Best Ice Cream Cake Nyc

Must Try

The 14 Best Ice Cream Shops In Nyc

The Best Ice Cream In NYC | Best Of The Best

NYC is packed with acclaimed new ice cream parlors and old frozen favorites

We love ice cream in all its formsand all year round. Though well happily partake any time, ice creamlike music festivals, picnics and outdoor diningis a joyful harbinger of warmer weather. Just try to be grumpy with a great big ice cream cone on a sunny dayyou cannot! New York City has an abundance of options for when you cant catch the Mister Softee truck. These are our favorite classic, offbeat, unique and traditional ice cream offerings this season.

An email youll actually love

By entering your email address you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and consent to receive emails from Time Out about news, events, offers and partner promotions.

Awesome, you’re subscribed!

  • Time Out Market

Sugar Hill Creamery owners Nick Larsen and Petrushka Bazin Larsens seasonal ice cream flavors are often inspired by their Midwestern and Caribbean backgrounds as well as their longtime home of Harlem. The husband-and-wife team has been crafting distinct ingredient combinations out of their Central Harlem store since 2017, and devoted fans hungry for frozen treats that you wont find in the supermarket led the pair to open a second location in Hamilton Heights just a few years later. Stop by oftentheres always an innovative new flavor to try.

  • Chinatown
  • price 1 of 4
  • Ice cream parlors
  • Forest Hills
  • Gowanus
  • price 2 of 4

Morgenstern`s Finest Ice Cream

There is no need to look beyond Morgenstern for someone looking for the best ice cream in Manhattan. You will find more than 80 wonderful flavors of ice cream, each individually twisted by the founder, Nicholas Morgenstern.

Whether you choose a traditional flavor like chocolate and vanilla or their innovative flavors such as burnt sage, your taste buds are going to be thankful anyway. To serve you the freshest ice cream, they make it in small batches. You will get a rush of nostalgia if you visit this place regardless of the flavor you choose.

  • 2 Rivington St, New York, NY, USA
  • +1 212 209 7684
  • 12 pm 10 pm, Monday Sunday.

The Best Ice Cream In Nyc

For a scoop of something cold, heres where to go.

As you print out old photos from summers past and gently stroke them as if to say, Ill never forget you, its important to remember that ice cream is still there for you. Plenty of ice cream spots around the city are open for takeout and delivery, including the best of the best.

Looking for soft serve? We have a guide for that too.

Read Also: Old Fashioned Chicken Pot Pie Recipe

Flippers Japanese Pancake Soho

This dessert pop-up in SoHo has drawn long lines since opening. Their signature is the small, circular, and puffy Japanese pancake dressed in a cloud of heavy cream whipped with butter and maple syrup.

When it first opened in 2019, we went there twice but couldnt get in due to the hours of wait. However, a few days before Christmas, we happened to walk by and surprised to get in easily with no waiting.

Flippers has two floors. The first floor is a dining counter and a carryout division that has not yet revved up. The second floor is a comparatively more luxurious room, featuring bare bricks, yellow neon, and yellow flowers on every table.

The inside of Flippers in Soho. Manufactur

Flippers puffy Japanese pancake dressed in a cloud of heavy cream.

There are up to 17 kinds of pancakes on the menu, and the signature is Flippers Pancake, which needs about 20 minutes to prepare.

While waiting, you can enjoy the pleasant ambiance and sip on their fresh-made bubble tea, which is good but a bit overpriced.

According to the instructions on the menu, you should eat the pancakes with two forks. When cut open, the inside is spongy and yellow, like the rooms flowers and neon. Sometimes individual pancakes collapse into a low heap that looks like scrambled eggs.

Flavor-wise, the egg dominates in these pancakes, which makes them taste like soufflés.

Max Brenner Chocolate Bar Union Square

The happiest cake in New York: Ice cream cake with sprinkles and a ...

French crepe from Max Brenner.

Founded in 1996, Israel, Max Brenner has been a one-stop chocolate shop for sweet lovers around the globe with 36 stores open in Australia, Israel, Japan, Russia, and the United States. Their chocolate is made of the highest quality cocoa beans and the finest raw materials.

It is not just desserts made of chocolate. The chefs at Max Brenner have incorporated the chocolate concept into everything they do, ranging from drinks to starters and even some of the main courses.

Some of our favorites are their Chocolate Crepe, Melting Chocolate Smores Sundae, Maxs White Russian, and Going Bananas.

Read Also: Purina Large Breed Puppy Food Chart

Van Leeuwen Ice Cream

Van Leeuwen has come a long way from selling ice creams in its yellow truck to having multiple branches across NYC. With an aim to create the best feel-good ice cream in town, this shop started selling ice cream in 2008.

Their classic ice cream combinations are cookie and cream, peanut butter brownie chip, caramel cookie, and many more. Their menu is full of vegan ice cream options as well as other treats like sundaes and milkshakes.

  • 81 Bergen St, Brooklyn, NY, USA
  • +1 347 763 2979
  • 12 pm 11 pm, Monday Sunday.

Ollies Ice Cream + Stuff

Best for Pet Owners

Yep, it sounds weird, but its true: Ollies is the best spot for pup parents because they serve frozen treats specifically for dogsthe pup cup! Nestled on a tree-lined street in Bushwick, they have amazing ice cream for humans too. Stop by the shop to try the soft serve, shakes, ice cream sandwiches or tasty vegan flavors. Not in an ice cream mood? Get a frozen chocolate banana, a sweet treat like a Dunkaroo or even a pickle. Because, why not?

158 Irving Avenue, Brooklyn 208-6825

Also Check: Keto Bread Walmart In Store

Ralphs Famous Italian Ices

Best Italian Ice

If youre from the tri-state area, you know Ralphs. Though they serve ice cream, edible cookie dough, drinks and eclectic toppings, the real star is the Italian ice. For those not familiar, Italian ice is similar to sorbet or snow cones, but is generally a frozen or semi-frozen sweetened treat made with fruit or other natural or artificial flavorings. Its somewhat healthier than traditional ice cream and Ralphs offers fat-free, cholesterol-free and dairy-free options out of all 80-plus locations. New Yorkers love Ralphs, which started out of Ralph Silvestros Staten Island truck when he immigrated from Italy in 1928. His ices have been cooling us off ever since.

Multiple locations

+ Ice Cream Cake Nyc Best Images

NYC’s Ice Cream Is World-Class | The Ice Cream Show

Check out the cake builder below to see how you can customize your very own ice cream cake. Moic new york city is proud to present 13 exhibition spaces with immersive and innovative concepts for all ice cream lovers. From classic flavors to a whole range of vegan selections and eclectic creations such as toasted coconut coconut cake ice cream and sichuan peppercorn with cherry compote, van leeuwen serves up ice cream that is rich, decadent and just naturally perfect. This ice cream shop is known as having the best ice cream and sorbet around. A ben & jerrys ice cream cake consists of two layers of ice cream with a layer of crumble in between, and a base of brownies on the bottom. This is old fashioned soda fountain is also one of nycs oldest ice cream parlours.

Check out the cake builder below to see how you can customize your very own ice cream cake.chocolate oat milk ice cream, pieces of chocolate cake layered with pecan coconut frosting, and a swirl of kirsch cherry cream & vegan ice cream.its expanding like crazy, and there. Vanilla vanilla vanilla ice cream with our special blend of vanilla. Our ice cream cakes are custom made with your favorite flavors. There is absolutely no limit on fun and imagination. Harbs, in chelsea and in soho, manhattan. You will customize your ice cream cake and writing at check out!

Also Check: Receipt For Chicken Pot Pie

What About Local Ice Cream Cake Delivery

Many national chains like Ben and Jerry’s, Carvel, and Coldstone offer delivery from their local stores. Enter your ZIP code on the company’s website to search for locations near you that offer delivery. In most cases, you’ll need to order one or two days in advance, but sometimes a phone call to the store can yield even faster service. Postmates, Grubhub, Uber Eats, and other delivery services can also coordinate local ice cream cake delivery.

Odd Fellows Ice Cream Co

This small-batch ice cream shop that started from scratch is now one of the finest ice cream parlors in Brooklyn. At Odd Fellows, you get more than 500 different choices of some really creative and yummy flavor blends.

The not-so-odd fellow behind all those delicious flavors is the pastry chef Sam Mason, with multiple awards and international recognitions. Vanilla bean, black pepper fig, miso cherry, and cookies & cream are some of their noticeable flavors.

  • 44 Water St, Brooklyn, NY, USA
  • +1 718 683 5755
  • 1 pm 8 pm, Sunday Thursday. 1 pm 9 pm, Friday and Saturday.

You May Like: Lasyone’s Meat Pie Restaurant

Levain Bakery Upper West Side

Levain Bakerys famous chocolate and raisin cookies.

Nestled in the Big Apples Upper West Side, Levain is a cozy neighborhood bakery famous for its fresh-made goodies.

From an inventive array of rustic bread to the famous six-ounce chocolate chip walnut cookie, everything is baked on-site, fresh every day from the finest natural ingredients.

Our favorites are the chocolate chip cookie, dark chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, dark chocolate peanut butter chip, and chocolate chip walnut.

Much To My Surprise Dairy Queen’s Ice

NYCâs Best Ice Cream Egg Waffles â Dessert Correspondents

I would totally buy the Dairy Queen cake again, thanks to its many great textures and flavors.

I did not think it would be my favorite, especially because Dairy Queen isn’t usually one of my go-to spots for dessert and this option didn’t contain real cake.

Even better? It was the most affordable out of the three ice-cream cakes I tried.

I would definitely get another ice-cream cake from Cold Stone, but I’d want to try different flavors that might be less intense and overpowering. I’d be open to trying another kind of ice-cream cake from Baskin Robbins especially if it was customized with my favorite flavors but I wouldn’t buy the Oreo one again.

Read Also: Nothing Bundt Cakes Denton Tx

Morgensterns Finest Ice Cream

Largest Flavor Selection

If youve seen a line halfway around the block and kiddos trying to lick up melted drips before they hit the ground, it was probably Morgensterns. With a whopping 55 available flavorsincluding 40 new flavors that were just introduced this springthis is the spot if youre looking for an eclectic array of avant garde flavors, like pineapple salted egg yolk, olive oil chocolate eggplant, tahini and jelly, toasted rice yuzu swirl and cardamom lemon jam, just to name a few. But thats not all. They also serve Smashburgers, fried chicken sandwiches, ice cream sandwiches and bars, shakes, floats, boozy shakes and floats, pies, sundaes and ice cream cakes.

Multiple locations 209-7684

Best Ice Cream Cake Delivery Services Of 2022

Why We Chose It: Six great cake flavors, beautiful style, nationwide shipping: Morgenstern’s brings it all together for the win.

  • Expensive

For many years, Nicholas Morgenstern worked as a pastry chef in some of New York City’s finest restaurants, all the while dreaming of someday opening his own ice cream shop. In 2014, his dream was realized. Morgenstern’s Finest Ice Cream is a modern version of the classic American ice cream parlor, serving a new American style of ice cream that contains no egg yolks and less fat, air, and sugar. The ice cream is dense, creamy, and mildly sweet.

Morgenstern’s has six flavors of ice cream cake: Cookies N’ Cream, Chocolate, Burnt Honey Vanilla, Mint Chip, Strawberry Vanilla, and Green Tea Pistachio. The cakes are 7 inches in diameter and serve six to eight people. They have a thin cookie crust on the bottom, a layer of crumbles in the middle, and a thin layer of frozen flavored whipped cream around the outside.

Morgenstern’s ice cream cakes cost around $120 each, and include free overnight shipping. The company only ships cakes on Tuesdays for overnight delivery the following day. Shipping insurancewhich is recommended in case an unexpected delay causes your ice cream cake to meltis available for an extra $4.

You May Like: Pillsbury Easy Chicken Pot Pie

Whipped Urban Dessert Lab Lower East Side

This newest addition to the NYC dessert scene offers plant-based, vegan, and dairy-free ice treats in the LES. They are made from oat milk, but you wont know unless they tell you, thanks to the creamy, rich flavor like any traditional ice cream you grow up eating.

You can choose from soft serve or Oate, a hard scooped collection which ships nationally for free. Popular flavors include Strawberry Shortcake, Mint Chocolate Cookie, Peanut Butter Chocolate Cookie, and Cinnamon Apple Crisp.

They also have ice crème truffles, a decadent bite-sized frozen treat filled with oat-milk ice cream and topped with some secret sauce.

Ice creme truffles from Whipped Urban Dessert Lab.

Spot Dessert Bar East Village

94-Year-Old Ice Cream Shop Makes The Best Sundaes In NYC | Legendary Eats

Spot Dessert Bar is my go-to place for sweets during my first year in graduate school. Though a bit far from where I live, I didnt mind being on the train for 30 minutes and waiting for another hour in the cold, just to have a bite of their sweet treats.

The neighborhood of Spot, where you can also find a ton of small, authentic Asian restaurants.

The famous The Harvest dessert at Spot Dessert Bar.

Tugged in a pre-war residential building, this tiny dessert spot is best known for its inventive and delicious desserts.

The most creative also, our favorite is The Harvest. From the outside, it looks like one of your house plants, but in fact, its a mix of nine different sweet layers, including Oreo crumbs, strawberry jam, chiffon cake, strawberries, whipped cream, more berries, cheesecake, and Oreo topsoil.

Parsley then gets planted in the soil, which you will be watering with the milky rose tea served on the side.

In addition, their Chestnut Butterscotch, Golden Toast, and Matcha Lava are good and worth trying as well.

You May Like: Pie Company Traverse City Michigan

Bibble & Sip Midtown West

Matcha cream puff and iced latte from Bibble & Sip.

Recommended by one of my co-workers from my first job, I went to try this tiny bakery with suspicion and right away fell in love with their Matcha White Chocolate Cream Puff, which is also the most popular item in the shop.

Frankly, I have never come across a cream puff so generous with the filling, which is also very velvety, smooth, and delicious. The sheer size of the cream puffs is almost overwhelming.

So, I suggest sharing it between two people or eating it quarter by quarter. If you want something to balance the sweetness, try their specialty lattes with flavors like Matcha Jasmine and Lavender and tea infused with syrups made in-house.

Also, they have adorable animal-shaped tarts that can certainly cure anybody in a bad mood. Bibble & Sip was the go-to spot for me to heal from my many sad and desperate early career struggles.

Serendipity 3 Upper East Side

Serendipitys treasure chest ice cream. Serendipity

At this lively, kitschy Upper East Side family spot, dessert outshines salads, burgers, and sandwiches to be the spotlight.

Their most popular sweet treat is the trademarked Frrrozen Hot Chocolate, a brain-freezing chocolate slushie. It is so huge that you need to bring a friend to share the burden.

Apart from the decadent desserts, the place is famous for its appearance in the 2001 romantic comedy Serendipity, alongside many other movies and TV shows, including Gossip Girl, One Fine Day, and Trust the Man.

Don’t Miss: American Pie Nake Mile Full Movie

Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain

Outdoor seating and take-out orders only.

Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain, a throwback soda parlor, is the total package. Its a quaint, vintage atmosphere with a menu chock-full of sundaes with names like Mr. Potato Head, a surprisingly long list of ice cream floats, and killer shakes. You can play fast and loose with your milkshake order , but if you order off the menu, go for the classic black and white with vanilla ice cream and hot fudge. Or take a step out and get the Rocket, which is a vanilla and a shot of espresso for a boost of energy .

Top 20 Desserts In New York City Female Foodie

NYCâs Best Ice Cream Egg Waffles â Dessert Correspondents

Oat milk ice cream is now a very real thing that you can get here in nyc.

Ice Cream Cake Nyc Best – Best ice cream cakes in new york, ny. Harbs, in chelsea and in soho, manhattan. Check out the cake builder below to see how you can customize your very own ice cream cake.chocolate oat milk ice cream, pieces of chocolate cake layered with pecan coconut frosting, and a swirl of kirsch cherry cream & vegan ice cream.its expanding like crazy, and there. From classic flavors to a whole range of vegan selections and eclectic creations such as toasted coconut coconut cake ice cream and sichuan peppercorn with cherry compote, van leeuwen serves up ice cream that is rich, decadent and just naturally perfect. Not your ordinary museum whats inside? Vanilla vanilla vanilla ice cream with our special blend of vanilla.

Also Check: Publix Mango Key Lime Pie Recipe

Popular Recipes

More Recipes Like This