Best Frozen Key Lime Pie

Must Try

Similar Recipes Perfect For Cinco De Mayo:

Frozen No-Bake Key Lime Pie
  • 1 1/2 cups graham cracker crumbs
  • 1/4 cup sugar
  • 6 extra-large egg yolks, at room temperature
  • 1/4 cup sugar
  • 1 can sweetened condensed milk
  • 2 tablespoons grated lime zest
  • 3/4 cup freshly squeezed lime juice


  • 1 cup cold heavy cream
  • 1/4 cup sugar
  • Preheat the oven to 350 degrees.
  • For the crust:

  • Combine the graham cracker crumbs, sugar, and butter in a bowl. Press into the bottom and up the sides of a 9-inch pie pan. Bake for 10 minutes. Allow to cool completely.
  • For the filling:

  • Beat the egg yolks and sugar on high speed in the bowl of an electric mixer fitted with a paddle attachment until thick .
  • With the mixer on medium speed, add the condensed milk, lime zest, and lime juice. Pour into the cooled, baked pie shell and freeze for a couple hours before adding the whipped cream on top.
  • For the topping:

  • Beat the heavy cream on high speed in the bowl of an electric mixer fitted with the whisk attachment until soft peaks form. Add the sugar and vanilla and beat until firm. Spoon or pipe decoratively onto the pie and decorate with lime. Freeze for several hours or overnight.
  • Where Did Key Lime Pie Originate

    So, before we jump into where to find the best key lime pie in Key West, we thought we would give you a little back story as to the origin of key lime pie.

    Now, the facts as to who made the very first key lime pie are a little fuzzy. Some claim that William Curry, as ship salvager in Florida, had a cook that made the first key lime pie. While others claim that sponge fishermen were the very first to concoct this delicious dessert.

    What we do know is that Key Lime Trees were found in abundance all throughout Key West dating back as early as the 1800s. During that time, refrigeration was not common, so the innovation of using shelf-stable sweetened condensed milk was pivotal.

    In 2006, Key Lime Pie became the official state pie of Florida. So, we might not be completely sure as to its origin, but we sure do love this pie and we are so happy it was created.

    Best Recommendations And Buying Guide For Your Frozen Key Lime Pie

    Before you venture out to purchase your preferred frozen key lime pie, take into consideration some factors. These factors will ultimately help you decide which frozen key lime pie is the right fit for your requirements.

    Use the internet to do your research about all the available frozen key lime pies in the market. This is helpful for both online and retail/ in-person purchases. If you are buying from an online marketplace, try to ascertain the most trustworthy online store. Usually, the online shops that have the highest following of masses are the best ones.

    These shops not only provide reliable products but also give the buyers a lot of diversified products to choose from. Search for the different types of frozen key lime pie available in the online store and find ones to choose from.

    Read the reviews of people on the online pages to understand the detailed and nuanced pros and cons that entail this particular frozen key lime pie. You can also understand through other peoples reviews whether a particular frozen key lime pie fits your needs.

    Assessing products online before buying the desired products from retail shops is also a very common phenomenon.

    While doing the crucial research on the frozen key lime pies available in the market, you might ask yourself a few questions that will help you reach your decision:

    Don’t Miss: Original Key Lime Pie Company

    Helpful Tips & Frequently Asked Questions

    • You can find key limes in the produce section of the grocery store and Walmart.
    • I used fresh key limes. If you can find key limes, you can use a bottle of Real Key West Lime Juice or regular limes/lime juice. Either will be fine.
    • If you dont have a stand mixer, you can make the whipped cream in a large bowl with a hand held mixer.
    • I also used a store bought graham cracker crust. It works great in this recipe. If you dont like the store bought crusts, you can definitely make your own crust.
    • To make you homemade crust, in a medium bowl combine 1½ cups graham cracker crumbs, 6 Tablespoons of melted butter, and 5 Tablespoons of sugar. Press mixture into the bottom and sides of a 9-inch pie plate.
  • Store leftovers in an airtight container in the freezer.
  • Cover the pie with plastic wrap and place in a freezer bag to avoid freezer burns.
  • How To Thaw A Frozen Key Lime Pie

    Easy Frozen Key Lime Pie Recipe

    Thawing a frozen key lime pie is easy. All you need to do is place it in the refrigerator for one to two hours, at which point you should serve it immediately. This is the best time to add meringue or other toppings, which rarely survive the freezing process as well as the pie itself does.

    Toppings can also make it harder to wrap a key lime pie correctly when freezing it. Minimizing air contact is essential, so plan to add toppings later .

    You May Like: Bisquick Impossible Chicken Pie

    Can My Key Lime Pie Get Freezer Burn

    Freezer burns occur when food dehydrates in the freezer, typically from a mixture of dehydration and air. Avoiding this is the reason our guidelines above focus on minimizing the possibility of air coming into contact with food. The more you can reduce these sorts of chemical reactions, the better your food is ultimately going to taste.

    Here are some other tips for preventing freezer burn and helping your pie freeze as safely as possible:

  • Make sure the pie is cool. Steam causes condensation on the inside of your plastic wrapping, which pushes the wrapping away and increases the chances of airflow. Freezing the pie for two hours first helps with a lot of this, but starting when its too warm could cause problems regardless.
  • Make sure air can circulate. Freezers work best when each item has some space around it. This improves both airflow and energy efficiency. If you find that your freezer is always packed, you may need to get another freezer.
  • Organize things. A well-organized freezer has foods nearing expiration at the front, where youre more likely to use them. If you forget about a pie after freezing it, chances are it will go bad before you get to enjoy it! Try to have a schedule for enjoying the pie when you freeze it, rather than assuming youll eat it when you feel like it.
  • Are Key Limes Native To Florida

    While the pie is attributed to that region, the Key limes namesake ingredient is an import. A man by the name of Dr. Henry Perrine was in Mexico and discovered this citrus gem. He believed they would grow well in the Florida Keys and imported them in 1835.

    Farming in that region proved to be difficult and the lime industry has had its ups and downs. But theyve been around long enough for the little green fruit to make its mark on the region. When visiting the Florida Keys, you can find slices, whole pies, pie on a stick, and even Key lime gelato. There are also Key lime cocktails in every bar.

    Read Also: Damgoode Pies Fayetteville

    How Long Does Key Lime Pie Last

    More specifically, can you freeze key lime pie for extended periods? How long does key lime pie last in the freezer?

    As we described above, key lime pie lasts for about one month in the freezer when stored properly. It will retain most of its characteristic texture and quality if you use it in that timeframe. If you freeze the pie for longer than that, expect it to lose the consistency. At that point, its often better to make a new pie.

    Midway Cafe & Coffee Bar

    Blast From The Past: Frozen Key Lime Pie

    The Midway Cafe & Coffee Bar is an excellent choice for breakfast if you happen to be in or near Islamorada. On this day, I decided I needed to have key lime pie for breakfast . The Midway Cafe has the traditional key lime pie recipe, and for locals, they might argue that because of this, it is the best key lime pie.

    For me, coming from the West Coast, this was my first time having key lime pie baked in a pastry crust and topped with a meringue topping. So, I was a little surprised when I received my pie. However, I do love trying new things, and it was still key lime pie, so I figured you couldnt go too wrong with it. Plus, I was served some delicious fresh brewed coffee to go along with my pie.

    This is the traditional way of making key lime pie using a pastry crust with meringue.

    My Pie Impressions: This key lime pie was made in a traditional pastry crust, and served with a thick meringue topping. It was good, as a pie, but not quite what I expected for a key lime pie. The crust was nice and flaky, and they did an excellent job with the meringue. However, the flavor of the key limes was somewhat lost, I feel, due to the taste and thickness of the pastry crust. So, although not my choice for the best key lime pie, I would still recommend you try it since it is the contested traditional way to make a key lime pie.

    Midway Cafe Address: 80499 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036

    Read Also: Churchs Chicken Apple Pie

    How We Chose The Best Key Lime Pie Delivery Services

    To select the best services, we weighed company history and accolades, quality of ingredients used in the pies, customer reviews, and pricing. A variety of flavors and other related items were also considered. For example, Key Lime Pie Company was chosen for its previous recognition in pie contests and best pie categories in addition to its century-old family recipe, while Kermits Key West Key Lime Shoppe was selected for its accolades as well as its extensive selection of key lime pie products.

    How To Make Mini Key Lime Pies:

  • Crush graham crackers and mix with the butter, set aside.
  • Cream the cream cheese until smooth using a hand mixer, add the sweetened condensed milk and mix until smooth. Add the key lime juice and mix until smooth.
  • Let the whipped topping defrost and add to the cream cheese mixture, folding it in until combined.
  • Taking individual silicone cups fill with the cream cheese mixture about ¾ of the way up. Top with the graham cracker crumbs. Place on a platter or sheet tray and place in freezer for 4 hours or until set. Unmold pies carefully and serve graham cracker side down. The easiest way to do this is to submerge the bottom half of the mold into warm water for a few seconds.
  • Serve with whipped topping garnish and key lime slice if desired, enjoy!
  • Ive been loving a more mini dessert lately especially for something like this. Can you imagine presenting these easy Mini Key Lime PieS on a big platter at your next cookout, or a plated for a dinner party?

    Totally impressive, gorgeous, delicious and youll be getting asked for the recipe ASAP, I guarantee it!

    When it comes to this delicious Key Lime Pie recipe I just cannot get enough. Although I could totally eat them all, I believe everything in moderation.

    I love the ease of these and that they come together quickly! With only 6 ingredients that you most likely have in your pantry you can put these together in no time.

    Don’t Miss: American Pie Free Movie

    Are Edwards Pies Frozen

    No matter how you slice our decadent, velvety layers and fresh-from-the-oven cookie crumb crust, our frozen pies are meticulously whipped, sprinkled, and drizzled to extravagant perfection. Simply thaw and serve to see how this crème pie will be the talk of the dessert table for every occasion and holiday.

    Where To Stay In Key Largo

    Frozen Key Lime Pie

    There are so many fabulous places to stay in Key Largo to suit all budgets and tastes. Click here for all accommodation in Key Largo during your dates.

    We would recommend staying at least 2 nights in Key Largo to soak up all this small town has to offer.

    If you want a little more comfort, we would recommend at this out of the world hotel!

    There is also a pretty unique hotel whose home is in Key Largo known as the This is a pretty epic place to stay. It is Floridas only underwater hotel. To stay at this hotel there is a catch, you need to dive to access the hotel. Staying here would truly be a once in a lifetime experience and a talking point among friends.


    Recommended Reading: Sonic Banana Cream Pie Shake Recipe

    Why Is Key Lime Pie Famous In Key West

    Key Lime Pie is very famous and popular in Key West. So, why is that? It is all about the climate! Key limes only grow well in areas where the temperatures stay very warm and never dip below freezing.

    Simply put, Key West has the perfect tropical environment for key limes to thrive and ripen beautifully. Key limes are quite tart and almost bitter if you eat them alone, but they truly shine as the super star ingredient for Floridas most beloved pie.

    How Long Can Key Lime Pie Sit Out

    December 7, 2021 | Keren Tayler

    Key lime pie is a fantastic dessert that originates in the Keys, islands on the southern coast of Florida. You purchased a frozen one at the store and left it sitting on the counter. Now youre wondering about food safety and want to know how long can key lime pie sit out before going bad?

    According to the U.S. Department of Agriculture, Key lime pie can sit out for a maximum of 2 hours. Key lime pie left out for longer than 2 hours moves into the Danger Zone. This is a temperature area where harmful bacteria can grow rapidly and cause food poisoning.

    The Danger Zone sits between 40 degrees Fahrenheit and 140F. Key lime pie left in the Danger Zone should be considered unsafe to eat and discarded.

    Quick Navigation

  • Related Guides
  • You May Like: Damgoode Pies Delivery

    How To Serve Key Lime Pie

    The pie turned out fantastic! Dont worry about cutting the pie it comes right out of the pan after it is frozen. Perfect slices every time. I like to run my knife under hot water before slicing it makes it a little easier to cut when it is frozen. Top the pie with a little dollop of whipped cream and key lime slices. This is the best way to cool off on hot summer days.

    Looking for more key lime desserts? Here are a few of our favorite recipes from the blog:

    Popular Recipes

    More Recipes Like This