Best Mail Order Pecan Pie

Must Try

Grand Traverse Pie Company

The Best Pecan Pie Recipe | Melissa Clark | NYT Cooking

Traverse City, MichiganGTPC takes its name from a bay thats world famous for its cherries, so it stands to reason that you should absolutely get one of its legendary, crumbly topped pies, a gallon of ice cream, and a pillow. And while that pie is wonderful and perfect on its own, there are a bazillion other options too. Luckily, theres a pie of the month club, which you should 1,000% join, because pie is too damn delicious for once a year especially the there are chocolate cream pies, peanut butter chocolate cream, and every fruit imaginable packed into the crust.

Best Chocolate Pecan Pie: Three Brothers Bakery

For sweet caramel pecan flavors swirled together with rich chocolate tones, try a chocolate pecan pie from Three Brothers Bakery. The Polish bakery was founded in 1949, and since then, it has gained recognition for its deep dish pies and innovative multi-layered pumpecapple piecake. The rich and gooey chocolate pecan pies made by Three Brothers Bakery truly stand out, made with chocolate chips, crisp pecans, and delicious fudge. You can even try the chocolate bourbon pecan pie, which uses Jack Daniels whiskey in its secret recipe.

To buy: Chocolate Pecan Pies, from $59

Best Places To Buy Apple Pie Online Via Mail Order For The Holidays

Thats our take on the 10 best places to buy apple pie online via mail order now for the fall 2021 holidays, including pies for Thanksgiving and Christmas. What do you think, dear reader? Lattice or crumb top? Ice cream or whipped cream? Maybe some cheddar cheese? However you choose to accessorize, promise to wait until we get there cause we always save room for dessert.

Recommended Reading: Campbell’s Soup Chicken Pot Pie

A Pie That Looks Like It Came From Grandmas Kitchen

Harry & David

This pie is a total classic. The apple filling is a delicious blend of apples, butter and cinnamon, while the crust is light and flaky. Once youre ready to eat it, just pop it in the oven and take it out when its time and enjoy. Harry & David just asks that you order by Friday, November 19 if you plan to do standard shipping

The Overall Best Pies To Order Online

Award Winning Southern Pecan Pie Three Brothers Bakery
  • $79

Prices taken at time of publishing.

Time and again, this cult, famous Brooklyn-based pie shop came up among our experts. I still dream of their pie slices, says Nadia Chaudhury, editor of Eater Austin and a former New Yorker. Shes such a fan, in fact, that she calls the companys 2013 cookbook my pie bible. If youre the type who likes to make pie from scratch, but if youd rather stay out of the kitchen, the pies also ship beautifully. You can order a handful of flavors, but for a not-typical pie, Chaudhury says to opt for the bakerys signature salty honey pie, with its wonderfully gooey, sweet, luscious, and just-rightly-intense custard.

  • $80

Prices taken at time of publishing.

Wisconsin is all over the news for a lot of reasons right now, but if studio food editor Amelia Rampe of the Kitchn had her way, it would be in the news for this apple pie named the best pie in America by The Wall Street Journal and Gourmet from the Elegant Farmer. Ive made the recipe for this pie a couple times in the last month, and its really good, says Rampe. But if youd rather take the work out of your pie-making, order a few of these online: The price is for two pies.

Don’t Miss: Hardee’s Apple Pie

Find Out If Its Worth Shelling Out $30 On A Pie You Could Pick Up From Trader Joes For $6

We see you. Youve been assigned a dessert for Thanksgiving, and so here you are, looking up pie companies because you dont bake. And youve got your cursor hovering over an add to basket button, wondering if that pie is really worth $25, 35, 50?!? Could you get away with picking up any old pie from the grocery store, instead?

Were curious, too. Are those fancy pies you can order from a specialty bakery worth the extra money? Exactly what kind of sorcery is happening under those pricey crusts to make them cost that much? Or is there absolutely no difference at all, in which case youre completely justified in picking up a pie at Ralphs on the way to Aunt Simones the day of?

We decided to find out. We ordered three pies from one of the best specialty pie makers in the country, the Southern Baked Pie Company. Surprisingly, they dont carry a sweet potato pie, so we ordered that from a barbecue outfit in North Carolina which shall go nameless because, bless their hearts, what they sent was an awful mess. Poorly packed, frost-covered, and the filling shrunken to half the size of the pie shell.

We ordered a replacement last-minute from The Little Pie Company here in New York City. Sacrilege? Probably, but we do what we must.

Southern Baked Pie Company Georgia

Salted Caramel Turtle Pie

Founded in Gainesville, Georgia in 2012, Southern Baked Pie Company was launched by Amanda Wilbanks. Based on treasured family recipes and an all-butter pie dough that melts in your mouth, Amanda and her team of bakers create gourmet sweet and savory pies in a variety of sizes including: whole 10-inch pies, petite 5-inch pies, and bite-size tassies. Not sure which pie to buy? Their signature French Coconut Custard Pie was featured on the Today Show. No matter what you order, you cant go wrong.

You May Like: What Is Bean Pie Made Of

Best Key Lime Pie: Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shop

As the weather gets cooler, take your taste buds on vacation off the coast of Florida with the help of this delicious Key lime pie. Located on the historic Key West Bight, Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shop is renowned for its key lime pies with delightful graham cracker crust and tart, fluffy filling. The pies are made using the shop’s famous Key lime juice and dolloped with whipped cream for a light dessert that’s just as beautiful as it is delicious.

To buy: Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Pie, $79

Kermits Key West Lime Shoppe

Collin Street Bakery: The Creation of our Perfect Pecan Pie

Key West, FLIf youre going to order yourself a key lime pie, you might as well go directly to the source. Kermits Key West Lime Shoppe uses actual key limes in celebration of the official Florida state pie. Its tart and zippy as every good key lime pie should be, but mellows out thanks to condensed milk and cream cheese.

Recommended Reading: Best Bean Pie Recipe

A Pumpkin Pie Meant For Everyone

Williams Sonoma

Williams Sonoma recruited the help of Sweet Things bakery in California to make this Thanksgiving favorite dessert accessible to folks with gluten sensitivities. The flaky crust is made with butter and not a lick of gluten. And the custard-rich pumpkin filling is flavored with ginger, cinnamon and cloves for that just-right taste. A pretty maple leaf on top completes the look.

Best Caramel Apple Pie: Blue Owl Bakery

Wow your Thanksgiving dinner guests with this gravity-defying apple pie from Blue Owl Bakery. The Levee high caramel pecan apple pie is approximately 9 inches tall, filled with 18 hand-peeled Golden Delicious apples, and topped with a caramelly made-from-scratch crust. It arrives fully assembled and ready to bake in your own oven, so you can enjoy the heavenly smells that’ll waft through your kitchen as it bakes. Plus, Oprah named the Levee high caramel pecan apple pie one of her favorite things in 2011, so you know it’s bound to be delicious. The pie serves 10â12 people, so there’ll be plenty to share with Thanksgiving guests.

To buy: Levee High Caramel Pecan Apple Pie, $109

Recommended Reading: How To Make Bean Pies

Key Lime Pie Co Key West Deal

Dont think you like key lime? This tangy pie might make you reconsider. Key Lime Pie Co.s version nails the sugar to lime ratio, making for a citrus-forward pie that doesnt give you a major rush afterwards. A classic graham cracker crust holds the silky filling, and everything is topped off with pretty whipped cream.To buy: $18,

Best Cherry Pie: Petee’s Pie Company

Best Pecan Pies

Petra, the founder of Petee’s Pie Company, grew up in a family of pie makers and learned all the secrets to creating a perfect pie from a young age. All that knowledge culminated in 2014 when Petra opened her own pie shop in New York City, and ever since then, her handmade pies have been highly praised by nearly everyone who’s tried them. The New York sour cherry pie is one of Petee’s most popular flavors, and it’s made from scratch using locally sourced tart red cherries and natural fair-trade sweeteners. You can choose between a 6-inch pie that serves two to three people or a 9-inch pie that serves six to eight guests. Simply pop this ready-to-bake pie into your oven, then taste test it with your Thanksgiving guests.

To buy: New York Sour Cherry Pie, From $45

Also Check: Key West Key Lime Pie Company Recipe

Dangerously Delicious Pies Baltimore Md

We love sour cherry pie

Dangerously Delicious Pies offers both sweet and savory pies, each handmade from scratch with no additives or preservatives. What would otherwise be a Baltimore favorite spot can now be enjoyed anywhere! 10-inch pies begin at $65 which includes shipping. Take time to consider their savory pies. Their steak, mushroom, onion and gruyere pie regularly sells out.

Sunnyland’s Southern Pecan Pie

For years customers requested Pecan Pie, so we decided to fulfill their wishes. We use the finest ingredients, including Georgia grown pecans and real butter. You and your guests will immediately taste the difference. This pie makes the perfect gift for the holidays, for the hostess, or for any reason at all. We bake our pies in small batches right here at the farm. Each Pecan Pie, will serve 8 and freezes beautifully.

You May Like: Damgoode Pies River Market

Best Pie Cake: Piecaken Bakeshop

What’s better than a slice of pie? Two slices of pie layered beneath a slice of cake, called the PieCaken. This show-stopping dessert quickly caught the attention of celebrities and food critics alike when PieCaken Bakeship first created it in 2015, and it even caused a pumpkin puree shortage in New York City that same year due to its success. Thanks to Goldbelly, you don’t have to make a trip to the Big Apple to secure your dessert simply get it delivered to your doorstep. The PieCaken is made up of three irresistible layers: pecan pie, then pumpkin pie, and finally spice cake on top, with cinnamon buttercream separating each layer. Topped with apple pie filling, this multi-layered dessert is an impressive addition to your Thanksgiving menu and serves 12â16 people.

To buy: PieCaken, $99

They Aren’t Cheap But They Are Good

The History of Pecan Pie

Thanksgiving is unquestionably America’s greatest food holiday. Yet much of the meal invites controversy. Not everyone is a fan of roasted turkey. Stuffing ingredients are contentious. The debate over the proper potato to mash regular or sweet will outlive us all.

Less controversial is the question of pie. We may quibble over the specifics fruit vs. custard, or whether pecan should be accompanied by chocolate but there’s generally more of a willingness to come together over a truly spectacular dessert.

To find the pies that bring everyone to the table for the holidays, Bloomberg sampled top desserts from across the country. Then food editor Kate Krader, with the help of a ravenous newsroom, picked her favorites.

10. Babka Pie, Breads Bakery, New York $52.95, shipping around $29.95

Krader: “Not everyone considers this a pie, but it’s shaped like one and it’s definitely the best chocolate babka around. Slathered with Nutella and studded with chocolate chips, it has incredible layers and levels of chocolate. Forgo the fork and knife, and pull it apart with your hands.”

Newsroom: “One of the best babkas I’ve tasted. Dough is nice and crispy, not gooey.” “Buttery goodness.” “Not a pie. Still would eat a lot of this.”

9. Brown Bag Apple Pie, Elegant Farmer, Wisconsin $29.99, shipping from $15.84

Newsroom: “Tastes homemade. Apples retain nice texture.” “Crust is incredible. So crispy.”

8. Four Berry Pie, Achatz Pies Armada, Michigan $49, free shipping

Read Also: Marcus Lemonis Key Lime Pie Company

Best Sweet Potato Pie: Dangerously Delicious Pies

The humble sweet potato has never tasted better than it does in this handcrafted pie. Dangerously Delicious Pies in Baltimore, Maryland, is known for its traditional holiday pies, like sweet potato pie, in addition to savory flavors, like the steak and mushroom gruyere pie. Made from locally sourced ingredients and loaded with sweet potatoes, sugar, and spices, the sweet potato pie has all the rich flavor you’d expect from the classic Southern dessert. The 10-inch handmade pie serves as many as eight people, so you and your holiday guests can each enjoy a slice.

To buy: Sweet Potato Pie, $65

Best Peach Pie: Harry & David

For a pie with bright, fruit-forward flavors, try this deep-dish option from Harry & David. The country-style peach and berry pie is filled with peaches, blueberries, and raspberries in a crisp pastry shell. Instead of a double crust or lattice top, the pie is generously sprinkled with a cinnamon-and-sugar streusel, making for a dessert that’s too beautiful to eat.

To buy: Peach and Berry Pie, $40

Recommended Reading: Key Lime Pie On A Stick Dipped In Chocolate

Best Berry Pie: Achatz Handmade Pie Co

As a National Pie Championship winner, the crumb Michigan four-berry pie is too delicious not to be included on your Thanksgiving table. Loaded with locally grown cherries, blueberries, raspberries, and blackberries, this tart-yet-sweet pie is handmade in Armada, Michigan, before being carefully shipped to your doorstep. The Achatz family has been making award-winning pies since 1993, and many of their recipes have been perfected over several generations, meaning the flavorful berry pie you receive is the product of decades of care and tradition.

To buy: Crumb Michigan Four-Berry Pie, $54

Centerville Pie Co Shepherds Pie


Its okay to eat pie for dinner! That is, when its savory . A buttery crust surrounds creamy Parmesan mashed potatoes and layers of corn and sautéed beef and onions. The ultimate comfort food is shipped to you from a small pie shop on Cape Cod, Massachusetts, and serves 6 to 8 people.To buy: $64,

Also Check: Key West Key Lime Pie Company The Profit Update

Popular Recipes

More Recipes Like This