Best Mail Order Cherry Pie

Must Try

Why Choose Mud Foods To Buy Pies Online

COMPARING 3 Cherry Pie Recipes – 5 Ingredient / Gluten Free / Classic

Christian, our Chief Pie Maker, created our legendary shortcrust pastry recipes and the scrumptious fillings in our multi-award-winning range of ready to buy pies online. We are dedicated to bringing you the best options in the market, and to be your go-to for when you dont feel like cooking but fancy down-to-earth-good food. Our pies are perfect on their own as a feast for one or as a complete low-maintenance pie meal for all the family when teamed up with our delicious side dishes. Choose from our buttery mashed potato, beer-battered chips. or our carrot and parsnip mash – top it all off with some gravy and youve got yourself a dinner winner. Our bakers carefully finish off each pie with a pastry motif , ready for you to enjoy the glorious taste of Mud Foods creations. Our team at Mud Foods are our very own Pie-oneers! With a passion for creating down-to-earth, heavenly pies, our team of piefectionists just love making our customers happy!

Buy Pies Online Today!

Deliciously Dangerous Pies Baltimore Md

Owner and chef Rodney Henry learned his mad pie skills from his grandmother, and created his famous invention The Baltimore Bomb made with Marylands famous chocolate Berger Cookies melted on vanilla custard. They even deliver their pies around Baltimore if youre too lazy to get out of bed. Sign us up. Heres some other amazing stuff youve got to eat around Baltimore.

Our Pick: Baked In Color

Claim To Fame:The original rainbow chocolate chip cookie and the Happiest Cookies on Earth

About Baked In Color Cookie Cakes:As their name suggests, COLOR is the name of the game at this fun bakery.

Made with super colorful dough, these huge rainbow cookie cakes are rolled and twisted to create a unique sweet treat. No two cookie cakes are the same!

In addition to the classic Rainbow Chocolate Chip, other flavors include Brownie Oreo, Funfetti Cookie and Cookies N Cream. There is even an option to choose your own colors.

Also Available from Baked In Color:Choose Your Own Color Cookie Gift Tins, College Colors Cookie Gifts, Giant Rainbow Oreo Brownies and Seasonal Treats

Claim To Fame:Cakes so good that they got a deal on Shark Tank!

The company is based in South Caroline. Their hand-crafted cakes are rich with southern family tradition and use recipes handed down through the generations.

About Daisy CakesHeads up to the chocolate lovers! Daisys classic chocolate cake has four layers of rich chocolate cake. Each layer has a semi-sweet chocolate ganache that is delicately spread by hand. The entire cake is finished with a thick coating of fudge icing.

Also AvailableA wide array of classic cake flavors plus minikins which are cakes in a jar. Birthday cake delivery is offered via Goldbelly.

Recommended Reading: How To Make Bean Pies

Bake My Day Bakery Mobile Alabama

Imagine all the classic fruitcake ingredients baked into a cookie! The family-owned, award-winning Bake My Day Bakery has packed candied cherries, pineapple, dates, and pecans into cake-like fruitcake cookies bursting with holiday color and flavor.

Reviewers were charmed by these delightful cookies that delivered all the pleasure of a slice of fruitcake in such a convenient and satisfying size. These cookies will be the highlight of your dessert table or holiday gift giving.


Want to up the surprise factor? Consider sending the 3 pound Heavenly Trio Fruitcake selection which is available on Amazon. The trio includes Beatrice Bakerys Classic Fruit and Nut Cake , the Amaretto Fruitcake , and the Pineapple Macadamia fruitcake .

4.5 pound Classic Fruitcake from Eilenbergers Bakery in Texas

In May of 1898, 21-year-old German immigrant F. H. Eilenberger opened a bakery in Palestine, Texas to begin producing an old German family recipe for fruitcake. Today, Eilenbergers bakery is the oldest operating bakery in Texas. Their multi-award winning fruitcakes continue to be handmade and sell nearly 50 thousand fruitcakes per year.

Our Pick: Bake Me A Wish

Top 10 Gourmet Mail Order Dessert Pies in 2021  Treat Buyer

Claim To Fame: Gourmet cakes and bakery gifts are delivered overnight, nationwide. Each mail order cake is delivered in an elegant gift box with a greeting card.

Image: Bake Me A Wish

About Bake Me A Wish Cakes:Bake Me A Wish doesnt stop at traditional vanilla and chocolate birthday cake flavors. This is the place to go if youre looking for a wide variety of flavor options.

Here are just a few that may strike your fancy: Tiramisu Classico, Salted Caramel, Tres Leches, Vesuvius , Butterscotch Pudding, Limoncello, Boston Cream and Coconut Cream. Yum!

Also Available from Bake Me A Wish:Cupcakes, cheesecakes, cookies, brownies, pies, gift towers and baskets filled with treats

Don’t Miss: Key Lime Pie The Profit

The Original Fried Pies Davis Ok

The recipe comes from an old recipe Nancy Fulton inherited from family members who baked the same pies for ranchers in the 1800s. Although theyre fried, these pies are surprisingly not greasy at all. Newcomers are highly recommended to try the apricot, a fan favorite. Want to know more info about Oklahomas food laws ? Check this out.

Humphry Slocombe Ice Cream

If you left your heart in San Francisco after your first taste of Humphry Slocombe ice cream, youll be pleased as punch to know you can order this brand, known for its out-of-the-box flavors like Beets, Carrots, and Government Cheese. A four-pack of their best-selling Secret Breakfast , Malted Milk Chocolate, Blue Bottle Vietnamese Coffee, and Tahitian Vanilla is available directly through Amazon.

  • Where to order: or Goldbely
  • Minimum order: 4 pints or 6 pints
  • Shipping costs: free in some cases
  • Flavor you shouldnt miss: Black Sesameyouve never tasted anything quite this intense

You May Like: Supreme Bean Pie Recipe

Cherry Pie At Crouse Cafe Indianola Iowa

It doesnt get much more hometown than this. Crouse Cafe is a delightfully charming and quaint cafe in the small town of Indianola, Iowa. Stop off here for tasty breakfast full of gigantic pancakes, hot griddlecakes and omelettes. Then, stay through lunch to enjoy the incredibly perfect fusion of tart cherries, flaky crust, and sweet sugary goodness. Its easily one of the best cherry pies in the country.

Cherry Pie At The Lion House Pantry Salt Lake City Utah

Daily Vlog | Getting My Life in Order | Cooking cherry pie and funchoza with tofu

Carb-heavy is a great way to describe the elevated homestyle food you can enjoy at The Lion House Pantry. From their scrumptious rolls to their famous pies, everything here tastes straight out of a family kitchen, even though its served in an elegant setting. Theyve been making pies from scratch for decades, and while their assorted dessert menu changes often, youll want to try and catch them on a day when theyre serving cherry pie. Its absolutely delicious.

Also Check: The Profit Key Lime Pie Full Episode

Slap Yo Mama Pie At The Pie Folks Cordova Tennessee

Never heard of a slap yo mama pie? Thats because this is the only place in the country to serve it. And, were telling you that as one of the best pies in America, its worth a trip to Cordova just for a taste or two. The pie is fudgy, decadent, delicious and creamy. Simply put, its a chocolate lovers ultimate fantasy. And, no, you dont have to slap your mama just to eat it, but its so good you just might not be able to contain yourself.

Best Blueberry Pie: Two Fat Cats Bakery

This from-scratch bakery in Portland, Maine, has been specializing in baked sweets made with real butter, locally sourced eggs, and wild Maine blueberries since 2005. Founded on the belief that good pies come from high-quality ingredients, Two Fat Cats Bakery hand-makes each of its delicious pies and delivers them nationally through Goldbelly. Try the shop’s popular blueberry pie, which is packed with wild Maine blueberries and tossed with sugar and spices to bring out the bright berry flavors. We also recommend topping a warm slice with a big scoop of vanilla ice cream to serve.

To buy: Maine Wild Blueberry Pie, $59

Don’t Miss: Weight Watchers Chicken Pot Pie Bisquick

Best Fudge Pie: Collin Street Bakery

Though this Corsicana, Texas-based bakery is world famous for its holiday fruitcakes, Collin Street Bakery also makes a mean chocolate fudge pie. This dessert is made with whole eggs and semi-sweet chocolate, then baked inside a deep-dish crust until the top takes on the crackly consistency of a brownie. Try the original chocolate fudge pie, or order a deep-dish fudge pecan pie that’s been topped with toasted pecans to combine two classic holiday sweets into one.

To buy: Fudge Pie, from $22

The Best Pies In Order

Homemade Cherry Pie in CT

Co-Owner and Sandwich Pusher at Pop+Dutch

We all know that pie is one of our greatest inventions as a human race. Even for those of us who don’t require dessert after every meal, it can be tough to turn down a slice of pie. Summertime feels like pie season to us, and so in honor of the impending official first day of summer, we’d like to present you with the best pies, ranked in order of excellence.

To clarify, these views do not reflect the whole of HuffPost Taste as a pie-eating collective. My colleagues have already guaranteed that they will have some choice words for me should I not list their favorite pie in the top spot. I’m sure that you, dear readers, will have some as well. Go ahead and let me have it in the comments.

You May Like: Recipe For Muslim Bean Pie

How To Store Extra Pie

Keep this pie well covered and refrigerated and enjoy it within 4-5 days. If youd like, you can warm each slice up in the microwave for 15-20 seconds before you dig in.

This pie should not be frozen once its baked the freezing process will cause the filling to weep upon thawing.

  • Total Time:1 hour 45 minutes
  • Yield:10

A Beyond Decadent Chocolate Pie


This Dallas-based bakery makes a chocolate pie that is as beautiful as it is delicious. A thick, silky blend of whipping cream and bittersweet chocolate gets piped in a hypnotic spiral into a crushed pretzel crust for pie thats sweet, salty and over-the-top decadent. The pie is also available with a gluten free crust.

Read Also: Campbell Soup Recipe Chicken Pot Pie

Best Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie: Tate’s Bake Shop

Tate’s Bake Shop may have just achieved the impossible: making a dessert even more delicious than a batch of homemade cookies. The bakery’s chocolate chip cookie pie has the crispy-on-the-outside, gooey-on-the-inside texture we all love about our go-to cookie recipes, combined with a flaky pie crust. Try this pie fresh out of the oven with a scoop of vanilla ice cream on topâyou won’t regret it.

To buy: Chocolate Chip Pie, $32

Best Sweet Potato Pie: Dangerously Delicious Pies


The humble sweet potato has never tasted better than it does in this handcrafted pie. Dangerously Delicious Pies in Baltimore, Maryland, is known for its traditional holiday pies, like sweet potato pie, in addition to savory flavors, like the steak and mushroom gruyere pie. Made from locally sourced ingredients and loaded with sweet potatoes, sugar, and spices, the sweet potato pie has all the rich flavor you’d expect from the classic Southern dessert. The 10-inch handmade pie serves as many as eight people, so you and your holiday guests can each enjoy a slice.

To buy: Sweet Potato Pie, $65

Read Also: What Is Bean Pie Made Of

Blueberry Pie At Emerys Berry Farm New Egypt New Jersey

Emerys has grown and sold berries and farm fresh baked goods to New Jerseyans 50 years. So, on top of being able to treat yourself to one of the best blueberry pies in America, youll be able to buy some preserves and jellies to take home with you as well. Craving something more than just blueberries? The trifecta pie comes with blueberries, peaches, and cherries all in one.

Our Pick: We Take The Cake

Claim To Fame: Fort Lauderdales most legendary custom-cake shop.

We Take The Cake is visited often by celebrities and luxury caterers. Their famous key lime bundt cake is one of Oprahs Favorite Things.

Image: We Take The Cake

About We Take The Cake Cakes:Quality and attention to detail are what sets this cake shop apart from the competition.

They use ingredients like whole buttermilk, fresh eggs and real butter just like grandma used to make. Experienced bakers mix every batter and frosting by hand.

This bakery knows that shipping a birthday cake is all about presentation. They go the extra mile with hand-decorated cakes and custom-designed packaging to make sure your birthday cake delivery is perfect.

They offer a variety of layer cakes as well as bundt cakes in classic flavors like vanilla, chocolate, lemon, strawberry and raspberry.

Gluten-free and vegan cake options are available.

The iconic American company that offers gourmet cookie tins, baskets and gifts for shipping nationwide.

Image: Mrs. Fields

About Mrs. Fields Cakes:Not everyone is a cake fan. We can respect that! Thats why we included Mrs. Fields Giant Cookie Cakes in our list.

Each giant chocolate chip cookie cake measures 12 inches in diameter. These colossal cookie cakes are moist, chewy and made with real butter, whole eggs, and pure vanilla.

For ease of ordering, there are a variety of pre-set Happy Birthday designs. However, you can also customize your message and frosting colors.

Don’t Miss: Shabazz Bean Pies

Melrose Ave Los Angeles Ca 90069 653

You will most likely have a difficult time deciding among the pies at Sweet Lady Jane. But know youre in good company, because their Pear Almond Tart earned the designation as one of Oprahs 2016 Favorite Things. They also offer cherry pie , apple pie, and more. And you dont have to limit yourself to pie you may be tempted to expand the dessert offerings this year with one of Sweet Lady Janes cakes, cheesecakes, or Thanksgiving cookies!

Best Marionberry Pie: Willamette Valley Pie Company

Traverse City, Mich.: Grand Traverse Pie Company : The Grand Traverse ...

Grown exclusively in the state of Oregon, are a cross between two different types of blackberries and offer a tart, earthy flavor that makes them perfect for pies. Willamette Valley Pie Company has been locally growing berries since 1999, transforming the fruit into delightfully sweet pies using family recipes and all-natural ingredients. Choose between the classic marionberry pie, which features a hand-shaped crust, or order the , which combines the tart berry flavor with a buttery almond crumble topping.

To buy: Marionberry Pie, $69

You May Like: Campbell’s Chicken Pot Pie Recipe

Popular Recipes

More Recipes Like This