sweeter but more tart and aromatic and, unlike the green juice of Persian limes, their juice is a pale yellow.

The creator of the first Key Lime pie was never documented, but food historians say the pie originated in the Florida Keys. Because the Keys were isolated before the railroad was opened in 1912, fresh milk was hard to come by, so authentic Key lime pie is made with canned sweetened condensed milk. This is the ingredient that gives the pie its smooth, creamy filling.

Sweet Streets Key Lime Pie is the real deal. It has the refreshing tartness you would expect from Key limes and a natural, light yellow filling. We make it with the highest-quality eggs, sugar, cream, butter and sweetened condensed milk. The pie has a Graham cracker/ granola crust and we top it off with delicate whipped cream. Perfection!

Today, Key Lime Pie is such an important and popular symbol of Florida that it was designated the official Florida state pie in 2006. It has become one of Americas most-loved regional desserts.

Recommended Reading: Mrs Anderson’s Pie Weights

Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie

Free Lyft

You’ve probably indulged in the best key lime pie in NYC at one of the restaurants it’s served in, or at a grocery store where it can be purchased . But after a bike ride down Van Dyke St., you will be rewarded by a KLP covered in Belgian dark chocolate and served on a stick – The Swingle. You’re welcome. The building, like many other locations in Red Hook, is situated right on the water looking directly west, featuring another pier and park that offers beautiful view. Treat yourself!

Anybody Know Where You Could Get A Key Lime Pie In New York

Im trying to learn the recipe but it seems like a unique flavor I need to try.

Steve’s in red hook is famous for them and they distribute at some groceries. I know sahadis sells them in brooklyn.

Thanks man Im going to look them up now !

Steve’s key lime pie. Thats all he does. His recipe is magical. Looking any further than that is a mistake trust me

Lol he seems like the guy to go to cant wait to check it out thanks

Steve’s are great but just for fun Petees has a great key lime meringue pie, although if you want a full pie i would call ahead and make sure they have one. They also sell by the slice.

Petees is all around killer pie

Oh hi Pitta_, didn’t realize you were here too.

Thanks for the suggestion. Definitely gonna check it out.

Petees is great, easy access, and delivers.

Edit: I say this knowing Steves is IT. But Petees does everything extremely well, including the Key Lime.

Petee’s chocoalte chess pie is magical. Delivered warm.

Best key lime pie at an unexpected place- London Lennies in Rego Park, Queens. Its a seafood restaurant but they make it in-house. Ive had Steves and Petees too and am a pie aficionado but this is by far the best key lime pie slice. They are closed temporarily but reopening for 2/14 it seems.

Whats so good about it ?

+1 for giant rooftop crustaceans.

I know a lot of people are going to suggest Steve’s in Red Hook, but are they still open? Website is shut down.

They are. I just went a couple weeks ago.

Also Check: Does Mcdonalds Have Cherry Pie

Popular Recipes

More Recipes Like This