Best Chicken Pot Pie Nyc

Must Try

The Best Classic Chicken Pot Pie

The Best Homemade Chicken Pot Pie Recipe Ever | Ultimate Comfort Food

The Best Classic Chicken Pot Pie Recipe Homemade chicken pot pie with flaky pie crust and creamy chicken pot pie filling. Classic comfort food!

This chicken pot pie recipe is loaded with flavor. Its got flaky pie crust and a buttery creamy chicken pot pie filling with chicken breast, a mix of fresh and frozen vegetables, and a mix of dried and fresh herbs.

I initially wanted to make an easy chicken pot pie. So, I started out using refrigerated pie dough, all frozen vegetables, and all dried herbs. That was easy, but it really needed some bright fresh flavors.

So, instead of making the easiest recipe, I decided to make the BEST chicken pot pie recipe.

Using fresh vegetables and some fresh herbs in the filling gives this pot pie so much flavor that its ok to take a short-cut with the crust and use a pre-made refrigerated pie crust.

Of course, if you have the time to make your own homemade pie crust, that would be amazing too.

Mcduffies Bakery’s Pot Pies Are Pure Comfort

      As we journey through the holidays and cold temperatures, tis the season of easy meals and comfort food.

      Acting on a tip from friend Jen, I finally bought a McDuffies Bakery frozen chicken pot pie at the Hamburg farmers market the very last day in October. The pie sat in my freezer a few weeks until strapped for time, I threw it in the oven.

      Eighty minutes later I was thinking, Where has this pot pie been my entire life?

      Wanting to find out more, I took a trek to McDuffies Bakery in Clarence to learn more about the pies from owner Brian Thomas, whose family started the bakery in 1976. Originally a wholesale operation baking shortbread, the retail location celebrates its five-year anniversary this month and the time chicken pot pies arrived on the scene.

      What prompted the bakery to make them?

      I had ordered chicken pot pie from Harry & David and was very disappointed, said Thomas.

      Thomas set out to create his own version, using his mom, Paulas, recipe.

      The traditional chicken pot pie is filled with white meat chicken, peas, carrots and a rich cream sauce made with heavy cream.

      We dont skimp or cut costs, said Thomas. The crust is a lard-based dough, giving it a silky, light texture that melts in the mouth.

      McDuffies pies are delicious with a great chicken flavor and slight sweetness from the peas and carrots, all in a light cream sauce. No added salt either.

      We used to add baby chicks too, but my one co-worker refused one day and we just stopped, she laughed.

      The 15 Best Places For Chicken Pot Pie In New York City

      Douglas Elliman: A high-end restaurant offering a unique take on American home cooking. We love how the fireplace adds a cozy and comfortable feel. Go with friends, and be sure to order the Chicken Pot Pie!

      Andrew Flicker: Chicken Pot Pie is awesome ! Grilled/roasted squid starter small but tasty. Well crafted drinks

      Cihan Ergur: Biscuits, I could eat tens of them.. Chicken pot pie & fries is a must! Ask for a table near fire place and oh they’re not allow you to instagram your meal, YES..!!

      Nat Harward: Chicken Pot Pie: “Forget the brunch rush at this friendly neighborhood spot and go straight for the main attraction: a creamy, dreamy, chicken pot pie of your very own.”Read more.

      Annie Matt: great for brunch! Amazing biscuits and for dinner their chicken pot pie is a day maker.

      Robert Gaal: A good selection of beers, corn bread for the table, chicken pot pie, a killer fish of the day always. Nuff said.

      Misha M: Chicken Pot Pie is a warm party in your belly…

      Megan Hodges: Try the fries with curry sauce! Excellent! I love the chicken pot pie, but FYI it has bacon in it.

      Jamie Y: Great food. Love the chicken pot pie. And steak. And the ladies who work here are lovely.

      Chelsea Dahl: Get the chicken pot pie it is INCREDIBLE

      Mallory Zumbach: You can’t go wrong with the mac and cheese or the chicken pot pie– great comfort food! I’m partial to their brussel sprouts as a side, and Friday’s special of the day, the lobster roll.

      Read Also: Chocolate Covered Key Lime Pie On A Stick

      Best Chicken Pot Pie In New York City

      There is plenty of Best Chicken Pot Pie In New York City, but it is very difficult to find the Best Chicken Pot Pie In New York City. Below we have compiled a list of the Top 10 Best Chicken Pot Pie In New York City.

      Our team has done the research and found only the Best Chicken Pot Pie In New York City!

      Top 10 Best Chicken Pot Pie In New York City

      Others Will See How You Vote

      Chicken Pot Pie

        My daughter’s first request on a return trip to nyc. She loves getting the chickenpotpie here-it’s huge. We went mid afternoon so it was pretty empty. Prompt and friendly service. Solid chips and fresh guacamole and hamburger on gluten free bread with fries, too. Will return next trip as well!

        Was this review ?

          Also Check: Campbells Chicken Pot Pie With Pie Crust

          Love Chicken Pot Pie Then Head To These 5 Long Island Eateries

          A good chicken pot pie is worth traveling forbut, here on Long Island, you dont have to.

          Chilly weather calls for something warminglike good, old-fashioned chicken pot pie. Photo by Lindsay Morris at Kerbers Farm

          On the coldest of winter days, there are few meals more satisfying than a chicken pot pie. The dish has everything you need to keep the cold at bay: A flaky pastry lid, a gravy-heavy interior, and ample chunks of chicken and vegetable. A good chicken pot pie is worth traveling forbut, here on Long Island, you dont have to. Here are five great chicken pot pies that you should be eating this winter.

          Best Combo: Grandma’s Chicken Soup

          Grandma’s Chicken Soup

          Grandma’s chicken pot pie and soup combos take comfort to the next level.

          • Pies not made in-house

          Grandma’s Chicken Soup is run by a brother and sister team from Boston who were inspired to offer their Bubby’s chicken soup to the whole nation. This classic soup can bring a little ease to everything from a case of the sniffles to a tough breakup. Add chicken pot pie to the mix, and you’ve got one seriously powerful cocktail of comfort.

          Grandma’s pot pie and soup combo includes two, 12-ounce chicken pot pies by Mrs. Budd’s and a half-gallon of Grandma’s chicken soup. You can get your chicken soup with noodles, rice, or matzo balls, orif you need extra carbsnoodles and matzo balls. The chicken pot pies are filled with chicken, peas, and carrots. Grandma’s is great for gifting you can add all kinds of things to this package, like various cakes and other comfort sides like knishes, latkes, grilled cheese kits, and even a teddy bear.

          The chicken soup and pot pie combo costs around $22, plus shipping. Grandma’s ships on Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday. If you want your order sent next day shipping, Grandma’s ships on Thursdays as well. You can also include a custom gift message.

          Don’t Miss: Damn Good Pies Little Rock Arkansas

          The 15 Best Places For Pot Pies In New York City

          Nat Harward: Chicken Pot Pie: “Forget the brunch rush at this friendly neighborhood spot and go straight for the main attraction: a creamy, dreamy, chicken pot pie of your very own.”Read more.

          Morgan Von Steen: Forget the brunch rush at this friendly neighborhood spot and go straight for the main attraction: a creamy, dreamy, chicken pot pie of your very own. – Buzzfeed

          Douglas Elliman: A high-end restaurant offering a unique take on American home cooking. We love how the fireplace adds a cozy and comfortable feel. Go with friends, and be sure to order the Chicken Pot Pie!

          Andrew Flicker: Chicken Pot Pie is awesome ! Grilled/roasted squid starter small but tasty. Well crafted drinks

          Cihan Ergur: Biscuits, I could eat tens of them.. Chicken pot pie & fries is a must! Ask for a table near fire place and oh they’re not allow you to instagram your meal, YES..!!

          Ryan Platner: WOW! Oysters on the half shell, streamed mussels, and chicken pot pie! I said “DAMN”!!!!!

          Jessica Stark: Shareable snacks/apps for a slightly larger group: Hot Potato Chips & Beer Battered String Beans. Dinner: Chicken Pot Pie. Was amazing but LARGE–be prepared to share or take some home!

          Sarah Tierney: Eggs Benedict for breakfast is amazing and the pork chop, chicken pot pie, and gnocchi is pretty great for dinner.

          Joey J: Great burger, Gnocchi, Kale Salad, Burrata, Chicken Pot Pie, Bibbity-Bop :). Everything is great.

          Misha M: Chicken Pot Pie is a warm party in your belly…

          Chicken Pot Pie Delivery In New York City

          How To Make The Best Chicken Pot Pie Ever

          Order Chicken Pot Pie for delivery or pickup from a local restaurant or shop in New York City. Compare your options for Chicken Pot Pie delivery then place your order online.

          Basket Bird Fried Chicken – NYC

          Holiday Pop-Up Shop: Valentine’s Edition

          w4 wings spot

          Joe’s Pizza – Fulton Street – Fidi

          Artichoke Basille’s Pizza – East Village

          Fat Dumpling – E 60th St

          East Village Farm

          6th Ave Wings Spot

          Cheeky’s Cheesesteaks

          Shanghai Dim Sum Garden

          BigApple Farm deli and Grocery

          Village Farm Grocery

          Outlaw Burger

          Potbelly Sandwich Shop

          Duane Reade

          Hale and Hearty Soups – Broad St.

          Sticky’s Finger Joint – Union Sq

          Pret a Manger

          ALPHABET FRESH PIZZA & FRIED CHICKEN

          Gudong Hot Pot Delivery

          Another Wing by DJ Khaled

          The Wing Dynasty

          Don’t Miss: Entenmann’s Coconut Custard Pie

          Stouffer’s Chicken Pot Pie Featured A Crisper Panel At The Top Of Its Tray

          We had high hopes for this next pie as it featured a metallic crisper panel at the top of its box. It was a good size and the second most expensive at $3.99.

          Despite having the crisper panel, it was still cold in the middle after we pulled it out following the six-and-a-half minute cooking and two-minute standing time directions. Once it was popped in for another two minutes, it was ready to go and it was worth the wait.

          It came out looking the best by far and the crust was also by far the best you could literally taste the butter they tucked into the dough.

          The chicken was great, but it did feature fewer veggies than some of the other pies, in our opinion. The gravy was a bit runnier than the Boston Market gravy and we also did not find it super flavorful, although it was pretty welcome with the richness of the crust.

          The Best Chicken Pot Pie In New York City

          Enjoy the best Chicken Pot Pie delivery in New York City with Uber Eats. Enter your address to browse the restaurants and shops offering Chicken Pot Pie delivery near you, then start comparing your options. Once youve placed your Chicken Pot Pie order online or via the Uber Eats app, you can track its arrival.

          You May Like: Key Lime Pie On A Stick Dipped In Chocolate

          How Do I Prevent A Potpie Crust From Getting Soggy

          • For a single-crust pie, prebake the crust before filling.
          • Brush the crust with a beaten egg white. This will help seal the crust and prevent the liquid filling from absorbing into the crust.
          • Pour the filling into the crust while its still hot and immediately place the potpie in the oven. The heat from the filling will help set the crust.
          • Bake the pie on a lower rack in the oven. Since heat is concentrated at the bottom, placing the potpie on the lowest rack ensures the bottom of the crust will bake up crisp and golden brown.

          Best Overall: Great Lakes Pot Pies

          Chicken Pot Pie for 2

          Great Lakes Pot Pies

          Quality ingredients, multiple sizes, and gluten- and dairy-free options: Great Lakes Pot Pies has it all.

          • Gluten- and dairy-free pies available

          • Three-pie minimum

          When Jannie Teitelbaum set out to create a food business, the first thing she did was ask her friends what kind of food they wanted. The answerconvenient meals without processed ingredientsmade Teitelbaum recall the frozen chicken pot pies of her childhood, and she began testing recipes. One day, six months into the process, her son proclaimed her latest chicken pot pie the best he had ever eaten, and Great Lakes Pot Pies was born.

          The company’s chicken pot pies come in three sizes: 5-inch, 9-inch, and a 5-ounce hand pie. Besides chicken, the pot pie contains carrots, celery, onion, peas, and corn, and is seasoned with thyme and just a touch of cayenne pepper to wake up the taste buds. Great Lakes also carries gluten-free and dairy-free chicken pot pies.

          You must order a minimum number of pies to qualify for shipping: 9-inch pies come in packs of three, 5-inch pies in packs of eight, and hand pies in packs of 12. The 9-inch pies sell for about $24 each, 5-inch pies are about $10 each, and hand pies are around $7 each. Gluten-free and dairy-free pot pies cost a little more. All pies ship frozen with dry ice, and shipping is extra.

          You May Like: Muslims Bean Pie Recipes

          How To Make Chicken Pot Pie:

          • Melt butter in a large skillet.
          • Add chicken, carrots, celery, and onion.
          • Add salt, garlic powder, dried thyme, and pepper.
          • Cook for 8-10 minutes.
          • Stir in cream until smooth.
          • Stir in chicken broth until smooth.
          • Cook until bubbling and thick.
          • Add peas and parsley to the filling.
          • Cool.
          • Fit the bottom pie crust into a pie plate.
          • Spoon the creamy filling into the bottom crust.
          • Place the top crust over the filling.
          • Seal the edges of the crust and cut slits in the top crust.
          • Place the pie on a baking sheet .
          • Bake.

          Chicken Potpie At Long Island Restaurants: 4 Best Bets

          The homestyle chicken pot pie is served in a buttery puff pastry dome at EAT Gastropub in Oceanside. Credit: Newsday / Joan Reminick

          When it comes to comfort, it’s hard to beat potpie. You know this the moment you pierce the crust, revealing a creamy filling.

          Here are four versions of this American classic, each with its own homestyle appeal.

          By clicking Sign up, you agree to our privacy policy.

          At this race-car-themed restaurant, the smoked turkey potpie with a biscuit topping puts an original twist on the conventional version. $16.95

          40 Peconic Ave., Riverhead, 631-591-3330, joesgarageandgrill.com

          Recommended Reading: Campbells Chicken Pot Pie Sauce

          The 15 Best Places For Pies In New York City

          30/01/2022 ┬ĚPeep at the chicken pot pie bites from Goldberg’s fine foods. Goldbelly even has the family-size chicken pot pie from New York’s famed Gramercy Tavern, and, if you’re feeling extra decadent, the Duck Pie from Momofuku. Prices range from around $70 to about $150. The size and number of pies per order vary.

          How Much Do Chicken Pot Pie Delivery Services Charge

          Love & Best Dishes: Hurry Up Chicken Pot Pie Recipe

          Most of the expense from ordering a chicken pot pie for delivery comes from the shipping. To get chicken pot pies delivered, budget at least $80, although for that price you may be able to get multiple pies. If you want to spend less, local delivery from a place like Boston Market is likely your best option.

          Read Also: Chicken Pot Pie Recipe Campbells

          Popular Recipes

          More Recipes Like This